New Car Help/Advice?

TheKub

Golden Member
Oct 2, 2001
1,756
1
0
Ok, here is the story Im in college and my lease is up in a few days (1999 GMC Sonoma reg. cab) and Im looking around for a car to replace it. After looking I have narrowed it down to 2.

1. 2002 Chevy Malibu, nothing outstanding everything I need/want cd power windows/locks/mirrors. After rebates and down payment ~265/mo. for 60mo not bad.

2. 2000 GMC Jimmy, now here it gets different. It is a NEW 2000 a while back someone purchased a Jimmy and whoever was doing the paperwork wrote down the wrong stock number so it was titled but never owned (it was a demo car and has less than 2000 miles). It is an SLS 2 door 4WD with power everything and a the towing package. Base price on the sticker was 25K and 27K with extras. They said make a bid so I went home and found 6 different prices from KellyBB/Edmunds/etc. and they ranged from 12500-17400 (note I looked up prices with lowest miles/best condition/ and all the options I didnt want to play any games) . So I went back and took all 6 and took the average which was ~14500 he went to go ask his manager and came back and said that he turned down 18000 OTD the other day. I told them the most I would even concider was the highest bluebook. I didnt beleive that just a few days ago someone stopped in and made that offer becasue after looking at a different dealership and getting some prices I decided to hop in the Jimmy and try it out and the battery was dead. Also, after comming back they said that I should make a disison soon becasue they had someone comming in to look at it and it was first come first serve. I told them that I would have to think about it and the last figure on the table was $17111.00 plus tax and fees (~$75). Just felt like the obvious selling schemes they couldnt sell the car in 2 years and in the past 3 days they have had 3 people look at it and make bids? sounds curious to me.

NOW!... my question is to anyone but specificly those in the retail car industry. What is the probability of this titleing issues happening and what does that mean about the car Im assuming that the cars resale will be lower because it will have multiple owners. If anyone could verify this and let me know if 17000 is too much and I should try to push for the 15500 (medium bluebook) or is this way to low. I know that the dealer gets money from the mfg for selling it and a few other ways so im not so sure about the "we are loosing $6000" statement they were making. But becasue of the titleing mix up im not sure and I am positive that they really want to get rid of it cause they would have paid the taxes on it twice as far as I know. So please let me know what you think if you drive either of these cars let me know your feelings.

Thanks

ps. please reply as soon as possible becasuse the Malibu is in on the 2002 off a new car rebate thing GM is having and I will have to make the desision in the next day or two. Thanks again!!!
 

Kevin

Diamond Member
Jan 1, 2002
3,995
1
0
Never believe what a car dealership tells you. And never, ever believe them when they say "we're losing _______ on this car." because they are most likely makes much more than that.

Thats what an old friend told me whose dad owned a few dealerships, mainly GM.
 

RossMAN

Grand Nagus
Feb 24, 2000
79,103
462
136
Neither.

The only Chevy I'd ever buy is the Corvette or a Prizm (only because it's essentially a rebadged Toyota Corolla).
 

freebee

Diamond Member
Dec 30, 2000
4,043
0
0
Are you sure its wise to lease a non-luxury car for 60 mo ? (where it will likely be out of warranty.)

I mean your payments are gonna be high too, because its a crappy car with less than stellar resale value.

 

KokomoGST

Diamond Member
Nov 13, 2001
3,758
0
0
Wanna buy a GM car? Pontiac Vibe... (even though the Toyota Matrix has the better options and stuffs)
If you really wanna stick with GM, I'd go for the Envoy since I guessing you can't afford a Denali?

Buy a Dodge if you wanna buy American...
 

TheKub

Golden Member
Oct 2, 2001
1,756
1
0
Going with the 60 months was to get the monthly down which is the most important to me over the next few months. But becasue my payment is 260-330 I have no problem putting an extra 50-100 dollars a payment if I have the money for it I just dont want to commit to more than I KNOW I can pay. Hell if I hit a bonus I wouldnt mind putting an extra 500-700 on it. And as for other cars YES I know there is a large following for the toyotas and hondas but at this junction I would like to stick with one of these too.... Im not saying you shouldnt post what you feel is the best buy but I am pretty set at these 2 cars for the moment... and as for an Envoy they run 30k - 35k WAY more than Im going for... technicly yes the Jimmy is almost 30k when it was 2000 but now its not worth that much hence the battle over the price... thanks for your input but keep them comming!!
 

Rallispec

Lifer
Jul 26, 2001
12,375
10
81
What is the warranty like on the jimmy? Will you get the full warranty still?
becuase its theoretically a 'used' car even though its never been owned- you may not be getting the entire warranty.

even still, i would get the malibu- i've heard way to many horror stories about jimmy's. The malibu is a decent car- and 265/mo looks good.
 

TheKub

Golden Member
Oct 2, 2001
1,756
1
0
They said that it has a full warranty. They said that the warranty doesnt start untill the car has been titled and delivered, since it was never delivered the warranty is intact. Of course I will want that in writing :)

 

Thegonagle

Diamond Member
Jun 8, 2000
9,773
0
71
Get the truck. The Malibu is a POS. People will laugh at you. Fewer people will laugh at your Jimmy, unless it's too skinny.

PS, look at the reviews for the Malibu on carreview.com.