When students are failed by their school, who is legally responsible?
Some questions.
If you send your children to public school and they don't learn, is it the schools fault?
Does the government guarantee that your children will learn? Or does the government just guarantee that your children will be 'educated'?
Agree or disagree with the Court's ruling?
What do you think?
Uno
Is a basic education a constitutional right?
And if it is, can the courts enforce it?
These are the questions at the heart of this case, in which the ACLU of Michigan sued Highland Park schools and the state of Michigan, saying students were not taught basic literacy skills.
The Michigan Court of Appeals says the ACLU cannot sue the state and the school district on behalf of students even if those students were abysmally failed.
... 90% of Highland Park students failed reading, math, social studies and science tests...
In their ruling, the courts said:
So the state has a more supervisory, indirect role in a students education, and theyre fine so long as theyre providing schools with the necessary tools which they are, the state argues, because other schools are doing just fine in the same system.
As for the district itself, Jansen says, theres no law that expressly allows a student or their family to sue the district for failing to educate its students.
Some questions.
If you send your children to public school and they don't learn, is it the schools fault?
Does the government guarantee that your children will learn? Or does the government just guarantee that your children will be 'educated'?
Agree or disagree with the Court's ruling?
What do you think?
Uno
