New home server OS dilemma and parts

tajmahal24

Junior Member
Nov 8, 2008
3
0
0
I recently had a single 478 motherboard die, and in the process of resolving the problem I ended up building an entire new gaming rig, and buying 2 extra 478 motherboards to re-use some 478 processors. After some research I decided I needed a home server, but I'm having trouble deciding on an OS.

The parts I have put together for the server are as follows
Case: Antec Sonata I with 380W quiet power supply
MB: ASRock P4i65GV 478 motherboard (Intel 865G chipset with integrated Intel graphics, the board has IDE and 2 SATA 1.5 ports, so I could potentially have 4 total HDDs)
CPU: Celeron 1.7 CPU, stock cooler
RAM: Mushkin DDR PC3500 512MB
DVD: old generic IDE drive for loading software
HDDs: 2 x Western Digital Caviar Green WD6400AACS 640GB drives

As a student I was able to dowload a free copy of Windows Server 2008, but I have no experience with servers so it would probably save me many hours worth of time to just spend the $100 and purchase Windows Home Server. I already searched for techniques to set up Server 08 as if it were WHS, but I can't find anything. I know this isn't going to be the most energy efficient server build, but the only parts I had to buy so far were the motherboard for $50 and hard drives for $150. I don't want to spend any more money on RAM, a new CPU, or MB because if I end up spending $450 on parts I might as well save time and buy the HP Mediasmart EX475. If anyone has tried both server OS's I would appreciate your advice.

I will use the server for streaming music but mainly as back up for important school work and digital photos so it shouldn't need to be high performance. I also plan to buy an inexpensive UPS but have not started research yet.
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
Do you have a spare copy or school download of XP? It can share files and create writable folders for backups perfectly well, it just doesn't have the automated features of Windows Home Server.

(Windows 2000 or even 98/ME can do this too.)
 

RebateMonger

Elite Member
Dec 24, 2005
11,586
0
0
I recommend spending the $100 and getting Windows Home Server. The PC that you have available is fine and that's plenty of RAM for WHS.

The automated backups and restores are a great feature. Most of us never have time to make backups and to manage them (i.e. which ones can I safely delete?). WHS takes care of that and displays a little yellow or red icon on all PCs if there's a problem with backups on any PC.