Originally posted by: pm
Originally posted by: munky
What it has is a bunch of fluff features that appeal to the consumer's "fashion gadget" sense. For people who say "Wow, I can have a Facebook App!" when you can easily access FB via a browser, or those amused by games using the motion sensor, without realizing how retarded they look while swinging it like a Wii remote on the subway.
I prefer features that actually make it easier to do what I need, or allow more flexibility. Features like a real keyboard for typing emails, stereo bluetooth so I don't fuss around with headset wires, AF camera with flash and adjustable settings, copy & paste, and most importantly, the freedom to use my phone however I want, on whatever carrier I want, and install whatever app I want. In that regard, the iphone is completely useless to me.
I don't think the first paragraph is true at all. It doesn't have a bunch of fluff features that appeal as a fashion gadget. Like what? As I look over the icons for the alarm clock, the calendar, the maps, the weather, about the only thing that the default iPhone ships with that really matches a fluff feature is the youtube icon. Sure, there's plenty of downloadable fluff stuff, but the iPhone itself having a bunch of fluff features that appeal as fashion...? I don't see it. Virtually nothing that it comes with qualifies as a fluffy fashion features (aside from YouTube) beyond the fact that it's an iPhone which in and of itself makes it a bit of a fluffly fashion feature. As far pointless apps - there's a facebook app for the Blackberry, there's one for Windows Mobile, and there's one for Android.
As far as the second paragraph, I've had an iPhone for over 18 months and I bought it new and I never signed a contract and I've used on a half dozen carriers. It's presently showing "Plus GSM" as it's carrier. Fine, I had to hack it... but that took all of 10 minutes and using one of the 3 GUI's out there to unlock an iPhone shouldn't present a technical challenge to pretty much anyone on this forum. My icons are my own - I drew a bunch of them myself - and my iPhone screen is barely recognizable to anyone else with an iPhone after I added all the 3rd party apps off of Cydia to put in Winterboard and everything else I have running. I can put whatever app I want on the phone. And, yeah, it's hacked to do all this too - but that's not a challenge, and it's not a big deal. You could get an iPhone and do it too - anyone can. Then there's the other features - cut 'n paste, stereo bluetooth - those are coming in June. It's likely there'll be a video camera and an auto-focus camera coming in a few months too.
Somehow I'm thinking that even if it was easily available unlocked, and had everything you describe as shortcomings, that you still wouldn't be buying one, Munky. Maybe you'll tell me that I'm way out of line - and if so, I will honestly and sincerely apologize, but I believe the problem you have with them is the same problem that I see lots of others have with them. The real problem with iPhones are, in my opinion, the iPhone owners. Who - in general - are a smug group of happy evangelists who try to convert everyone they meet that they have the greatest communication device known to man - despite the fact that most of the features of their phone were available years ago, and despite the fact that there's a whole host of fundmental issues with the phone (lack of removeable battery, lack of removeable memory, expensive prices, not great battery life, no keyboard). It's like Prius owners - as a group they are generally a really annoying group of people to talk to, they love their cars and they want you to love them too... and if you point out that it looks like a shapeship and drives like a heavy brick, they don't want to hear it. I'm thinking that your problem - and the problem of a lot of people who don't like iPhones has a lot less to do with the device itself and it's capabilities, and a lot more to do with the company that makes it, the image that company projects and the people who buy their stuff and their attitudes towards their Apple gear.
Again, if you think I'm way off or out of line, I will post up a sincere apology.
Patrick Mahoney