A friend of mine just assembled a new rig that consists of an Opteron 165, Biostar 6100-M9, 1GB of DDR333 (he used it from a previous build), and an IDE 60GB Maxtor drive 5400RPM (also used from a previous build).
Since he got an Opteron 165, which are known for overclocking well, and his motherboard had overclocking options he decided to overclock. I overclocked my Sempron socket 754 system without any problems to 2.75Ghz so I decided to help him out. Since I was helping him out we didn't do anything stupid like jumping up the CPU frequency too fast, we took it slow. However, even at 230x9, there was stability problems, so we backed it down. Soon after this it wasn't even stable at a little past stock and then there were all sorts of problems with the OS and everything. It turned out his hard drive failed. He replaced it with a Western Digital 80GB IDE drive and everything seems to work fine now.
Now my question is, was it the overclock that caused it to fail or was the hard drive just dieing anyway? Is it safe for him to begin overclocking with the new drive or will the same thing occur?
Since he got an Opteron 165, which are known for overclocking well, and his motherboard had overclocking options he decided to overclock. I overclocked my Sempron socket 754 system without any problems to 2.75Ghz so I decided to help him out. Since I was helping him out we didn't do anything stupid like jumping up the CPU frequency too fast, we took it slow. However, even at 230x9, there was stability problems, so we backed it down. Soon after this it wasn't even stable at a little past stock and then there were all sorts of problems with the OS and everything. It turned out his hard drive failed. He replaced it with a Western Digital 80GB IDE drive and everything seems to work fine now.
Now my question is, was it the overclock that caused it to fail or was the hard drive just dieing anyway? Is it safe for him to begin overclocking with the new drive or will the same thing occur?