• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

OOoooops, physics demo goes bad

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Okay...
So, in physics class, I'm doing my end of the year labs. Kids have already met the lab requirements, so the labs are completely fun, and mostly for review.

We're doing a lab where they design and test, make modifications (one of the standards is in engineering for science), etc.
They're building rockets, and using a 2 liter bottle for the engine - 1/2 full of water, and at 100psi. Heck of a lot of thrust from those things (video analysis calculated the acceleration at about 100 times the acceleration from gravity)

The conclusion of the lab is a contest - students have to launch a raw egg into the air using their rocket. Whoever's egg stays up the longest, and returns without breaking is the winner.

To make it fair, I added a pressure regulator so no one could exceed 100psi. I was adjusting it during lab time today (and I was also watching a small studyhall). Pumped a bottle up to 100psi with air only. Physics kids could hardly contain the laughter as they knew what a loud bang it was going to make as I launched the empty bottle under a desk. They knew the studyhall kids would jump out of their seats. (and, they did)

Well, now, imagine propelling an empty 2 liter bottle through the bottom of a desk. (I had it under a desk to avoid damaging the ceiling tiles.).

You read that right... THROUGH the bottom of the desk. The bottom part is made of plywood and has a cubbyhole for books. The 2 liter bottle went THROUGH the plywood, splinters and pieces of wood exploded out of the desk. Empty 2-liter bottle.

So, I pointed out to my students that someone mentioned in class the video of the idiots mixing alcohol and ammonia in a 2 liter bottle and it exploding in the kids hand. I pointed out that suppose they threw it, it hit the ground, and the cap broke off instead - it could propel the 2 liter bottle right into their skulls. I think some of the kids thought the video was a great idea beforehand (assuming it didn't burst in your hand.) I think afterward, they saw how dangerous the pressure actually is.

btw, I had always wanted to see a CO2 tank get it's valve-stem piece knocked off, which allegedly would propel it through a cinderblock wall. I really don't need to see that happen anymore, now that I've propelled an EMPTY PLASTIC 2 liter bottle through plywood!! (albeit only 3 plies, but really... wow.)
 
I've always wanted ot take one of the oxygen bottles used in oxy-actelyne torches (The big ones) and whack the vavle off. Course, the fear of putting a 100 pound steel bottle through some guys car, making a 8 inch hole in his chest cavity and then shooting off into the distance has always kept me from trying.....
 
Originally posted by: TheBoyBlunder
:camera:'s?

/obligatory

I'll second that 😀
I've been curious about seeing the valve get knocked off a scuba tank also ... those things have some ungodly pressure in them.
 
The sad thing is, I know exactly the kind of desk you're talking about. We had them when I was in HS 4-8 years ago. I remember making rockets out of 2 litre pop bottles for shop class in the 7th grade. They had to carry an egg with them and not break it. I fashioned a nose cone out of scrap metal for mine. The thing burried itself in the ground when it came back. 😀

ZV
 
Originally posted by: Shockwave
I've always wanted ot take one of the oxygen bottles used in oxy-actelyne torches (The big ones) and whack the vavle off. Course, the fear of putting a 100 pound steel bottle through some guys car, making a 8 inch hole in his chest cavity and then shooting off into the distance has always kept me from trying.....
I watch that happen, well sort of.

I was working in my grandfather shop one day when a mechanic decided to weld a fuel tank to repair a rusted out section. As this skilled craftsman was heating the metal to being welding the residual fuel explodes launching this guy into the shop wall and the tank into the torches. The blast knock the gas tanks, for the torch, over and broke the chain keeping them in the cart. When the oxygen tank hit the floor the valve snapped of and pure oxygen was expelled out of the tank igniting from the exposed flame at the end of the welding tip. The tank took off like a torpedo underneath a car ripping the exhaust off before blasting though the opposite wall and into a cornfield. After the fire was put out, the dust settle and the guy checked we were all glad to be alive. Well except for the guy that caused all of this, he was fired on the spot by my grandfather. I was twelve at the time at thought it was the coolest thing I ever saw, and sometimes still do. 😉
 
Originally posted by: Quixfire
Originally posted by: Shockwave
I've always wanted ot take one of the oxygen bottles used in oxy-actelyne torches (The big ones) and whack the vavle off. Course, the fear of putting a 100 pound steel bottle through some guys car, making a 8 inch hole in his chest cavity and then shooting off into the distance has always kept me from trying.....
I watch that happen, well sort of.

I was working in my grandfather shop one day when a mechanic decided to weld a fuel tank to repair a rusted out section. As this skilled craftsman was heating the metal to being welding the residual fuel explodes launching this guy into the shop wall and the tank into the torches. The blast knock the gas tanks, for the torch, over and broke the chain keeping them in the cart. When the oxygen tank hit the floor the valve snapped of and pure oxygen was expelled out of the tank igniting from the exposed flame at the end of the welding tip. The tank took off like a torpedo underneath a car ripping the exhaust off before blasting though the opposite wall and into a cornfield. After the fire was put out, the dust settle and the guy checked we were all glad to be alive. Well except for the guy that caused all of this, he was fired on the spot by my grandfather. I was twelve at the time at thought it was the coolest thing I ever saw, and sometimes still do. 😉
Maybe I should re-think my plans to come to you for help putting that transmission cooler on my car... 😛

ZV
 
Originally posted by: Quixfire
Originally posted by: Shockwave
I've always wanted ot take one of the oxygen bottles used in oxy-actelyne torches (The big ones) and whack the vavle off. Course, the fear of putting a 100 pound steel bottle through some guys car, making a 8 inch hole in his chest cavity and then shooting off into the distance has always kept me from trying.....
I watch that happen, well sort of.

I was working in my grandfather shop one day when a mechanic decided to weld a fuel tank to repair a rusted out section. As this skilled craftsman was heating the metal to being welding the residual fuel explodes launching this guy into the shop wall and the tank into the torches. The blast knock the gas tanks, for the torch, over and broke the chain keeping them in the cart. When the oxygen tank hit the floor the valve snapped of and pure oxygen was expelled out of the tank igniting from the exposed flame at the end of the welding tip. The tank took off like a torpedo underneath a car ripping the exhaust off before blasting though the opposite wall and into a cornfield. After the fire was put out, the dust settle and the guy checked we were all glad to be alive. Well except for the guy that caused all of this, he was fired on the spot by my grandfather. I was twelve at the time at thought it was the coolest thing I ever saw, and sometimes still do. 😉


there is something you should never ever do. Did he have water running through it at least? (isnt' that one of the things to do when welding a tank?)
 
Reminds me of the time one of my High School Chemistry teachers tried to demonstrate the reaction of potassium metal and water.

Trouble was, he'd accidentally filled the bowl with hydrochloric acid.
 
Originally posted by: Mark R
Reminds me of the time one of my High School Chemistry teachers tried to demonstrate the reaction of potassium metal and water.

Trouble was, he'd accidentally filled the bowl with hydrochloric acid.


How the hell do you accidently put hydrochloric acid in instead of water?
 
Originally posted by: intercollector
Yes, this sounds safe to have highschool kids playing with 100psi plastic bottles.

*runs to the nearest tv to catch the rest of this story on the news*

Actually, the bursting point of most 2 liter bottles is rated above 150 psi. If you do an online search, you'll discover that this project is fairly common. I'll try to get pictures of the bench on Monday... I've already put duct tape over it to keep someone from getting hurt on the slivers of wood protruding out.
 
Originally posted by: cRazYdood
Originally posted by: Mark R
Reminds me of the time one of my High School Chemistry teachers tried to demonstrate the reaction of potassium metal and water.

Trouble was, he'd accidentally filled the bowl with hydrochloric acid.


How the hell do you accidently put hydrochloric acid in instead of water?

Isn't HCl + K -> Fire/Explosion???
 
Back
Top