my unbiased ipod review

sniperruff

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
11,644
2
0
well so i got a free ipod mini (the new one) from citibank for opening the checking account, and here are my impressions:

-appearance- i like the metalic feel of the case. it is also one of the smallest in size (maybe the rio carbon is smaller). overall it looks ok, but it is too common for my taste.

-ease of use- i do like the click wheel to scroll through the list of albums and i like that you can customize the menu, but using the click wheel to adjust volume is somewhat a PITA. they should have added a separate colume button that is adjustable even if the unit is locked. but i like the click wheel in general.

-sound quality- it has preset EQ's, which is ok but i expected better... even my cheap rio forge has a 5-band adjustable EQ! i expected more than this and i am disappointted by the presets. either you get too much bass or not enough. i use the "rock" preset. basically the sound is clear which is good, but it is lacking in bass.

-charging- i think the only charging option is through an USB port is retarded. and even more so since you can't stop it from charging when it's plugged into the computer to transfer some songs. keep charging it every day will kill the battery faster of course.

-file transfer- just disable the AAC option and itunes is easy to use. the ipod can even display some IP3 tags in chinese! nice. full sub2.0 transfer here unlike my rio forge. i have no complains.

-battery life- i get about 12-14 hours with the backlight off with moderate amount of track skipping. nothing close to the 18 hours they claimed. the backlight does look cool, but of course i leave it off at all times.

-headphones- they suck. they are too muddy for my taste and the bass is exaggerated. but then again i hate my sennheiser mx400 too. too bad my koss ksc35 is really opened air, and i broke my sony MDR E888. the combination of the mx400 and ipod gives me a lack of bass and the mid is too high.

***conclusion- overall i'd say the ipod mini is not the perfect mp3 player. the sound quality is only acceptable and the whole charging interface is simply retarded.

but it retails for $199, which is similar to the creative zen micro (which people have reported some problems with it) and maybe the olympus mrobe (which looks ultra slick IMO), and is cheaper than the $250 iriver. i wouldn't buy the carbon because my rio forge is falling apart within 2 months of use but that is just my opinion (the carbon has a 90-day wannary i think?).

so there, it's not that expensive ($199), and the click wheel is truly innovative. the sound quality is not excellent, but then which player is without faults? just buy whatever you like and move on. i plan to keep the ipod mini.
 

sniperruff

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
11,644
2
0
Originally posted by: Kalvin00
wow, this hasn't been done before!

:p

yeah i was thinking it'd be pointless when i was typing. but i was hoping by expressing my opnions, people may realize that the ipod is not really that bad (nor that good).
 

lokiju

Lifer
May 29, 2003
18,526
5
0
If you listen to rock like I do try the Latin setting in the EQ, I completely agree that its nice and clear but almost no bass.

 

dudeman007

Diamond Member
Apr 6, 2004
3,243
0
0
Originally posted by: sniperruff
but it retails for $199, which is similar to the creative zen micro (which people have reported some problems with it)


Uh...that thread doesn't really list problems. It's not like Apple makes perfect IPods all the time either. Pick up a Zen. End of story.
 

upsciLLion

Diamond Member
Feb 21, 2001
5,947
1
81
Your iPod should have come with an AC adapter that you can use to charge the battery. Mine did.
 

sniperruff

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
11,644
2
0
Originally posted by: dudeman007
Originally posted by: sniperruff
but it retails for $199, which is similar to the creative zen micro (which people have reported some problems with it)


Uh...that thread doesn't really list problems. It's not like Apple makes perfect IPods all the time either. Pick up a Zen. End of story.

my point being that people often say that the zen is much better than the ipod mini which is not true. i am not saying the ipod mini is better than the zan micro

and upsciLLion, unfortunately mine is an ipod mini.
 

OulOat

Diamond Member
Aug 8, 2002
5,769
0
0
Originally posted by: upsciLLion
Your iPod should have come with an AC adapter that you can use to charge the battery. Mine did.

He has the ipod mini 2nd gen. I got it from the same deal at citibank. Yeah, the headphones are a major POS. Too big and no bass at all. I would never personally buy the mini. Instead, for 50 bucks more, I would get the regular ipod.
 

dudeman007

Diamond Member
Apr 6, 2004
3,243
0
0
Originally posted by: sniperruff
Originally posted by: dudeman007
Originally posted by: sniperruff
but it retails for $199, which is similar to the creative zen micro (which people have reported some problems with it)


Uh...that thread doesn't really list problems. It's not like Apple makes perfect IPods all the time either. Pick up a Zen. End of story.

my point being that people often say that the zen is much better than the ipod mini which is not true. i am not saying the ipod mini is better than the zan micro

and upsciLLion, unfortunately mine is an ipod mini.

Well I just have to throw this in here. I own a Zen Micro, and it's definitely not because I'm a Creative fanboy, but because I did some research and really the Zen beats the IPod in so many ways. The removable battery and FM radio were enough to win me over. I think the only really good thing about the IPod is itunes.
 

sniperruff

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
11,644
2
0
Originally posted by: dudeman007
Originally posted by: sniperruff
Originally posted by: dudeman007
Originally posted by: sniperruff
but it retails for $199, which is similar to the creative zen micro (which people have reported some problems with it)


Uh...that thread doesn't really list problems. It's not like Apple makes perfect IPods all the time either. Pick up a Zen. End of story.

my point being that people often say that the zen is much better than the ipod mini which is not true. i am not saying the ipod mini is better than the zan micro

and upsciLLion, unfortunately mine is an ipod mini.

Well I just have to throw this in here. I own a Zen Micro, and it's definitely not because I'm a Creative fanboy, but because I did some research and really the Zen beats the IPod in so many ways. The removable battery and FM radio were enough to win me over. I think the only really good thing about the IPod is itunes.

yeah i would love the removable battery but selling the mini just for that reason would be too much trouble. does the creative has adjustable EQ?
 

Gurck

Banned
Mar 16, 2004
12,963
1
0
Originally posted by: dudeman007
I think the only really good thing about the IPod is itunes.
You realize itunes is a free download? personally I hate it and feel that QT, which installs itself with itunes, is malware - but that's beside the point and has been discussed in other threads. My point here is that you don't need to buy an ipod to use itunes.
 

SVT Cobra

Lifer
Mar 29, 2005
13,264
2
0
Originally posted by: dudeman007
Originally posted by: sniperruff
Originally posted by: dudeman007
Originally posted by: sniperruff
but it retails for $199, which is similar to the creative zen micro (which people have reported some problems with it)


Uh...that thread doesn't really list problems. It's not like Apple makes perfect IPods all the time either. Pick up a Zen. End of story.

my point being that people often say that the zen is much better than the ipod mini which is not true. i am not saying the ipod mini is better than the zan micro

and upsciLLion, unfortunately mine is an ipod mini.

Well I just have to throw this in here. I own a Zen Micro, and it's definitely not because I'm a Creative fanboy, but because I did some research and really the Zen beats the IPod in so many ways. The removable battery and FM radio were enough to win me over. I think the only really good thing about the IPod is itunes.



same here, creative's features and pure kickass goodness is what sold me...evben though i usually hate creatives marketing
 

arod

Diamond Member
Sep 26, 2000
4,236
0
76
I know the karma is in a different class but I have been very impressed with mine and for less than the price of a mini you get 4x the space.
 

sniperruff

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
11,644
2
0
Originally posted by: arod
I know the karma is in a different class but I have been very impressed with mine and for less than the price of a mini you get 4x the space.

rio's 90-day warranty really irks me and after my experience with the forge... i'd rather stick with apple creative or iriver...