• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Need car advice (automotive noob)

AbsoluteParadigm

Senior member
The situation is as such:

One of our two cars, a 1998 Nissan Sentra, was in an accident and it's financially unsound to fix. So the insurance company would be giving us about 3.3k for the car. The Sentra was to be my car after my father leaves the country for business. So, my parents lay the responsibility of getting a new car on me as this new car would essentially be my car in about 4 months, when my father leaves. The 3.3k is to be used for the car whether it is a used or new car. If I choose a used car above 3.3k then my parents are willing to "loan" me the rest. If I choose a new car, the 3.3k would be used as a down payment on the new car.

The Question is:

New Car or Used Car? Any suggestions regard make/model for either a new or used car? I prefer something fuel efficient, reliable, and, ideally, cheap. Styling and power isn't a big factor for me. This would be a daily driver with an automatic transmission since none of my family can drive manual.

I've given some thought to it all and I've come up with some pros and cons for both option, given my limited car knowledge.

NEW CAR
Pros:
More Reliable
Arguablely more fuel efficient

Cons:
More expensive
Monthly payments

USED CAR
Pros:
Cheaper
No Monthly payments

Cons:
Less reliable
Less fuel efficient (maybe)

It might seem a clear-cut case but the job offer is a 6-month contract pending hiring. Ideally, I'd like to buy the car AFTER I have some money in the bank, but the situation forces me to buy a car now. One car servicing three people just isn't going to work.

I've also heard of "Certified Preowned" cars and would like to know what people think of those in general.

I feel like I'm making a big decision with little or no information, so I'm turning to you guys at Anandtech.

Any suggestions, tips, hints, advice, and/or nudge in the right direction would be greatly appreciated.
 
Originally posted by: AbsoluteParadigm
The situation is as such:

One of our two cars, a 1998 Nissan Sentra, was in an accident and it's financially unsound to fix. So the insurance company would be giving us about 3.3k for the car. The Sentra was to be my car after my father leaves the country for business. So, my parents lay the responsibility of getting a new car on me as this new car would essentially be my car in about 4 months, when my father leaves. The 3.3k is to be used for the car whether it is a used or new car. If I choose a used car above 3.3k then my parents are willing to "loan" me the rest. If I choose a new car, the 3.3k would be used as a down payment on the new car.

The Question is:

New Car or Used Car? Any suggestions regard make/model for either a new or used car? I prefer something fuel efficient, reliable, and, ideally, cheap. Styling and power isn't a big factor for me. This would be a daily driver with an automatic transmission since none of my family can drive manual.

I've given some thought to it all and I've come up with some pros and cons for both option, given my limited car knowledge.

NEW CAR
Pros:
More Reliable
Arguablely more fuel efficient

Cons:
More expensive
Monthly payments

USED CAR
Pros:
Cheaper
No Monthly payments

Cons:
Less reliable
Less fuel efficient (maybe)

It might seem a clear-cut case but the job offer is a 6-month contract pending hiring. Ideally, I'd like to buy the car AFTER I have some money in the bank, but the situation forces me to buy a car now. One car servicing three people just isn't going to work.

I've also heard of "Certified Preowned" cars and would like to know what people think of those in general.

I feel like I'm making a big decision with little or no information, so I'm turning to you guys at Anandtech.

Any suggestions, tips, hints, advice, and/or nudge in the right direction would be greatly appreciated.
Especially with the uncertainty of your job situation (and lack of money saved), I would say go used for sure. Having car payments and no job sucks... also keep in mind that your car insurance will be roughly cut in HALF (assuming you're > 25), I learned this when I sold my 2006 truck for a 1997 commuter car. You can get a decent late 90's Toyota/Honda for 5-10K depending on the mileage. In addition, you say a new car is more reliable, but overall it's not going to be that much more reliable other than standard maintenance costs arriving sooner.

 
Best bets for value are smaller 4 cylinder sedans. The Japanese makes go for a premium and it's questionable whether it's worth it.

I would recommend this - 2005 Saturn Ion Level 2 for 9999 or less. They are easily had at that price. Boring but a good value and economical. In '05 they switched away from an Aisin 5 speed auto that was causing problems back to a more trusted but older design GM 4 speed automatic.

example ION

You can find '05 Sentras that fit the bill too.

sentra


The sentras eek out slightly better fuel mileage from their 1.8L than the 2.2L in the Saturn.
 
I'll second the Prizm. It was made by Chevy up through 2002. It is basically a rebadged Toyota Corolla so it is a reliable vehicle. You should be able to find one for a really good price at this point.
 
Thanks for your advice all. I'll take a look at the Prizm.

Sorry Vogel515, but I'm in California.

Regarding buying used cars, is the basic modus operandi just looking through classifieds, speaking with the owners, getting the car checked, running an auto-report, and all that? Am I missing anything?

Edit: Spelling
 
Originally posted by: AbsoluteParadigm
Thanks for your advice all. I'll take a look at the Prizm.

Sorry Vogel515, but I'm in California.

Regarding buying used cars, is the basic modus operandi just looking through classifieds, speaking with the owners, getting the car checked, running an auto-report, and all that? Am I missing anything?

Edit: Spelling

:thumbsup:
 
Originally posted by: Arkaign
Originally posted by: AbsoluteParadigm
Thanks for your advice all. I'll take a look at the Prizm.

Sorry Vogel515, but I'm in California.

Regarding buying used cars, is the basic modus operandi just looking through classifieds, speaking with the owners, getting the car checked, running an auto-report, and all that? Am I missing anything?

Edit: Spelling

:thumbsup:

The only thing I would add is to look up the book value of the car, so you know what it's worth.
 
Back
Top