• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Need some input on college choices

bobert

Senior member
So I got into all my schools, and I plan on doing Mechanical Engineering(Undergraduate). I am from Texas so I appled to UT Austin and Texas A&M, but I think I might want to stay in the Big Ten: Illinois(Urbana-Champaign), Wisconsin(Madison), Penn State, Purdue, and Ohio State.

Right now it looks like it's narrowed down to Illinois, Wisconsin, and maybe Purdue and UT/A&M.

What input could yall give about these schools?

added poll for more fun!
 
I've got kind of a limited scope as I've never been to any other engineering colleges, but Penn State Erie's program is alright. They've got nice-sized labs - the machine shop I'm in now for a sophomore level class has 3 engine lathes with digital readouts, 3 manual mills, 1 CNC mill, various welding stations, a sheet metal shear, and a thing to bend sheet metal. It's a lab with maybe 12 students. Class sizes are usually fairly small, except for the more general courses like physics and chemistry. They are taught in lecture halls of up to 100 people. Regular classes have ranged from 10 people to 45, with the norm for me being around 30-35.
The teachers are usually interested in helping out, provided you're willing to put some effort in on your side. The people who complain about professors not being helpful are often those who don't pay attention in class. If you show that you're willing to put some time into at least trying to figure out what you're doing, the professor will also be more willing to put forth effort to help out. Like if you come into someone's office for help, and the problem you have would have been addressed if you'd read the chapter like you should have, you won't get much more help than, "It's in the current chapter, come back once you've read it."

Note: Only come to Erie if constant rain, snow, and wind don't bother you. Early in winter there's lake effect snow. It tapers off slightly once Lake Erie's frozen over (yeah, it gets really cold too), but the snow seems to find other sources of moisture from which to form.

I've never seen University Park's campus, so I can't comment on that. I don't care for huge numbers of people, so I never even investigated the possibility of going there.
 
Madison. I'm good friends with a few professors there, seems like a great school. That would have been my pick if i lived in the midwest.
 
I accepted Illinois. It's got the best rep for ME from all of those schools, though Purdue would be a close 2nd.

Purdue is very male centered though. The Male/Female ration is very skewed so the typical college life may be a little different. I have a friend in the CE program at UIUC and he loves it so thats why I decided to go to UIUC for ME.

UIUC for academic reputation

UT Austin/Penn State for party school/social scene
 
I just graduated last May BSME from UIUC so PM me or post here if you have any questions.

In response to mwmorph, Illinois has a plenty fine party scene. Most any Big Ten school is going to. You just have to make friends with non-engineers. Really even that isn't all that important because there actually are a fair amount of cool engineers. Quite a number that outside of class you would have no idea they're in engineering.

One general tip is if you have an idea that you permanently want to live in a certain region, go to school near that region. Most (not all obviously) companies at the career fairs are going to be from a couple hundred mile radius.
 
Originally posted by: bobert
So I got into all my schools, and I plan on doing Mechanical Engineering(Undergraduate). I am from Texas so I appled to UT Austin and Texas A&M, but I think I might want to stay in the Big Ten: Illinois(Urbana-Champaign), Wisconsin(Madison), Penn State, Purdue, and Ohio State.

Right now it looks like it's narrowed down to Illinois, Wisconsin, and maybe Purdue and UT/A&M.

What input could yall give about these schools?

added poll for more fun!

lol...why would you narrow down your school choices based on a athletic conference? nothing wrong with wanting to go out of state, but an athletic conference???
 
IMHO most schools have a party seen if that's your thing. It's just a matter of finding it and at some it's easier than others. I have hit up a few U of I bars and it was a great time.
 
I have visited both Illinois and Wisconsin recently, and my only concerns with Illinois are things to do, other than partying and homework.

My problem with UT Austin is that I'm from Austin and I would prefer to get out and see other places and not stay in Austin my entire life, even though it's a great city.
 
Originally posted by: jaybert
Originally posted by: bobert
So I got into all my schools, and I plan on doing Mechanical Engineering(Undergraduate). I am from Texas so I appled to UT Austin and Texas A&M, but I think I might want to stay in the Big Ten: Illinois(Urbana-Champaign), Wisconsin(Madison), Penn State, Purdue, and Ohio State.

Right now it looks like it's narrowed down to Illinois, Wisconsin, and maybe Purdue and UT/A&M.

What input could yall give about these schools?

added poll for more fun!

lol...why would you narrow down your school choices based on a athletic conference? nothing wrong with wanting to go out of state, but an athletic conference???


It just happens that some of the top schools are in the same conference.... I have many siblings that are engineers that have been to schools in Big Ten and Big 12, and the Big Ten has all the research money. I plan to continue onto graduate school afterwards as well.
 
What's your financial situation like?

Illinois, along with every other big school, has plenty of sports related activities. There are also lots of plays and crap at Krannert if that's your thing. A fair number of concerts come to town.

Besides what else do you need besides partying?
 
I voted for Illionis but if financial support is a factor I'd say UT Austin.
These out of state public schools can be really expensive.
 
Financial situation is not a concern right now. In fact, it will be cheapest(even compared to instate schools) for me to go to Wisconsin because of scholarship money.
 
The big ten happens to have a lot of really good engineering schools. I can't speak too well for mechanical, but I know aerospace pretty well (and they're similar in many aspects). In aerospace,

Illinois, Purdue, UT Austin, and Penn State are some of the best all-around engineering schools in the US. For mechanical I'm sure they are all in the top 15. UW Madison, OSU and A&M are all really good too, though I would say those I listed first are a bit better. There's a good chance that you'll want to change your engineering major to another discipline (like aerospace, which is way cooler 🙂... UW Madison doesn't even have an aerospace engineering program)

Honestly, any one you pick will give you a great education and in my opinion Illinois/Purdue/Austin/PennState are extremely reputable throughout the country in engineering. Because of this, go with one you think you'll like the most.
 
Originally posted by: bobert
Originally posted by: jaybert
Originally posted by: bobert
So I got into all my schools, and I plan on doing Mechanical Engineering(Undergraduate). I am from Texas so I appled to UT Austin and Texas A&M, but I think I might want to stay in the Big Ten: Illinois(Urbana-Champaign), Wisconsin(Madison), Penn State, Purdue, and Ohio State.

Right now it looks like it's narrowed down to Illinois, Wisconsin, and maybe Purdue and UT/A&M.

What input could yall give about these schools?

added poll for more fun!

lol...why would you narrow down your school choices based on a athletic conference? nothing wrong with wanting to go out of state, but an athletic conference???


It just happens that some of the top schools are in the same conference.... I have many siblings that are engineers that have been to schools in Big Ten and Big 12, and the Big Ten has all the research money. I plan to continue onto graduate school afterwards as well.

When I was graduating HS I looked primarily at Big Ten schools (Illinois, Purdue & Michigan). They're all ranked in the top 10 for engineering and very similar IMO in terms of academics. If you got into Purdue and Illinois, I wouldn't consider going to OSU, Penn State or Wisconsin.
 
i hate uiuc for what its worth, heh. But it does have the tops engineering program, and you can party all you want i suppose. My only reccomendation would be to avoid staying at Allen Hall at all costs, that is unless you are a wierdo art/hippie.
 
While I'm not at any of these schools I do have two friends who went to Purdue and one to UW-M.
The Purdue guys say that the party/woman scene can be horrible, and there's not much to do - and classes are competitive and hard.
However if you're in a top school chances are the competitive pressure can be harsh, and to come out a stronger person you just have to live with it.
 
Originally posted by: jiggahertz
Originally posted by: bobert
Originally posted by: jaybert
Originally posted by: bobert
So I got into all my schools, and I plan on doing Mechanical Engineering(Undergraduate). I am from Texas so I appled to UT Austin and Texas A&M, but I think I might want to stay in the Big Ten: Illinois(Urbana-Champaign), Wisconsin(Madison), Penn State, Purdue, and Ohio State.

Right now it looks like it's narrowed down to Illinois, Wisconsin, and maybe Purdue and UT/A&M.

What input could yall give about these schools?

added poll for more fun!

lol...why would you narrow down your school choices based on a athletic conference? nothing wrong with wanting to go out of state, but an athletic conference???


It just happens that some of the top schools are in the same conference.... I have many siblings that are engineers that have been to schools in Big Ten and Big 12, and the Big Ten has all the research money. I plan to continue onto graduate school afterwards as well.

When I was graduating HS I looked primarily at Big Ten schools (Illinois, Purdue & Michigan). They're all ranked in the top 10 for engineering and very similar IMO in terms of academics. If you got into Purdue and Illinois, I wouldn't consider going to OSU, Penn State or Wisconsin.

100% agree. Of the Big Ten schools you listed go Purdue or Illinois. IMHO Illinois has a way nicer campus than Purdue. I've only been to Purdue once but from what I remember it was pretty urban with everything real close together. Illinois is more spread out, lots of green space. And honestly I like the flatland in that area. Summer evenings are beautiful.
 
Originally posted by: ric1287
i hate uiuc for what its worth, heh. But it does have the tops engineering program, and you can party all you want i suppose. My only reccomendation would be to avoid staying at Allen Hall at all costs, that is unless you are a wierdo art/hippie.

LOL OMG YES. Do not stay at Allen!! Really don't say at ISR either. Yes it's the engineering dorm but it's full of WEIRD PEOPLE. Live at the 6-Pack for a year, deal with the distance, get some good friends, and live up closer to Green St the next couple years.
 
Originally posted by: Parasitic
While I'm not at any of these schools I do have two friends who went to Purdue and one to UW-M.
The Purdue guys say that the party/woman scene can be horrible, and there's not much to do - and classes are competitive and hard.
However if you're in a top school chances are the competitive pressure can be harsh, and to come out a stronger person you just have to live with it.

UW friend has no thoughts?

 
I went to Texas A&M. I was admitted to both UT-Austin and A&M from undergrad. Really, I just liked the atmosphere at A&M better, but I had a lot of friends who went to UT, and for awhile I dated a girl there so I was in Austin all the time. I really had a great time at A&M, couldn't have asked for a better college experience. Pretty much everybody there is involved with extracurriculur activities, and College Station is one of the best college towns around..I hear that only Madison is comparable. Of course the frat parties at UT were better, I have to say..depends on where you feel most comfortable between the two schools, both will get you wherever you want to go.

It was 200 miles from home (Dallas) so it wasn't like my parents were showing up all the time either. In fact I probably went home less than my sister did, and she was going to school in Cali.

I was a EE major, the education was good enough to get me into both of my graduate schools with funding - a TA from Georgia Tech, and a top fellowship from UT-Austin. I ended up choosing GT for grad school.

Have you considered where you want to live afterwards? The job prospects will be better if you want to stay in Texas with a degree from one of the Texas schools, especially the Aggie network. Also, do you think you can survive a Wisconsin/Illinois/Indiana winter?
 
they are all equally reputable
but for non-school specific quality of life:
Austin if you like the heat, Madison if you like the cold
 
Back
Top