NOVA - Jeopardy Watson REMINDER it's on tonight, tuesday and wednesday

Page 5 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,125
30,076
146
I was under the impression you couldn't ring in until the question as read completely.

yeah. the advantage watson has is that he knows the answer before the humans can even process it, and is already searching, compiling, whatever, before the humans get a chance to buzz in.

the text for him is instant--maybe a few milliseconds. the humans would be stupid to not at least take 1 or 2 seconds to go through the question--whether or not they listen to Alex--before they consider timing their buzzer when allowed to do so.

point being, they aren't ever able to "compile" their answer in the same amount of time that Watson has. I think it's a great advantage--but maybe not great enough...


....because humans kick ass.
 

frostedflakes

Diamond Member
Mar 1, 2005
7,925
1
81
I was bored. :D

watson9000.jpg
 

KLin

Lifer
Feb 29, 2000
29,554
158
106
So what's preventing watson from ringing in every question before someone else does, taking a second or so to do a search, then answer the question correctly?
 

MikeMike

Lifer
Feb 6, 2000
45,885
66
91
So what's preventing watson from ringing in every question before someone else does, taking a second or so to do a search, then answer the question correctly?

in jeopardy you MUST wait for the question to be read, and then there is a few millisecond delay prior to being able to push the button... if you push to early, you get locked out for a second or so.
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
96,907
16,174
126
This is some show of ingenuity... I think the humans will do much better in double jeopardy. The "training" of the expert system is hilarious.
 

Rubycon

Madame President
Aug 10, 2005
17,768
485
126
The computer has a huge advantage in reaction time.

This, definitely.

It would be interesting if they put an intentional 1,000 ms delay in the response of Watson's "button".

See how the results may change.

What would be even more interesting if Watson tries to speak up and complain that his button was rigged! :biggrin:

That said a genius knows the answer before the question is asked. ;)
 

MikeMike

Lifer
Feb 6, 2000
45,885
66
91
This, definitely.

It would be interesting if they put an intentional 1,000 ms delay in the response of Watson's "button".

See how the results may change.

What would be even more interesting if Watson tries to speak up and complain that his button was rigged! :biggrin:

there is still a mechanical button for watson to push, so no matter what, there is a delay in the pushing...

it would be interesting to compare the reaction times possible by humans vs that of Watson's mechanical thumb...

light goes on
human processes the light going on
human send signal to thumb to press
thumb presses

light goes on
watson processes the light going on
watson sends signal to "thumb" to press
"thumb" presses...

i really honestly wonder.
 

Rubycon

Madame President
Aug 10, 2005
17,768
485
126
there is still a mechanical button for watson to push, so no matter what, there is a delay in the pushing...

it would be interesting to compare the reaction times possible by humans vs that of Watson's mechanical thumb...

light goes on
human processes the light going on
human send signal to thumb to press
thumb presses

light goes on
watson processes the light going on
watson sends signal to "thumb" to press
"thumb" presses...

i really honestly wonder.

Did not know they had a mechanical interface! :biggrin:

Even still adding delay would make it interesting. :ninja:
 

MikeMike

Lifer
Feb 6, 2000
45,885
66
91
Did not know they had a mechanical interface! :biggrin:

Even still adding delay would make it interesting. :ninja:

but at what point do you make it unfair for the computer?

what is the honest delay in hand-eye coordination?
 

Jeffg010

Diamond Member
Feb 22, 2008
3,435
1
0
WoW some of you are making this way to complicated. We don't know how the question is being feed to Watson. Is the question being feed all at once or is it being feed word by word as Alex is reading it? You guys act like the question is given to Watson before Alex is done reading. They really never explained this.

They explained the button and showed it in use. From what I seen I think I could out click Watson. It did not look like he clicked very fast.

Also it is so easy to see that Watson is programmed to try and get the double Jeopardy first so he will ask for the last 2 questions until it is found. Once it is found he then goes back to the easiest questions in each category. Most people will stay on the same category and work their way down.
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
96,907
16,174
126
WoW some of you are making this way to complicated. We don't know how the question is being feed to Watson. Is the question being feed all at once or is it being feed word by word as Alex is reading it? You guys act like the question is given to Watson before Alex is done reading. They really never explained this.

They explained the button and showed it in use. From what I seen I think I could out click Watson. It did not look like he clicked very fast.

Also it is so easy to see that Watson is programmed to try and get the double Jeopardy first so he will ask for the last 2 questions until it is found. Once it is found he then goes back to the easiest questions in each category. Most people will stay on the same category and work their way down.

they said the question is fed to watson by a person through a text string just as it is being read by Trebek.
 

MikeMike

Lifer
Feb 6, 2000
45,885
66
91
they said the question is fed to watson by a person through a text string just as it is being read by Trebek.

they also stated that Watson has a few separate strategies when attacking the board that it selects before the round.

there are also a few personal experience articles on the web about former contestants playing against Watson when it was in testing/practice...

fast company.com/1726969/how-i-beat-ibms-watson-at-jeopardy-3-times

copy/paste and take out the space, AT doesn't like them thus no link.

re: fast company's links being blocked. It's not Fast Company itself; it's their willingness to let blogger after blogger create pages on their site and post links all over the place. ATOT was being spammed left and right by people selling all sorts of drugs, etc. -DrPizza
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ViRGE

Elite Member, Moderator Emeritus
Oct 9, 1999
31,516
167
106
WoW some of you are making this way to complicated. We don't know how the question is being feed to Watson. Is the question being feed all at once or is it being feed word by word as Alex is reading it? You guys act like the question is given to Watson before Alex is done reading. They really never explained this.

They explained the button and showed it in use. From what I seen I think I could out click Watson. It did not look like he clicked very fast.

Also it is so easy to see that Watson is programmed to try and get the double Jeopardy first so he will ask for the last 2 questions until it is found. Once it is found he then goes back to the easiest questions in each category. Most people will stay on the same category and work their way down.
Watson gets the entire question at the same time the humans do: as soon as it's on the screen. Alex isn't really reading the question to give it to the players (although his inflection on words can be a clue in and of itself), he's reading it for the viewers and to as a mechanism to give the players time to think. Humans and Watsons alike have finished reading the question long before Alex has.
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
96,907
16,174
126
How does watson know that Trebek has finished reading? Alex said Watson can't hear.
 

ViRGE

Elite Member, Moderator Emeritus
Oct 9, 1999
31,516
167
106
How does watson know that Trebek has finished reading? Alex said Watson can't hear.
For the players there's actually a small light in the corner (off-camera) to indicate when they can ring in. I don't believe they've specified how Watson handles it; it's either wired in to Watson, or there's a light sensor watching the light.
 

sdifox

No Lifer
Sep 30, 2005
96,907
16,174
126
For the players there's actually a small light in the corner (off-camera) to indicate when they can ring in. I don't believe they've specified how Watson handles it; it's either wired in to Watson, or there's a light sensor watching the light.

It would be interesting to know. Not being able to incorporate other contestants' wrong answer into the decision matrix is definitely a handicap.

I imagine it is wired in since Watson has answered second (and gave the same answer as human) so it has to be notified somehow.
 

Homerboy

Lifer
Mar 1, 2000
30,859
4,976
126
It would be interesting to know. Not being able to incorporate other contestants' wrong answer into the decision matrix is definitely a handicap.

I imagine it is wired in since Watson has answered second (and gave the same answer as human) so it has to be notified somehow.

It would be interesting to see the engineers' notes on Watson's performance. You KNOW that after that duplicate response, the engineers had egg on their face and will be working on that fix for next year's competition :)

That has to be a lot of "ahhhh crap!" moments as these guys watch. I loved the footage of them watching the trial games like when Watson answered "Milk" to the "non-diary" answer. This seems like it was be an awesomely fun and hard job.