Memory that's able to run at faster timings is generally more expensive, although with PC133 becoming less common, it's now almost the same price when you buy it online. Your local shop likely doesn't carry memory rated for faster speeds since they can get better bulk pricing on the slower memory, or will gouge you on the price if they do. You probably won't see such a tremendous difference in performance that it would be worth more than a few bucks increase in price.
What you probably want is memory rated for CAS latency 2 (may appear as CL2), which is the fastest that standard SDRAM will be rated for. What you've got is probably CL3.
Compare prices at
Crucial to what you can get locally, if you're in the US. It's good memory, and can be run at faster timings. And the shipping is free, and every time I've ordered, it's gotten to me in less than 20 hours. Use the motherboard selector to make sure you get memory that will be compatible, since the BX chipset doesn't support high-density memory. You can read
this FAQ to get what that means.