Name the best 939 board under $100.00

Stephan28

Senior member
Feb 25, 2003
266
0
0
I'm driving myself crazy trying to decide on what mobo to get. I doubt I'll ever OC it so that is not really a consideration. I want a good stable board with lots of room for upgradeability.

Ones I keep looking at

ASUS A8N5X
BIOSTAR TForce6100-939
MSI K8NGM2-FID
ASRock 939Dual-SATA2
ASRock 939SLI32-eSATA2 (worried that sli isn't supported because of Nvidia takeover)

Make up my damn mind for me before I go nuts.
 

Stephan28

Senior member
Feb 25, 2003
266
0
0
Originally posted by: pkme2
ASUS too.

Why Asus? Any particular board besides the one I mentioned? Why does NewEgg always say "** This item is warranted through the product manufacturer only.** on the Asus motherboards?!!? That has always left me leary.


 

krotchy

Golden Member
Mar 29, 2006
1,942
0
76
Originally posted by: Stephan28
Originally posted by: pkme2
ASUS too.

Why Asus? Any particular board besides the one I mentioned? Why does NewEgg always say "** This item is warranted through the product manufacturer only.** on the Asus motherboards?!!? That has always left me leary.

Because Asus customer service is excellent, and will send bios chips and RMA boards without much question asking most of the time.
 

dball3

Member
Aug 12, 2005
38
0
0
i have the asrock 939sli32-esata2 and its a very nice board, they have a limited amount of sli as of right now, but in my manual it says it can also run crossfire with the x850, this was before they changed owners. the chipset has heatsinks that work very well and its a really quiet board and i haven't had any issues since i purchased it
 

astrophysics

Member
Feb 10, 2004
81
0
0
I just like to add Asus does replace motherboards without a hassle, but replacing them with working boards is something else.

I had an Asus board die on me, I had two or three replacements shipped to me that did not work at all, I forget how many times I went through RMA'ing the same 'board' now. Needlessly to say after shipping fees I could've just bought a new motherboard.

Asus tech kept insisting it was me who kept killing the boards. After I gave up on RMA, I bought a -refurbished- Abit board off Newegg, something cheap, just to try my luck. It worked fine! I e-mailed the Asus tech and told him what happened, and he had no reply.

Lost a board and 30$~ or so on shipping fees.

I never... ever even consider Asus anymore when purchasing a motherboard.
 

mb103051

Senior member
Oct 27, 2005
280
0
0
asus boards are the finest out for stability and mild to medium o/clocking.3yr warranty and quick replacement if you do get a bad board.
If i were you i would but the asus a8n-e ultra board,it gives you the sata2 option.the a8n5x is the same board but without sata2 and the options that go with the ultra chip.
i went through 3 other ultra boards before buying the asus and what a great board it is.fo instance the layout is perfect,it has mature bios,its stable as a rock,o/clocks surprisingly well and and is as close to a perfect board in function and design as possible.it never crashes,never had a blue screen of death.the only thing ive done is made a modified chipset cooler with the zalman n47 heatsink and put a 10x40mm led fan on it[cost 12.00 total]and its amazing performance really pleases me.im running a 3200 venice e3 @ 2550mhz with 1.375v and corsair xms3200c2 ram @2.5,3,3,7 1T running 1 to 1 with the cpu.its a fast setup and runs cool.I make my living building computers and this setup is the finest rig ive had in many years.it would take alot to get me to get rid of this setup and upgrade to something else.
Now if your not sold on asus ill tell you about some other boards ive built systems on that impressed me.the biostar tforce ultra and sli boards are awsome.i like the tforce sli board alot.many o/clocking options in bios,like dfi kinda.comes with alot of extras too.
the abit kn8 ultra was a good board but layout sucks and its ram picky too moreso than the asus.the asus a8n sli vanilla version and the asus a8nsli premium kick butt boards.dfi ultra d if you know what your doing and have all high end reccomended hardware,very picky board but for max o/clocks its the cats ass.the final board i liked alot is the msi ultra platinum,nice layout and firewire onboard was expensive now like 109.00 or something on newegg.so these should give you something to look at and i know from experience these boards are very good.look around and see which one is the best deal.i know the msi board sold for about 145.00 dollars for a long time and now its cheap in comparison.lots of features with it too.
honestly though my favorite is the asus a8n-e and alot of my customers ask me what would you use if it were your computer.ive built over 20 computers with the a8n-e board and never had a bad board and to this day not 1 failure.same goes for the a8n sli vanilla board no bad ones and no failures.cant beat those odds.had 1 doa biostar and has 2 msi boards fail within 2 months.but all companies will have a bad board go out and its just the law of averages..i dont hold it against any mobo manufacturer,it happens to all of them...........
 

Stephan28

Senior member
Feb 25, 2003
266
0
0
Originally posted by: mb103051
asus boards are the finest out for stability and mild to medium o/clocking.3yr warranty and quick replacement if you do get a bad board.
If i were you i would but the asus a8n-e ultra board,it gives you the sata2 option.the a8n5x is the same board but without sata2 and the options that go with the ultra chip.
i went through 3 other ultra boards before buying the asus and what a great board it is.fo instance the layout is perfect,it has mature bios,its stable as a rock,o/clocks surprisingly well and and is as close to a perfect board in function and design as possible.it never crashes,never had a blue screen of death.the only thing ive done is made a modified chipset cooler with the zalman n47 heatsink and put a 10x40mm led fan on it[cost 12.00 total]and its amazing performance really pleases me.im running a 3200 venice e3 @ 2550mhz with 1.375v and corsair xms3200c2 ram @2.5,3,3,7 1T running 1 to 1 with the cpu.its a fast setup and runs cool.I make my living building computers and this setup is the finest rig ive had in many years.it would take alot to get me to get rid of this setup and upgrade to something else.


Now if your not sold on asus ill tell you about some other boards ive built systems on that impressed me.the biostar tforce ultra and sli boards are awsome.i like the tforce sli board alot.many o/clocking options in bios,like dfi kinda.comes with alot of extras too.
the abit kn8 ultra was a good board but layout sucks and its ram picky too moreso than the asus.the asus a8n sli vanilla version and the asus a8nsli premium kick butt boards.dfi ultra d if you know what your doing and have all high end reccomended hardware,very picky board but for max o/clocks its the cats ass.the final board i liked alot is the msi ultra platinum,nice layout and firewire onboard was expensive now like 109.00 or something on newegg.so these should give you something to look at and i know from experience these boards are very good.look around and see which one is the best deal.i know the msi board sold for about 145.00 dollars for a long time and now its cheap in comparison.lots of features with it too.
honestly though my favorite is the asus a8n-e and alot of my customers ask me what would you use if it were your computer.ive built over 20 computers with the a8n-e board and never had a bad board and to this day not 1 failure.same goes for the a8n sli vanilla board no bad ones and no failures.cant beat those odds.had 1 doa biostar and has 2 msi boards fail within 2 months.but all companies will have a bad board go out and its just the law of averages..i dont hold it against any mobo manufacturer,it happens to all of them...........

Nice reply, thanks for taking your time to let me know your opinions. I will take a closer look at the A8N-E. I did however build a computer once with an ASUS board and had to RMA it (because it would not work....makes me a bit leary) and I exchanged it for a ABIT NF7-S.

 

delco007

Member
Mar 16, 2006
59
0
0
Originally posted by: Stephan28
I'm driving myself crazy trying to decide on what mobo to get. I doubt I'll ever OC it so that is not really a consideration. I want a good stable board with lots of room for upgradeability.

Ones I keep looking at

ASUS A8N5X
BIOSTAR TForce6100-939
MSI K8NGM2-FID
ASRock 939Dual-SATA2
ASRock 939SLI32-eSATA2 (worried that sli isn't supported because of Nvidia takeover)

Make up my damn mind for me before I go nuts.

hey buddy ,
if u r going to be satisfied with onboard grafix solution then as far as i think MSI K8NGM2-FID is best , check this link
http://forums.anandtech.com/messageview.cfm?catid=29&threadid=1803985
but if u r heavily into gaming then i will suggest u to buy a nforce4 ultra based mobo and i m going to advice u to buy ASUS A8NE.i hope it will make things more clear for u
GKS

 

alex123

Member
Apr 7, 2006
77
0
0
I want a good stable board with lots of room for upgradeability.

then you should be looking into AM2 board, because 2007 AMD K8L is going to be AM2. And RAM will eventually be DDR2.

Nevertheless, I am myslef is a happy owner of MSI K8NGM2-FID. Decided not to go with ASUS after having some trouble with (ASUS + Intel Pentium D 820), and after reading THIS thread on Anandtech (they talk about ASUS as well )



 

DidlySquat

Banned
Jun 30, 2005
903
0
0
the biggest letdown was with Asus A8N-SLI deluxe which was the first nforce4 pci-e SLI board out. Supposedly a top of the line product it was really an average product with many bIOS related problems, mediocre overclocking options (joke #1: initially the pci-e was not locked and would change if you overclock the FSB, later this was fixed in a bios revision), and bad layout and design (joke #2: you need to swap out and rotate an add-in daughter board to choose between SLI and single video card modes). Poor quality voltage regulators and noisy and inefficient chipset fan. BIOS revisions which fix very little (some issues have never been fixed) but introduce new problems. Issues with USB ports, doundcard IRQ compatibility and even hard drives. All in all a rather poor experince with a supposedly top of the line board. Asus realized their errors and released a V2 premium boards, but it was too late for all the people who were duped into paying $200+ for this POS. And in the end I guess that was Asus's plan all along - be the first mobo marketed as "high end" despite being hastily engineered, and take in all the eager customer's money. well it worked for them this time, bit for me and many other that's the last time I trust Asus.
 

pkme2

Diamond Member
Sep 30, 2005
3,896
0
0
Originally posted by: Stephan28
Originally posted by: pkme2
ASUS too.

Why Asus? Any particular board besides the one I mentioned? Why does NewEgg always say "** This item is warranted through the product manufacturer only.** on the Asus motherboards?!!? That has always left me leary.

Well I have 3 ASUS mobos and all 3 was bought <$100 on eBay. I've used ABit, and a whole variety of mobos, but ASUS has always made me come back to it. One reason is realiability. You can go to any other mobo, but its ASUS that will make you joyful.
 

emilyek

Senior member
Mar 1, 2005
511
0
0
If I were gambling on a cheap 939 motherboard, I'd go for the TUL ATI xpress200 mobo at Newegg. It looks budget, but the reviewers seem to like it, and it is dirt cheap at $50.

TUL is Powercolor, by the way, the makers of ATI GPUs.
 

Captante

Lifer
Oct 20, 2003
30,342
10,860
136
I've built many systems with Asus boards ...approx 75-80 and I have had a couple issues, one was a Via KT400 (forgot the model) that just refused to install Windows & was swapped for a Gigabyte model instead & the other was a similar RMA debacle to the one experienced by astrophysics in which it took 5 (five!) tries to get my A7VX-E replaced ... they sent doa boards, v1.0 PCB's incapable of 200mhz fsb, a broken board... finally they sent me a brand-new one though & overall I've had great luck with them since.
I currently have the A8N-E myself running my slightly oc'ed Opteron 170 (2.4) & X1900XTX and its rock solid stable... the only thing to watch out for with this board is if you have a BIOS earlier then v1011, it won't recognize certain Seagate SATA hd's. I'm using a Promise 4 port SATA RAID controller with mine, so I never ran into the problem, but if I'd been counting on using the Nvidia RAID controller it would required a BIOS flash to install Windows, not a big deal but annoying... even so, for $90 shipped its a great board.