my belief in God is wavering...

Page 6 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

KevinF

Senior member
Aug 25, 2000
952
0
0
I believe in God because if there is no God, then the only reason for living is self-fulfillment. I guess you could say I believe in God out of denial that our lives are completely meaningless.

Of course, that's going to make it really interesting when I'm confirmed as a Jew in May and give a speech professing my belief in Judaism.
 

XMan

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
12,513
49
91
Of course, that's going to make it really interesting when I'm confirmed as a Jew in May and give a speech professing my belief in Judaism.

That's interesting . . . I recently found a website which quizzes you as to your personal beliefs and then "matches" you with a religion. According to the site, Reform Judaism is dead-on with how I feel about most things. I'm not going to take the word of a website as far as choosing a religion goes, but I definitely plan to pick up a few books on the topic.
 

Dedpuhl

Lifer
Nov 20, 1999
10,370
0
76


<<

<< I know what you mean, Silveronsilver. I inherited a Guttenberg, but I through it away because of a typo. >>

Talking about typos ;)

However, Silveronsilver is correct. There are many contradictions between the Old and New Testament. Ever wondered why there are at least as many interpretations of the bible as the bible has pages?

By the way, no language can be objective, therefore no text can ever contain an objective view.
>>




You'd think that Jesus would have the clairvoyance to know the Earth was round...
 

dohyun

Senior member
Nov 4, 1999
336
1
0
has anyone read "mere christianity"by c.s. lewis? thats a pretty good book for atheists or agnostics or doubting christians to read.

i encourage you guys to read it, lates.
 

littlegohan

Senior member
Oct 10, 2001
828
0
0


<< after all these years of defending religion and what not, i'm starting to change. i've already thrown out organized religion out as a bunch of crap, although I still believe in God, but i think I only believe because of fear. I suppose that's how it's always been (belief of fear).

do you believe out of fear or what?
>>



just pray

I think the devil is trying to temp you
 

littlegohan

Senior member
Oct 10, 2001
828
0
0


<<

<< Atheism is not simple. It is very complicated. It requires that you answer all the important cosmological and philosophical questions by doing your own research and reasoning. >>



Umm no. I'd say most Athiests are what they are because they don't like having limits put on them. Such as having morals, etc. Being an Athiest can be as simple as saying "I don't see God, so he doesn't exist".

Explain to me how all the matter in the universe came about and i'll become an Athiest.
>>



I agree, the only reason why Atheism is so popular is because ppl dont want to be bouned. By not beliving there is surperme watching over them, they can transgress(drugs,kill,fight,rape,arguing,sex etc) without remorse.

come to think of it, atheist just dont want to have responsibility , thats all
 

Dedpuhl

Lifer
Nov 20, 1999
10,370
0
76
I agree, the only reason why Atheism is so popular is because ppl dont want to be bouned. By not beliving there is surperme watching over them, they can transgress(drugs,kill,fight,rape,arguing,sex etc) without remorse.

Give me a break! Do you know how much fighting, arguing and killing has occured in the name of God? Sure you do, but nobody wants to talk about that.


come to think of it, atheist just dont want to have responsibility , thats all

BLEEDING CHRIST! Why does a "responsible" person need religion?

 

Bobomatic

Senior member
Dec 31, 2001
514
0
0
<< I know what you mean, Silveronsilver. I inherited a Guttenberg, but I through it away because of a typo. >>

Talking about typos

However, Silveronsilver is correct. There are many contradictions between the Old and New Testament. Ever wondered why there are at least as many interpretations of the bible as the bible has pages?

By the way, no language can be objective, therefore no text can ever contain an objective view


can you name specific places where there are contradictions? and because there are many interpritations does that mean it contradicts? If I say you are an idiot , perople can interprit it meaning I know you and you are, or that I am just mad at you, but it still does not contradict. I think in the end you should ultimately decide, and talk to some pastors and some atheists and decide, but I also think you should pray hard.
 
Dec 31, 2001
161
0
0
Atheists do not seek to shun responsibility; at least, not the ones who are truly atheist and not using it as an excuse to perform certain acts (much as religion is used as an excuse in many other matters, including war). Rather, they take upon themselves the ultimate responsibility: Being fully and utterly responsible for EVERYTHING that they do. There's no God to ease the burden, no heavenly salvation to hope for. Just good, honest toil. Yum.

-Forsaken
 

bugsysiegel

Golden Member
Jan 11, 2001
1,213
1
81
"Man would indeed be in a poor way if he had to be restrained by fear of punishment or hope of reward after death."

Einstein


Not sure if that's exaclty the wording, but it's pretty close.
 

TDSLB

Member
Jun 19, 2001
178
0
0
<<If you're believing out of fear then you are believing for the wrong reason. >>

"work out your own salvation with FEAR AND TREMBLING." Quote strate from the Bible. I dont see how believing from fear is wrong. as long as you work the salvation out in your own way. Find what you beileve by reading the word and learning what it says. Dont let some preacher tell you what is wrong and what is write. Find out for yourself.

BTW. Member of the Church of Christ 505 Elms Bulevard Kansas City MO

(No Preacher, self edification)
 

PistachioByAzul

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,132
0
71
I agree, the only reason why Atheism is so popular is because ppl dont want to be bouned. By not beliving there is surperme watching over them, they can transgress(drugs,kill,fight,rape,arguing,sex etc) without remorse.

come to think of it, atheist just dont want to have responsibility , thats all


I think you'd find that most christians engage in the same kind of materialism & hedonism that most atheists do. They just sleep easy about it, content that they will be forgiven.
 

PistachioByAzul

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,132
0
71
I dont see how believing from fear is wrong.


It's like when someone is apologizing for stealing from you, they're only only sorry that they got caught.

This is why conventional religion is such a grand contradiction, everyone is trying to pull a fast one on their god/gods, whether they realize it or not. It's not humanly possible to believe with any kind of purity in intention. So what you're left with when examining why someone is religiously convicted is the situational basis, ie. they were smothered with the ideas from birth, experienced a "miracle" of luck, fear, etc.
 

wQuay

Senior member
Nov 19, 2000
712
0
0


<< I think you'd find that most christians engage in the same kind of materialism & hedonism that most atheists do. They just sleep easy about it, content that they will be forgiven. >>



Sad but true.



<< It's not humanly possible to believe with any kind of purity in intention. >>



Also true. But the end of Christianity is to glorify God by overcoming your sinful nature with the aid of His Holy Spirit.
 

PistachioByAzul

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
5,132
0
71
But the end of Christianity is to glorify God by overcoming your sinful nature with the aid of His Holy Spirit.

By saying that you ignore the billions of people, the trillions (?) throughout history, who don't/didn't know about and don't/didn't believe in your particular Christian god. That is a greater sin than any.
 

Gulzakar

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,074
0
0
Same boat here...I've come to the conclusion that going to a better place is 1% belief 99% action. Do your best to live life without hurting others, you'll probably go to the higher plane. If there is a god, then already knows he's all powerful so why spend all your time convincing him you're "good"? Rather then spend all their time bothering people about why there is only their god, why don't people try and set examples of kindness and friendliness? I don't know, it's a huge subject. I personally just spend my days trying to live on without infringing the basic rights of others. Physically of course, verbally, I'm all ass :)
 

skylark

Senior member
Feb 24, 2001
798
0
0
Dismal:


<< after all these years of defending religion and what not, i'm starting to change. i've already thrown out organized religion out as a bunch of crap, although I still believe in God, but i think I only believe because of fear. I suppose that's how it's always been (belief of fear).

do you believe out of fear or what?
>>



No, my internal knowledge does not have any belief structures anymore. I, or rather my mind operates on a different level. A co-processor (Mindfulness) , to the super-ego that I have learnt to develop, catches the subtleties of thoughts and actions. It will always tell me if I wavered off. That is if I pondered and started to believe the possibilities of whatever (ie: aliens, God, shadow governments), it'll pull me back to a neutral alignment. Or suddenly a rush of irrational emotions (virus cells :D) like fear and anger arises, it [like an anti-body] envelops these emotions; traces the paths to source; I will be aware of what the issue or problem is; I let these emotions relinquish itselves.

Mindfulness is considered "detached awareness" of self. There are like 4 levels of this awareness in jhanas (someone correct me if I'm wrong).

I know that's a mouthful, but it's the best I can describe the formation and contructs of Buddhist psychology and how my awareness operates.

And as to your fear... Your reason could be just a self-manifestation of a deep-seated issue in the subconscious, which you have not delt with properly in your current life. Afterall, the root of our all our emotional stratas is the primal instincts (in the master-ego) of Love and Fear... So to speak. :D

Hotchic:


<< Silverpig, that's where I get to trust in God's justice. Since I believe in a perfect God, that's not hard to do for me.

Side note: An Episcopalian priest I once knew had the theory that people who never had the chance to hear about God went neither to heaven or hell, instead it was "as if they never were."

Something I'm admittedly not qualified to comment on because all I can offer are my personal views, which are proof of nothing.
>>



To believe in the Ultimate Truth that is non-existent? Scary. ..And displacing your denial to see life's injustices for what it is.

...So where do these people go? That theory is incomplete and lacks understanding of other phenomological systems on past lives (clinical hynotherapy, tibetan); samsara (theravadin); and bardo (tibetan).


Anyways.. Since the theme of this thread is about beliefs, here are my last thoughts on them.

Beliefs belong on a hierachy like Maslow's, except I modified it:

1. Self-realization
2. Insight, Wisdom
3. Acknowledgment
4. Beliefs

Yep, it's the lowest, right at the bottom of the conical structure. Self-realization is the highest of illumination.

The first symbolic meaning in this is:

1. The bottom base level (beliefs) is the heaviest of the cone. Heavy means weight. Weight is like density that can weigh a seeker down. the thicker the mass (of beliefs) becomes, the harder it is for the seeker to see with clarity.

2. Acknowledgment is where the seeker slowly relinquishes his/her beliefs, deconstruct (unfetter) its bindings and inflexible paradigms. Here, the person can become aware the ephemeral qualities of beliefs; gain understanding of how our mind functions (ie: ego / super-ego (Freud), duality (Tibetan)); and why we try to self-create internal realities to propagate in the external reality; illusions.

3. Here, the conceptualizations of the previous are realized. This is the sphere of self-actualization. Experience is gained through integrating new external knowledge. A broader perspective on humanity is achieved through practice, inflections, and self-discipline. The person's attitudes will be more light-hearted, compassionate, and loving. He/she moves with the flow of his/her emotional layers with forbearance and acceptance. Becoming anchored in the present moment, the beauty of life becomes alive as if for the first time..

4. The top represents the lightest of mass, the smallest point of energy. Singuarly densed and translucent -- unfettered from all karmic patterns, the mind is luminous. The "bliss of Clear Light" as Tibetan masters call it. The seeker finally ends his/her own strifes, becomes unshakable and enligthened. The transformation of Peace is achieved.


The second symbolic meaning is about brainwave frequencies:

Generally, the bottom is the slowest and largest of waveforms, the top is the fastest and smallest of waveforms. Basically, from bottom to top, the mind is processing quicker, more agile and more reflexive. The brainwaves are being altered permanently to reflect progression through the hierachy.


The third symbolic meaning is materialism and self-possessives:

the bottom presents possessions, the needs and desires [large areas / spacing] of the master-ego. The subconscious impulse to cling and get attached. Beliefs has all of those qualities -- immaterial it is -- but so so real to the mind.

As one nears the top, such possessions and needs diminishes. If the person needs less, he / she becomes lighter in spirit, not held down by the mass of materialistic compulsions.

**Travelling from bottom to top, the area [=possessions] of the conical structure becomes less, that's the idea behind it.


The fourth symbolic meaning is ego super-imposition of self:

The bottom is dark indivisble mass, resides the nature of the master-ego -- unobservable. As the seeker progresses up the cone, its nature becomes indirectly observable through one's thoughts and behaviors. It's like a shadow receding as light illuminates into it. As one reaches the top, the master-ego goes *poof*, extinguished.

You can picture the master-ego climbing the cone like a circle slowly being engulfed by mindfulness [super-ego's co-processor] -- either from the outside, or starting from the middle.

That's how the visualizations appears from the top level pulling down as the bottom level gets pushed up:

Looking from the top [cone]. The spread starts from the middle of the circle [cone].
Looking from the bottom [cone]. The spread starts from the outside of the cirlce[cone].

So what do you have left? The dominance of the super-ego and its co-processor at the top and bottom stratas.


HOOKAY, that's enough of me jibbering, probably fried some people's brain cells now.. :D



Sky.. l.. l agh


EDIT: Argh
 

MF1

Senior member
May 29, 2000
298
1
0


<< I agree, the only reason why Atheism is so popular is because ppl dont want to be bouned. By not beliving there is surperme watching over them, they can transgress(drugs,kill,fight,rape,arguing,sex etc) without remorse.

come to think of it, atheist just dont want to have responsibility , thats all
>>




Woooooo! wake up.

<shaking head in disbelief>
 

wQuay

Senior member
Nov 19, 2000
712
0
0


<< By saying that you ignore the billions of people, the trillions (?) throughout history, who don't/didn't know about and don't/didn't believe in your particular Christian god. That is a greater sin than any. >>



What?
 

HombrePequeno

Diamond Member
Mar 7, 2001
4,657
0
0


<< I dont see how believing from fear is wrong. as long as you work the salvation out in your own way. Find what you beileve by reading the word and learning what it says. Dont let some preacher tell you what is wrong and what is write. Find out for yourself. >>



Believing out of fear is definitely bad. If you're a Chistian you should be a Christian because you love Christ not because you fear going to hell.
 
Jan 12, 2002
131
1
0
God is Santa Claus for adults.

There is a scientific explanation for how Christmas presents end up under the tree (that does not involve Santa Claus) as there is for everything else (that does not involve religion).