PC Build Critique Requested

guptasa1

Senior member
Oct 22, 2001
366
0
0
Hey all,

Been planning my new rig for months now...changing...changing again...etc...etc... Finally close to pulling the plug, but should I? I want to note first...this'll be my first new machine (my very first complete build too) in 6 years. I build 'em top of the line and try to get a long life out of them. So I'm not using budget parts here and I understand it's expensive. I'm mostly looking for future-upgradability and as much future-proofing as I can.

Also please note I am planning to use stock air cooling over. I do not overclock (aside from buying pre-OC parts such as video cards). I'm looking for something that runs cool and stable at stock. I want both stability and performance, but emphasis on stability.

I've been waiting and waiting and waiting and am finally at the realization that I can wait forever with something new around the corner or I can just do it. And where it's at right now seems pretty good...or as good as it gets at least.

This rig will be used for work, games, lot of multitasking online, lil multimedia...etc.

Here are the specs I'm thinking about. Criticism/alternatives definitely appreciated, especially about incompatibilities, etc.

Intel Core 2 Extreme Quad QX9650 3.00 GHz 1333 12 MB Cache CPU
- I'm so tempted to wait for the 1600 FSB QX9750, but as I understand it, that's next year, and this looks like a kicker of a processor. Comes with a new stock cooler that looks like it should be decent too.

Gigabyte GA-X38T-DQ6 Motherboard
- Ditto - part of me wants to wait for X48, BUT, since nobody really knows when that is and this supports 1600 FSB, won't that mean it will have full support for 1600 FSB Penryn's later? So essentially, this should be about as good as X48 for my purposes? This thing looks like a serious mobo that supports just about anything, present and future. Any bugs/serious issues/flaws I should be aware of? I know BIOS updates are frequent already - any hardware problems that a BIOS won't be able to fix?

Corsair 4GB (2 x 2GB) XMS3 DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) w/ XMP
- A bit confused about this, but this looks to be my best bet as far as memory right now. FSB 1600 support, Intel XMP technology, heat spreader, and 2GB per chip so I'll leave slots free in the future if I wish to upgrade. Any better fit for me out there? Anyt compatibility issues?

2X Western Digital Raptor X 150 GB SATA 10,000 RPM HDD OEM in RAID 0
- Yes, I know RAID 0 is risky, but this will give me a 300 GB drive, and with frequent sheduled backups, should give me about the best performance I can find on one of this machine's biggest limiting factors.

Western Digital My Book Studio 320GB External HDD
- For said backups. Plan to schedule them automatically for all my important stuff.

Mitsumi Black Floppy/Media Reader
- Might as well. I work with PC's and fixing 'em on the side so might still have to read floppy disks once in a blue moon (even though I can't recall the last time that happened). A built in memory card reader would be nice too.

ASUS Black SATA 20X DVD+/-R DVD Burner
- May as well go SATA, and this supports Lightscribe as well. Plus trust ASUS.

ASUS Black SATA DVD-ROM E616A3T OEM
- Ditto on the SATA as secondary read-only drive.

eVGA GeForce 8800 Ultra Superclocked
- This one is an especially hard choice given the new GT, and I want to wait for the refresh of the GTX/Ultra, but there's no indication of how long that'll be. The GT is just not top of the line (how I wish for a new G92-based killer). At least with eVGA, should a new G92-based monster happen within the next three months, I should be able to step-up. GTS rumors are great, but they're just rumors so far. Also, I was originally going to go SLI. The 680i boards pretty much rule that out (with the stability problems I've read about, simply not comfortable for a long-term machine based on this platform). And frankly I'm getting sick of seeing news stories about 4X (and more) SLI/Xfire. I think I'm firmly in the "Let's stick with one video card and upgrade more frequently" camp at the moment. Even if I wasn't, just not sure X-Fire makes sense right now, plus I don't like the power requirements/heat output of a multi-card solution. So I'm thinking this is my best option.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi XtremeGamer Fatal1ty Pro
- I see they have a PCI-e version now with optical, but I think this PCI version probably fits me better because of the X-RAM and performance whistles. I know Vista has had some compatibility with the X-Fi in the past, but I'm hoping that's getting better now.

Logitech Z-5500 5.1 Speakers
- Seems like a quite good first 5.1 PC system for me. Though figuring out how exactly I'm gonna do 5.1 in my room is going to be a pip, but I think it can be done. =oP

SilverStone TJ09-SW Case
- I keep trying to convince myself to go with a smaller TARDIS-like case that's roomly enough (perhaps a Lian-Li), but people keep convincing me this is one of the ultimate cases out there. So, it may be big, but it looks beauuuutiful. And I think it should keep everything cool. I just may have to put it beside my desk instead of under it... Hah.

3X SilverStone FN121 Fan
- Additional fans for the extra slots my case offers. I may not be overclocking, but I'm a big fan of ample cooling. This should give the case alone five fans plus all the component fans, so I think I should be running nice and cool.

PC Power & Cooling Silencer 750 Crossfire
- Alright, I'll be perfectly blunt. I like the red, and it's one of the best reviewed PSU's to boot. (Actually, I adored the copper, but I'm not seeing that around anymore). I should think 750 watts will be plenty for this system and hopefully future processor, RAM, and single video card upgrades. I'd probably want more if I went SLI (not an option) or CrossFire, but I don't really anticipate doing that. Also, this PSU seems to have a really good reputation. The only thing I don't like about it is that it's not modular, which might mean messier cables. For that reason, I'd consider the Silverstone Modular 750W offering, but I'm thinking the PC&P really is the way to go, and supposedly non-modular's are more solid anyhow (if you believe PCP&P's claims).

APC Back-UPS RS BR1500 LCD
- Love the LCD on this, and I think it should have sufficient power for my needs, hopefully with upgrades in the future as well.

BenQ FP241WZ 24" Monitor
- I wanna go 24" and this really looks like my best option. I was going to go with the Dell WFP2407-HC, but it has bad ghosting issues apparently that haven't been fixed, and I do want to game, so this looks like my best option. HP apparently has one too, but...neh...haven't had good experiences with HP in the past.

Saitek Eclipse II Keyboard
- Looks like my best bet. I want backlit and gaming but still compact. Considered the G15, and it looks very nice, but I think it would just take up too much space. I have one of those desks with a pullout drawer and want to keep the keyboard and mouse on that (29" wide). The new G15 is more compact, but unfortunately it seems impossible to get accurate dimensions on this compared to the Saitek Eclipse II, and I would think from the pics the G15 would STILL have to be larger.

Microsoft Habu Laser Mouse
- I want a mouse that's simple enough (some of these new gaming look too complex), wired, preferably backlit, and comfy. I've always used Microsoft mice, and I like the looks of the Habu, so I'm thinking it may be perfect for me. Other suggestions welcome. Probably Ratpadz XT mousepad to go with it.

Microsoft Windows Vista Ultimate 64-Bit OEM
- May as well go 64-bit, especially with the extra RAM. I know XP is still popular, but the fact is, Vista is maturing, I want to be able to run DX10, and it just seems like this is the only logical choice. I'd love to wait for SP1, but that's going to be a bit yet, and at least a lot of the initial problems are starting to get resolved.

Thanks again all for any/all advice/recommendations!
 

Boyo

Golden Member
Feb 23, 2006
1,406
0
0
top of the line build......people won't respond because they're jealous.....
 

piasabird

Lifer
Feb 6, 2002
17,168
60
91
Some people are preferring the Antec tri-speed fans for this case. It does look like a nice case. Probably looks better in person than in the photos at www.newegg.com. You going to use some LED fans to light it up? The clear fanblades will make for more light inside the case if not.
 

balane

Senior member
Dec 15, 2006
666
0
76
Just a comment on a small issue I recently went through with a piece of hardware you selected.

Get an internal SATA drive for back ups, not an external UPS drive. Not only can you get a bigger drive for the same money but external USB drives absolutely KILL Vista 64 bit boot times. I just sold my WD external and bought an internal SATA drive instead. I'm very glad I did. It will also be faster.

If you must have an external drive then consider a network drive. They attach to your LAN and any PC connected and authorized can gain access.
 

jkresh

Platinum Member
Jun 18, 2001
2,436
0
71
I still would recommend the 8800gt (if you can find one for $300 are less) you can still step up (either to an 8800 ultra or its replacement if its out in 3months) and if takes 4-5 months for the new high end card then you can use the money you saved by not buying the ultra to pay for the new card (resell value for the 8800gt and ultra will probably be fairly similar in a few months).
 

guptasa1

Senior member
Oct 22, 2001
366
0
0
Thanks all for the great responses!

I don't build often, so when I do, I like to go top of the line. This will hopefully last me years with a few upgrades along the way. Like I said, my last machine (GamePC...not built by me) has lasted me 6 years. Granted, it's had a few upgrades along the way, but it's still done very well. I want an experience like that again (maybe not that long, but close).

Some comments:

- I looked at the Antec tri-speed fans. A bit concerned about some not-so-great reviews, but they would look really nice. (I do have an Antec PSU at the moment that's served me well.) I dunno - I haven't really thought about lighting, but I may try to add some at some point. Functionality's more important to me than appearance, though obviously I did get the window and choose a red PSU based on it looking nice. Hmmm. Thanks for the suggestion - I'll consider it. The reason I chose the FN121's is they're what I believe comes with the case (the 2 that are included), so I figured they'd definitely be compatible, and they have good reviews. They aren't fancy and I don't think there's a clear version of that specific fan, but they perform very well I guess. I dunno - I'll give it some more thought. If not in the area of fans, I may employ some other form of lighting. Or maybe just keep the pretty things for when I'm showing it to people under lights. =oP

- Coolermaster Cosmos looks like a very nice case, just not as much my style (I'm running a CoolerMaster now that's been a great case tho'). I've never been a fan of front doors on cases - they just feel odd to me.

- Thanks for the external drive tip. Sounds a little similar to what I do now with an internal secondary (non-RAID) hard drive. The reason I was moving to external was A) I thought it might be a bit safer than an internal drive if something fried the computer and B) I could easily connect it to something else if I ever needed to. Definitely noted about USB - do you know if eSATA (what I'm planning to use) or Firewire have the same issue with Vista 64?

- I definitely see what you're saying about the 8800 GT. Frankly, I'm surprised Ultra prices haven't fallen a lot since it's release. It's very odd to have the choice between a high-priced old card using an old chip that's still the fastest thing available and a new card with a new chip at a moderate price that's not as fast as their old stuff (but also better in some things). GrrR. And it makes matters worse that nobody really knows what nVidia's next move is (though I keep hearing things about a new GTS around the beginning of December that should blow away a GTX and maybe an Ultra...BUT...as far as I know, that's still just rumor). Frustrating! But I see your point about the GT being financially wiser and will take it under consideration - probably won't know for sure what I'm doing with this until I pull the plug because I keep wavering back and forth.

Thanks again all! More suggestions, alternatives, and critiques welcome and appreciated!