NEC Multisync LCD1700V -- Mini review

tristramshandy

Senior member
Jan 11, 2000
556
0
0
Such as it is: I bought this 17" LCD new as a result of the wheedling Dell customer rep, who explained that the sales department had recently been treated to a new NEC-Mitsu incentives program. I was sceptical -- I had planned to get one of the 17.4" Planars, but the Dell guy pointed out that the Planar's screen was purchased from a separate distributor, and the NECs had a growing reputation for manufacturing near-professional level monitors. So I finally bought it for just over $600 in January.

And I'm glad I did. It is a remarkably clear monitor, despite its only having an analogue connection. For gamers out there, I was very worried that ghosting would be a constant distraction. When I first hooked up the monitor and tested it with Serious Sam, I could see very subtle but tell-tale signs of ghosting. But, believe-it-or-not, after a week of regular play, I can no longer detect the ghosting. I cannot decide whether this is because I've grown used to the monitor or because the electronics have "warmed-up." There are moments when slight disynchronisation between the top and bottom portions of the screen is apparent -- principally in moments of furious swerving action. Still, I was afraid that this would not be able to replace my 19" Samsung 955SL, and it has succeeded with flying colours.

The graphics are magnficently clear and sharp by comparison with the old monitor [Note: I'm using a Gainward GF3]. So anyway, this is a thumbs-up. I imagine the same model can be picked-up now for somewhere in the region of $500. To my mind, that's a superior deal.
 

CanisEstInVia

Senior member
Mar 5, 2001
576
0
0
just thought up some questions for ya...

This monitor would do just fine with dvd movies right? How did that turn out in your testing. I'll only use this computer every-now-and-then so I can deal with the slight ghosting, but the most my dad will strain this monitor is with dvds.

On another note, I dont have a vidcard with dvi (i think? Ati 64mb vivo DDR retail), so getting a DVI lcd would be add lots of costs with another vidcard as well as more for the digital connection. DVI's not really that much different is it? I wouldn't want to spend so much more for it, yet I wouldn't want to spend so much for a monitor and not have it perform like its worth 600dollars, know what I mean? =/? Your advice is needed. Thanks!!!
 

tristramshandy

Senior member
Jan 11, 2000
556
0
0
Hey Canis, I've got this running with PowerDVD and it's wonderful. Note -- you'll see that the resolution of the average DVD (made for televisions) is not nearly as sharp as that of the average computer graphic. However, I get fast, flawless playback with my setup.

Here's a KEY POINT: the LCD1700V ONLY has VGA analog output, which will would just fine with any video card, 'cause that's the standard. This monitor will not work at all with a video card that ONLY uses the new DVI connector (and I don't believe there is such an animal, but I could very well be wrong). Frankly, I think anand's article about DVI said that the ATI cards HAD DVI: DVI Art but I'm too lazy to look too closely.

Good luck!