Originally posted by: VinDSL
Hell, this is going to end up branding Mint users as a bunch of anti-semitic neo-Nazis!
That would be a rather superficial attempt at slander, especially considering
neo-Nazis have been suppressing their Judophobia and cheering on Israel's conquest of Palestine. Granted, even
the Nazis themselves supported the Zionist cause. On the other hand, there are
progressive Jews who condemn Israel's conquest of Palestine, and
some who even go so far as to call for boycotting Israel. Just to drive the point home,
here is a Jewish member of British parliament compairing Israeli's policies to that of Nazis.
Originally posted by: SickBeast
Israel stood by for years while Hamas launched rockets at them.
Rather Israel has been blocading Gaza since they withdrew to it's boarders and holding the rest of Palestinian terrtory under martial law while colonizing it constantly over the course of decades, killing thousands of Palestinians every year, as demonstrated by
the statistics here, click the figures for details.
Originally posted by: SickBeast
That obviously didn't solve the problem and it actually got worse. If someone launched a single rocket into my country, I would expect my military to deal with them clearly and decisively.
And if people were holding your homeland under military occupation while colonizing it out from under you, what would you expect then?
Originally posted by: SickBeast
TBH I have talked to a lot of Arabs and a lot of Jews; I'm Christian so I'm in the middle and relatively objective IMO. From what I have seen, the Arabs openly express hatred for Israel and Jews. The Jews tend to be very reserved about the issue. Some say that Israel should use its military in a serious way, but most seem almost timid and hurt at the fact that all these people have hated on them for so long (and it truly is disgusting).
If I had to pick a side, I would side with the Jews for a number of reasons. This is not a left/right issue as many will make it out to be. It's about the rights of a group of people to live in peace. To me there is a big difference between taking someone's land and blowing yourself up and killing a bunch of people with rockets and grenades. The Arabs are flat-out wrong here.
As RandomStuff went on to explain, both sides are predominately in favor of peaceful resolution, as evidenced by countless polls,
this being one example. It is the extremists on both sides who are flat-out wrong, and ignoring one side while pointing fingers at the other is wrong too.
Originally posted by: SickBeast
IMO there are only a few "solutions" to the problem (and they're not really solutions):
1. The Jews could move away to another land like a bunch of nomads *again* (not easy for them, but perhaps fair to the Palestinians).
2. The Arabs could do #1 (not easy or fair).
3. The Jews could kill all the Arabs (very very bad).
4. The Arabs could kill all the Jews (again, terrible).
Unfortunately there is no easy solution to the problem. The hate runs too deep. Perhaps in a few generations they can make amends.
You left out the two-state solution. It isn't easy or perfect, but the most pragmatic solution available by any reasonable account I've seen. That is what our US government officially endorses as it has for decades, though not so far as to vote in favor if it at the UN as the vast majority of the world does every year. Granted, our media ignores that solution, and it seems most of our population does as well. Why do you ignore it?
Originally posted by: RandomStyuff
...
I'm sorry for this rant, It's a lot of things I think when seeing international reaction to things here in Israel, and I tried to be as unbiased as I could (I personally think I'm more neutral than most) but I know that a bit of bias dripped into it...
I think you made a respectable effort to avoid bias and appreciate your comments and agree with you on much of what you said. However, I do want to point out that this isn't simply an issue of past mistakes but rather the ongoing colonization of the West Bank while your government holds the Palestinian territories and the millions of people living there under it's control. In effect, while Israelis in general want peace, the extremists who run your government, Likud to Labor, while some playing lip service to peace more than others, have been actively wiping Palestine off the map in their quest for "Greater Israel" with settlement population increasing much faster than that of that within Israel and over 40% of the West Bank now under full Israeli control.
As for Egypt and Jordan, their dictators play friendly with Israel, but their populations watching Israel's ongoing conquest of what little is left of Palestine is further radicalising their populations all the time. That simply isn't a sustainable situation in the long run.
Also, the teaching of propoganda is an issue on both sides, see
"Reports on Palestinian kids? hatred grossly exaggerated". From the article, a note on the teaching of propoganda in Israeli textbooks:
If the Palestinians can find room for improvement, so can the Israelis. In "The Arab Image in Hebrew School Textbooks," an article drawing from his study of 124 textbooks, Professor Dan Bar-Tal of Tel Aviv University reports that "over the years, generations of Israeli Jews were taught a negative and often delegitimizing view of Arabs."
Bar-Tal found some positive Arab images. But he reports two major themes of Arab characteristics. One taught "primitiveness, inferiority in comparison to Jews." The other related to "their violence, to characteristics like brutality, untrustworthiness, cruelty, fanaticism, treacherousness and aggressiveness."
Referring to Israeli texts of the '80s and '90s, Bar-Tal reports: "Geography books for the elementary and junior high schools stereotype Arabs negatively, as primitive, dirty, agitated, aggressive, and hostile to Jews ... history books in the elementary schools hardly mention Arabs ... history textbooks of the high schools, the majority of which cover the Arab-Jewish conflict, stereotype the Arabs negatively. Arabs are presented as intransigent and uncompromising."
"The parents and the grandparents of the present generation," says Bar-Tal, "were provided with the same negative image of the Arabs in their school textbooks as we see today, within the context of the prolonged Jewish-Arab conflict. One might add that it takes many years to rewrite school textbooks and a few generations to change the societal beliefs about the stereotyping and delegitimization of the Arabs."
Though it is worth noting that more recently
in Israel has been improving their textbooks, at least outside of ultra-Orthodox circles. Regardless, there is much confusion and animosity on both sides, and the rest of the world needs to take a stand and resolve this conflict, for the sake of the majorities on both sides and the world at large.