Need recommendation on Wireless Harddisk-2TB

p1tin

Member
Dec 24, 2007
140
0
76
Hi all,

Request your input on selecting a good 2TB external Hard disk.
It would be better if it can be connected Wirelessly.
Also request your answer on :

a. is it worth it to get a Hard disk with wireless capability ?
b. I personally do not prefer Seagate hard disk because off the 10 Seagate hard disks which I got over 4 years 9 of them failed and the other one got bad sectors.
Also..Reference:
https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-failure-rates-q2-2016/

Toshiba and Hitachi are highly preferred.
 

VirtualLarry

No Lifer
Aug 25, 2001
56,571
10,206
126
Why wireless? If you want a network-capable HDD, do it the RIGHT WAY, and get a small NAS unit (2-bay are relatively inexpensive, and support mirrored RAID-1), and then attach it via Gigabit Ethernet to your wifi router, and then ALL of your PCs, wired, wireless, desktop, laptop, tablet, etc., can ALL access the HDDs in the NAS, at the same time (*).

(*) Ok, some NAS units have a limit on the number of simultaneous logins or accesses. But even my cheapest "Gigabit NAS" (IDE, that was the name on the box), had a limit of 32 users, which is unlikely to be exceeded in a home-user scenario.

Go with QNAP (I own several), or Synology (Also highly-rated). Try to avoid off-brands. Also, I was able to recently pick up a Lenovo / EMC IX2-DL NAS (actually several), "new" (box was opened, missing US plug for AC adapter), for under $100. Those I don't think aren't being made anymore, but they still release firmware updates for them, to fix security bugs (apparently, they still sell the bigger units to businesses). Those are fairly solid units too, they are 2-bay as well.

Or, if you think that you will have bigger needs in the future, go with a 4-bay NAS now, and only populate two bays to start with. (You want mirroring / RAID-1 or RAID-5, if you care about the data on the NAS at all.)

Or, cheaper, just get an external desktop HDD (USB3.0), and plug it into your router, IF your router has USB ports. (Many modern consumer AC-class routers DO.) That is more limited, in terms of cloud features and access controls and security, and multi-user access, and worst of all, no mirroring or data-protection features.

In that case, get some WD EasyStore Desktop External units (if they have a BestBuy in your country, they are only sold there, so far), either a 4TB or an 8TB. If you're getting a two-bay NAS unit, then get two of the 8TB EasyStores, and "shuck" them - remove the internal desktop HDD from the external enclosure, and put both of them in your NAS unit. You can save roughly $100/drive doing it that way. (What I did, incidentally.)

And if you're going to go the router with external drive method, then just connect one of them to a router's USB port, log into your router, and configure the storage section.
 

p1tin

Member
Dec 24, 2007
140
0
76
Wow. Thanks for detailed answer and your effort.
The purchase is going to be done in next few days in US ( Texas , to be exact). I will pass this on to my friend in Texas now. I will ask if there is any clarification or more input needed.
 

VirtualLarry

No Lifer
Aug 25, 2001
56,571
10,206
126
About the only reason to get a "wireless" portable external HDD, is if you are a photographer or business laptop traveller, setting up in a hotel room or some similar place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ranulf