new car choice, somewhat after the fact

Status
Not open for further replies.

gorobei

Diamond Member
Jan 7, 2007
4,025
1,525
136
moms car developed an issue, car isnt worth the cost of the repair.
~$19,000 budget, new, very short distance driving no daily commute

if given a choice between
honda fit LX
mazda 3 i hatch
subaru impreza 2.0i sedan

which would you recommend? or any warnings?
 

bryanl

Golden Member
Oct 15, 2006
1,157
8
81
The Mazda 3 will be more comfortable for long commutes. The Fit doesn't have the smoothest ride.
 

NutBucket

Lifer
Aug 30, 2000
27,152
635
126
Where do you live? I agree the Fit is not the best freeway vehicle.

I would replace the Impreza sedan with the hatch though.
 

nedfunnell

Senior member
Nov 14, 2009
372
0
76
How short of a trip? Lots of super-cheap Nissan Leafs coming off lease in good trim levels if that's the only driving she does.
 
Sep 29, 2004
18,656
68
91
My mom is 83. How old is your mom.

My mom has a Rav 4. It's easy for her to get in and out of. And in snow, she can get her car moving. It's actually the perfect car for her. My truck is a PITA for her as is my wife' Prius. The Prious is easier for her though.

Seriously, how old. I doubt someone 80 wants a GMC Yukon or Corvette. And do yyou have to deal with snow?
 

gorobei

Diamond Member
Jan 7, 2007
4,025
1,525
136
west coast, drives mostly for shopping.

bit moot now, i took her to the dealerships and tested the Fit and 3. she wanted to be done with it and went with the 3. got a decent price(bit under kellybluebook) but it wasnt like the salesman had to do much work, as she was fairly intent on buying something that day(spent most of the day as bad cop shooting down excessive options and mentioning how many other test drives we still had to do).

the Fit was too torquey at low revs and would have gotten her in trouble in start/stop situations. that and the honda salesman had no ability to do a cold read on us(i'm pretty sure we dont look like chumps or overly excited impulse shoppers). we asked for a basic quote and indicated we still had other cars to look at. he did the standard 'talk to my manager' bit and came back with full sticker. who the hell is going to jump at that when they have 2 or 3 other places to go?

the impreza was ok, but a little underpowered. but since it was part of the same dealership as the mazda, they werent pushing that hard. the mazda salesman at least went for the 'cutting into their own margins' pitch. he did go the full distance and offered a factory $750 discount for going through mazda's financing department's loan and then paying it off 3 months later to avoid the intrest.

i would have preferred to wait a bit to see if there was something a little taller that she might enjoy, but most of them like the kia soul were overpriced for her taste. she ruled out the prius lines because she's done dealing with hybrid battery packs. i tried to get her to look at the mazda 5 but she had done way more research on the 3. if the CRV, xB, or RAV4 had better safety ratings i would have pushed more for something taller.
 

slugg

Diamond Member
Feb 17, 2002
4,723
80
91
Hey the 3 hatch is pretty nice. Out of the cars that were listed, that would have been my choice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.