Narrowed down my search to these two watches within my budget of $250 (though on the Hamilton I'm torn between the Leather Strap or the Bracelet - I could always get the bracelet and buy a leather strap later). Looking for something that's good for a suit, as well as everyday. Already have a nice Victrionox, so I don't want anything too sporty.
Hamilton Jazzmaster (Quartz, Sapphire Crystal, very thin at 7mm)
Same watch on a Bracelet
And the other watch
Bulova (Automatic, Mineral Crystal, high gloss bracelet, thicker & no power reserve)
All three are right about $200-$250