Need an X58 motherboard recommendation

aka1nas

Diamond Member
Aug 30, 2001
4,335
1
0
Hi all,

I think I've sold the wife on an I7 920 upgrade for my birthday and the motherboard choices are making my head spin a bit. I need an X58 board that meets the following criteria:

- Can take all my GPUs. The GTX 260s are SLI'd and need full x16 slots. I need the 8800GT for my third monitor. I also am doing distributed computing with CUDA right now, so being able to have that third card is a nice bonus.

It's probably not critical for the third slot to have 16 lanes active, but it would be nice for it not be too gimped as I run an app that is PCI-E bandwidth limited on my current setup (Softth). I wouldn't mind the option of doing Tri-SLI later down the road if Nvidia improves their multi-mon support, as it seems to actually scale fairly well with an I7 behind it. Affordable models with the NF200 chip (if there are any) would be a plus.

- Has acceptable overclocking capability. I usually never do anything crazier than high-end air, but I would like to get a decent OC out of this chip. Ideally, I'd want a board that can at least potentially approach 4Ghz with a 920. I don't want to spend $400 on a board, though, and I don't need to set any world records. I spend most of my gaming time playing X3: Terran Conflict, which is both single-threaded and hideously cpu-bound, so I would like to try to get my clock speed up there.

Any CPU cooler recommendations to go with a particular board would be appreciated.

- Supports lots of RAM. I like RAM. I want metric shitloads of it. I definitely want a board with 6 DIMM slots, and I intend to at least eventually fill them all up. Depending on the ETA for semi-affordable 4GB sticks, I may either get 6GB or 12GB now, but I will probably max it out to 24GB once feasible. Most of the X58s seem to be listing as supporting 24GB now, so hopefully this won't be a problem.

- I need at least 6 SATA ports.



What do you guys recommend?

 

ashishmishra

Senior member
Nov 23, 2005
906
0
76
I am quite happy with my MSI x58 PRO (Flashed to x58 Pro SLI).

1. Meets your first criteria (after the Bios flash ;))

2. I am running my 920 at (19x200) and 12GB Supertalent RAM at 1200 7-7-7-21-1T, the board has very stable voltages. However let me say that the CPU plays a much major role this time around than the motherboard, if you have a capable CPU then this board will not hold you back. If you are planning to use a tower air cooler make sure that the northbridge is being cooled either by a spot fan or side case fan. So yes it meets your criteria.

3. Running 12 GB of DDR3 1200 @ 7-7-7-21-1T, but as I stated earlier the clocks and timings that you would be able to achieve depends on the particular memory controller in your cpu. I would think this meets your criteria as well.

4. Not mentioned but the price is just unbeatable.

EDIT: Yes it has 6 SATA ports as well.
 

aka1nas

Diamond Member
Aug 30, 2001
4,335
1
0
Was it the Eclipse model that you flashed the BIOS of? I don't see a Pro SLI board, and the Platinum models don't have a third PCI-E slot.

I'm not very thrilled with the third slot on the Pro and Eclipse being x4, but not seeing a lot of affordable alternatives. The Gigabyte UD5 unfortunately looks like it is actually only x16/x8/x8 when all 3 slots are populated, so that model is out of the running.
 

SirRob

Member
Jun 15, 2003
89
0
66
I have read that a lot of the MSI X58 boards run extremely hot. Any insight from your experiences?
 

jandlecack

Senior member
Apr 25, 2009
244
0
0
Originally posted by: aka1nas
Was it the Eclipse model that you flashed the BIOS of? I don't see a Pro SLI board, and the Platinum models don't have a third PCI-E slot.

I'm not very thrilled with the third slot on the Pro and Eclipse being x4, but not seeing a lot of affordable alternatives. The Gigabyte UD5 unfortunately looks like it is actually only x16/x8/x8 when all 3 slots are populated, so that model is out of the running.

To my knowledge the only current x58 board that supports x16/x16/x16 is the EVGA Classified. And it's EATX so make sure your case supports it. Also, it's pricey.

You will get the best overclocking capabilities from these boards:

ASUS Rampage II Extreme
Gigabyte EX58-UD5 Extreme
ASUS P6T Deluxe
Gigabyte EX58-UD5
EVGA Classified
MSI Eclipse

List in no particular order. They're all pretty good to OC with, but my vote goes to the ROG candidate for obvious reasons. It's an overclockers dream in my opinion. The others are more or less equal.

Also, the Foxconn Bloodrage is out due to various reasons of your choices...but it's a pretty damn good board if you can live with the discrepancies.
 

ashishmishra

Senior member
Nov 23, 2005
906
0
76
Originally posted by: aka1nas
Was it the Eclipse model that you flashed the BIOS of? I don't see a Pro SLI board, and the Platinum models don't have a third PCI-E slot.

I'm not very thrilled with the third slot on the Pro and Eclipse being x4, but not seeing a lot of affordable alternatives. The Gigabyte UD5 unfortunately looks like it is actually only x16/x8/x8 when all 3 slots are populated, so that model is out of the running.

Actually it is funny but I haven't seen the Pro SLI version on sale anywhere either. But it is listed on MSI's website and if you download that BIOS and with a little re-naming ;) it flashes and becomes the x58 PRO SLI.

Tri SLI on this board is not a good idea as you already noticed it is 16x/16x/4x unlike some other boards which do 16x/16x/8x or 16x/16x/16x (eVGA Classified only AFAIK)
 

ashishmishra

Senior member
Nov 23, 2005
906
0
76
Originally posted by: SirRob
I have read that a lot of the MSI X58 boards run extremely hot. Any insight from your experiences?

It is not that bad, I monitored the NB temps using everest and it idles at 71C and loads around 75C. AFAIK all x58 chipsets (default voltage =1.5V) tend to run hot, some less than others.

The NB is rated to run well over 100C but it will never ever get that hot unless you have poor contact or no airflow around the heatsink of the chipset at all. Keep in mind that the stock intel cooler blows air down, this very air most x58 heatsink designs rely on to provide cooling. If you are using some vertical heatpipe cooler like TRUE 120 then make sure that either you have a spot fan (ANTEC sells one) or you have a 120 or 140 mm on the side of your case blowing on the chipset heatsink.
 

F1N3ST

Diamond Member
Nov 9, 2006
3,802
0
76
http://www.newegg.com/Product/...x?Item=N82E16813138136

16 16 4.

I personally love my TPower board....check out XtremeSystems, this board hits higher FSB than most boards including ASUS, GIGABYTE etc..

Its one of the best for OCing.
http://www.xtremesystems.org/f...howthread.php?t=221563
http://www.xtremesystems.org/f...howthread.php?t=207139
Check that out, its nice.

eVGA Classified max I have seen is 238, 14mhz less for like $200 less is a hit I would be willing to take lol.

http://www.biostar.com.tw/app/...r/content.php?S_ID=397

Biostar's site, says SLI supported.
 

aka1nas

Diamond Member
Aug 30, 2001
4,335
1
0
Originally posted by: jandlecack
Originally posted by: aka1nas
Was it the Eclipse model that you flashed the BIOS of? I don't see a Pro SLI board, and the Platinum models don't have a third PCI-E slot.

I'm not very thrilled with the third slot on the Pro and Eclipse being x4, but not seeing a lot of affordable alternatives. The Gigabyte UD5 unfortunately looks like it is actually only x16/x8/x8 when all 3 slots are populated, so that model is out of the running.

To my knowledge the only current x58 board that supports x16/x16/x16 is the EVGA Classified. And it's EATX so make sure your case supports it. Also, it's pricey.

I think you need a board with the NF200 chip to have enough lanes for x16/x16/x16, which is why all those models are so expensive. I'd be fine with x16/x16/x8, I'm just having trouble finding any boards like that as well.