• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Need help evaluating LCD monitors

torpid

Lifer
Hello all,

I have never owned an LCD monitor. I am in major need of help. I really want to reclaim some desk space without sacrificing video quality. I currently own a viewsonic 19" crt and have been quite pleased with it overall.

I have a modest system, Athlon 2400+ with (soon to be) 1.25g of ram and a Radeon 9700 pro.

My inclination is to think that I should get a 19" monitor since I currently play most games at 1280. I had assumed (perhaps wrongly?) that the dell would be a higher native resolution.

Here is what I have discovered:

Newegg has the Viewsonic 191b for $514.99

The 191b appears to have the best response/contrast for the $, but I am unsure about the brightness (both it and the dell list 250 cd/m2). I think it may be a 6 bit panel as well. The specs of relevance are: response time 16ms, contrast ratio 700:1, brightness 250/cdm2.

It also has the 912b for $559.00 I know that this monitor has gotten glowing reviews from the industry. However, I also belive that the 191b was recently upgraded so it could be that its reviews are outdated. I certainly wouldn't mind spending $44 for a better monitor. But I'm not sure about the contrast. 12ms, contrast 450:1, brightness 400 cd/m2. I have no idea still if it is 6 or 8 bit.

Then there's the old standby dell 2001fp for $639.20. It appears to have the worst specs, but then again it is 1 inch larger. 400:1 contrast, 250cd/m2. I have no idea what the response time or native resolution are. It also seems a bit pricey.

So, help me out here folks! Any recommendations of the three? What should I expect to be different? Any others I should consider? (I have already ruled out the ludicrously cheap princetons due to response time).
 
I just picked up an LG L1920P from BestBuy after looking at many 19" LCD's. It was about $600 w/ $150 in mail in rebates. It is one of the nicest monitors I have seen. Other than the Apple displays, it's the only display that has made me consider giving up my 19" Sony Trinitron CRT.
 
Back
Top