All kinda lol in this thread.
Eccos are FTW, I am a shoe kinda guy and they are on my list of top shoes.
What? Eccos aren't even close to the "top". I wouldn't put them in the top20. Poorly made but comfortable doesn't make a good shoe, let alone a top shoe.
My top shoes are...
Peal & Co (Brooks Brothers usually made by Alden or English shoe makers), great deals when on sale.
Allen Edmonds
Gordon Rush (I'll take AE over GR but some GR fit better on me)
I took Johnston Murphy off my list 2 years ago, now it's all trash.
I will take Gordon Rush or Kenneth Cole any day over those, not that Florsheim are bad or anything.
I'll give you Gordon Rush, but never Kenneth Cole. KC is a f'ing waste of time, leather, and money. I've had 3 KC products in my life and I'll never buy one again.
In general, any shoe that's usually around $99 is trash. I have a pair of Bostonians, a pair of Florsheims, and a pair of Rockports, all very poorly made (got them many years ago) and look like crap now. My Bostonians actually had an MDF heel. Yeah, MDF instead of leather. Florsheims cracked despite a lot of care. Rockports' sole split.
You really don't even need to pay all that much more for a really good shoe that'll last you a lifetime. I've got coworkers wearing AE Park Aves they bought in the 80s and they look brand new. You can find those on sale for 250.