There was a time when a peer reviewed scientific community would have said the earth was flat.
...because there totally were peer-reviewed scientific communities at the time when people thought the world was flat.
i'd lay down twenty bucks on you not even knowing exactly what time period that was- mostly because no one really does. it's left to the vagaries of ancient history. when it certainly WASN'T is the 1490's, when, according to some (you), columbus spoke for every scientist in the world and said the earth was flat. in actuality, cosmographers from the middle ages even knew that the world was a sphere- and this is during one of the darkest times in the history of human learning (slightly behind today, i'd guess).
what's the point of this (other than pointing out the dopeyness of the analogy you tried to make)? that you should leave the science up to the scientists. even if joe schmo thought the earth was flat in 1000 AD, anyone who studied in the proper field knew the truth. you are not in the proper field.
if you want to know something, and there are scientists trained in the field you wish to know about, with observable data and the tools to examine it, you ask them. not rush limbaugh. take your science fail somewhere else.