Netgear router is so much better than Linksys

Lord Evermore

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 1999
9,558
0
76
Last week when I first tried setting up an Unreal Tournament server, I couldn't find any references for setting up the Linksys cable/DSL router to work properly with it. I think it may have been working, but I wasn't sure. (Logs showed people connecting with odd non-bot names, but I could never see the server in a list.)

I was able to find references online for setting up the Netgear RT314 router to work properly with an UT server though. Since I'd been wanting to get the Netgear for a while anyway, that just became more reason to do so (ignoring the thought that I might just be colocating the server at work one day anyway).

Anyway, I got the RT314 last week at a computer show and hadn't had a chance till today to set it up. I configured it by that wonderful serial port (which meant not having to disconnect my LAN while doing it; console rox), called Mediaone with the new MAC address (that pain blows) and it's working now. It took a total of about 20 minutes. Would have been faster if I'd not been doing it the geeky way and looking at all the settings and stuff and seeing the various ways of setting it up. I also upgraded the firmware while I was at it, which took all of 4 minutes.

I haven't done anything special with it yet, like setting up the UT filters, but right away I like it better for one reason: IRC works better. With the Linksys, every time I tried to connect to an IRC server, I had to wait for 30 seconds for the hostname lookup to timeout. With the Netgear, even though it still can't lookup my hostname (which is probably just due to Mediaone's DNS system and the dynamic IP's), it times out right away and just lets me right in.

Plus all of the extra filter settings and all the control that's available, I just much prefer that sort of thing. The Linksys is perfectly good, and it's cheaper, but for a geek the Netgear is better. I like being able to telnet into the router or console into it.
 

Vrangel

Golden Member
Jan 12, 2000
1,259
0
0
One note about pricing.As you probably know Netgear routers are made by Zyxel.
The original Zyxel Prestige 314 is $145 here.
Routers are identical but Prestige 314 has uplink port (Netgear doesnt).

The only disadvantage of Zyxel/Netgear compared to Linksys is that onboard memory
is only 64kB. So Gamespy doesnt work well. It refreshes 45 servers simultaneously
and quickly overwhelms onboard memory. The workaround is to set Gamespy to refresh
2-5 servers at a time (which makes server updates so much slower of course).

I've heard they solved this problem somehow in 3.21 or 3.23 firmware but havent tried it myself.
 

Lord Evermore

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 1999
9,558
0
76
At times I'm not all that concerned about pricing. This is one of those times. I could have gotten this one cheaper online, but I would have had to wait (of course I did anyway, but that was because I was procrastinating and working on getting my car insured and registered, plus I have the flu).

I don't use GameSpy, so...
 

BoberFett

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
37,562
9
81
I just put a Linksys router on my LAN, and it works quite well. I haven't tried setting up a server yet, but since it's only a matter of forwarding the correct ports, I don't imagine it'd be too difficult. Also, with the latest Linksys firmware, you can forward port ranges instead of single ports. C'est magnifique!

I haven't had the Linksys for too long, so I don't know all it's shortcomings, but so far it seems just fine.
 

Engineer

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
39,230
701
126
I've had the Linksys BEFSR41 (kept it for 6 months), the SMC Baracade (Kept for 1 day) and finally, the Netgear RT314 and couldn't be happier. Yea, the telnet (geek! :p) interface and filter rules are very different (difficult?) to understand compared to the nice Web interfaces of the Linksys and SMC, but the solid connection of the Netgear (51 days straight) compared to the Linksys 2 times per day lockup is enough for me to be a Netgear fan!!! :D

My opinions:

Linksys: Fast and easy to set up, but unstable and quirky on some programs
SMC: Solid and easy to set up but much slower than the other two here (not sure why)
Netgear: Very fast, stable and very adaptable to programs. The telnet interface is one a geek could love :D

My vote: Netgear!

Oh, just for reference, I'm on @home cable.

Great day and Happy Holidays all :D
 

Vrangel

Golden Member
Jan 12, 2000
1,259
0
0
Indeed Netgear/Zyxel 314 is a better choice in terms of WAN/LAN throughput.
Linksys provides 3Mbpps, Netgear/Zyxel more than 5Mbps.
(Both are fast enough for most people, but I actually do have 5Mbps connection).

EDIT: OptimumOnline cable. :cool:
 

RGN

Diamond Member
Feb 24, 2000
6,623
6
81
I've got the RT311 and is fine.... I've never seen it lock up, it has only been off once because I hit the power switch on my surge supressor! :) But I couln't agree more, its a quality product.