Need HD-based MP3 player (with FM tuner) non-Apple recommendation

hkklife

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2003
5,889
0
76
Ok, I am looking for something decidedly non-iPod.

Here are my requirements, in order of importance:

-Mass storage compliant (ie no drivers required-and I'd prefer for the whole volume to be visible in Windows and not have "music" and "data" segments on the HD ala the new Creative players) this is crucial

-FM tuner this is crucial

-20gb or larger capacity, 30gb or larger is ideal.

-Smalllish size (I can handle something a bit larger than an iPod but not tremendously so. I'd like to keep it smaller than a Palm Tungsten E PDA for sure).

-Reliability & a fairly decent UI. I don't want to do anything esoteric with this thing. I also do not care about DRM compliance. I just want something I can rip my music CD collection to and have it play reliably whenever I need it. Not having to wade through dozens of submenus would be nice too.

I figure it'll be used about 60% as an mp3 player and 40% as a portable hard drive to lug big files between home & work and multiple PCs.

Color screen, voice recorder, video capabilities, USB host functionality, USB trickle charging are all nice but not essentials by any means. Price needs to be under $300 for sure, $250 or less would be ideal.

I am currently looking at the iAudio X5 but it unfortunately requires a proprietary connector to sync/charge. If nothing else appears I still may try to go with one of these. Archos' audio players are nice but they seem to all lack FM tuners.

Right now I am leaning towards the iAudio unless something else is on the horizon...but I'd like to get a player within the next month or two.

Any and all advice & recommendations are appreciated!!
 

stardrek

Senior member
Jan 25, 2006
264
0
0
Copied from my post in a previous topic:

I just got a Creative Vision:M and it has a built in tuner, is 30gb, a built in FM tuner (which can record FM transmitions), a voice recorder, and plays movies on its very nice 2.5" color screen, which has 200,000 more colors then the new iPods. The sounds quility is also better then that of the iPods.

Link: http://www.creative.com/products/mp3/zenvisionm/
 

iluvdeal

Golden Member
Nov 22, 1999
1,975
0
76
I just ordered one (Creative Vision:M) a couple days from Crutchfield.com. Used a $50 coupon so total price shipped was $279.99. You might still be able to backorder one for that price.

EDIT: Opps, I read your comment about the Creative players so this player might not appeal to you.
 

hkklife

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2003
5,889
0
76
From what I've read online, the Creative players let you "assign" a portion of the HD to be dedicated for data storage and the rest of the capacity is used for media. Is that about right?

I've currently narrowed it down to the iAudio X5 30gb or the Creative Vision:M.

Any other similar alternate brands/players I've overlooked?

 

hkklife

Diamond Member
Jul 29, 2003
5,889
0
76
Bump? Anything else? It's down to the Cowon X5 or the Creagive Zen Vision now!