Netbook/notebook suggestion

Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
Will be taking a job in sales that has me out on the "road" (err, subway) quite often, and I will never be around a desk. Mostly office tasks (updating websites, replying to emails, light photoshop work) I have some fairly light notebooks (vostro v13 and hp dm3) but even those light (sub 4lb) notebooks are going to wreck my back.

Here are my requirements:
-Awesome trackpad / keyboard - HATE the one on my vostro v13 and hp.. Awful trackpads - selecting text is almost impossible on my dell, and photoshop work is impossible as well
-Good battery life. Let's say 6 hours as a realistic minimum. Extra battery packs sorta defeats the purpose of getting something light
-Relatively rugged. I'm not saying I need a toughbook, but my MSI wind had keys falling off after 6 months
-As light as possible - around 2.5 pounds would be great
-Screen size is NOT important. I'd rather have moderately powerful and light 10.1 vs. a powerhouse of a 13.3/15"
-Price, sub-$600 if possible but $800 would be my absolute max

Here are a few I've found while researching:

Hp Business netbook 1502 (1503 is coming out)
+Magnesium case
+Doesn't look like a toy
+Decent battery life
-Expensive for an Atom system
-I've had very bad experiences with HP trackpads so I'm a bit wary of buying it blind and no one carriers it locally

Asus thin and light system (U series)
+Good bang for buck
+Good battery life
-May be more computer than I actually need
-Not sure how rugged it is - will it take daily commuting and bumps from subway riders
-Display issues about viewing angles, but that's a minor issue to me
-Trackpad/ keyboard - not many people talk about it

Thinkpad x100e
+Adore thinkpads build quality
+Great keyboard and pointer
+Good price
-AMD mobile processors scare me
-Related to above, battery life is rated at 5 hours but I bet real world will be closer to 3 based on my similarly speced HP DM3

Toshiba Mini
Actually don't know much about it at all, but the reviews are good and the 11+ hour battery life seems impressive.

Thoughts?
 
Last edited:

zod96

Platinum Member
May 28, 2007
2,871
68
91
I'm in the same boat. And after reading tons of reviews I'll probably go with the X100E myself, just because its a thinkpad...
 

JWade

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,273
197
106
www.heatware.com
its a bit heavier, but the latitude 2110 is rugged, can get a 1366x768 screen as an add on option. comes with the atom n470 1.83ghz processor too.

i have the 2100 and it is very nice and sturdy. i get about 5 hours of battery life on the six cell.
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
I'm in the same boat. And after reading tons of reviews I'll probably go with the X100E myself, just because its a thinkpad...

It would be a no brainer if they slapped even a Pentium Dual Core in there, but AMD just scares me. My wife's uses a similar NEO processor and the battery life just isn't good. I doubt AMD even has a speedstep like throttling systems, so it's always running at full speed even unplugged, on an already power hungry platform.
 
Mar 15, 2003
12,668
103
106
its a bit heavier, but the latitude 2110 is rugged, can get a 1366x768 screen as an add on option. comes with the atom n470 1.83ghz processor too.

i have the 2100 and it is very nice and sturdy. i get about 5 hours of battery life on the six cell.

Hows' the trackpad? My dell vostro v13 is a sexy little machine but the buttons on the trackpad are awful - I hold down the button to select text but the mushy mechanism makes selecting more than a few words impossible because the button disengages without reason.
 

JWade

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,273
197
106
www.heatware.com
i never had any issues with the trackpad/buttons. the left/right buttons are below the trackpad and are separate buttons, not on a rocker and not on the same space as the trackpad, they are two separate buttons, which i like, it does make selecting/highlighting easier than when the buttons and trackpad are all one part