• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Mother Stabs Her Two Sons, One Dies. RIGHT DOWN THE STREET FROM ME!!

Amused

Elite Member
What the hell is wrong with people?

Link

Mother charged in son´s death


By PAUL WOOD, MIKE MONSON AND MARY SCHENK
© 2002 THE NEWS-GAZETTE
Published Online March 1, 2002

CHAMPAIGN ? A boy was dead and his brother hospitalized and their mother accused of killing them after they were attacked Thursday in their upscale southwest Champaign neighborhood.

Police responded to a call at 3:56 p.m. at 2804 Cherry Hills Drive.

Adam Feinberg, 10, was pronounced dead at Carle Foundation Hospital, Urbana, at 4:55 p.m. Thursday. Matthew Feinberg, 6, was listed in critical condition there late this morning.

An autopsy was to be done on Adam later today.

They are the children of Dr. Samuel Feinberg and Dr. Ellen Feinberg, 43. Ellen Feinberg was arrested for murder, and taken to the county jail, where she remains on the highest level of supervision today.

"An officer is constantly in front of her door. She's at the satellite in a cell where staff can view her while they're booking people in, in addition to the officer," said Capt. Jim Young, who runs the jail. He said staff mental health counselors have also been called for her. Urbana attorney Steve Beckett has been hired to represent Feinberg.

Neighbor Alan Parker said he watched the woman being subdued on the ground and handcuffed, then saw the younger boy carried out with an oxygen mask on his face. Shortly afterward, the older boy was carried out and paramedics worked on his chest.

Neighbors described the Feinbergs as friendly and quiet members of the southwest Champaign neighborhood.

"They were normal, very nice, the last people you would ever think would have a tragedy like this," Parker said. "The kids do all the normal things kids do."

The father is a surgeon at Christie Clinic. Neighbors said the mother is a pediatrician.

Champaign police used crime scene tape to keep reporters and onlookers a few houses away from the Feinbergs' two-story, tan brick home. Several police and investigators milled about in the street and front yard.

Neighbors said they were stunned by the incident.

Jennifer Burnham, 19, who lives at 2801 Cherry Hills Drive, called the Feinbergs "your average family."

"They went to UI games and hung out. They like to do a lot of activities together. I never would have expected anything like this. I'm still in shock."

She described Ellen Feinberg as "a busy mom" and said she had a number of friends who, like the family, attended the Sinai Temple in Champaign.

"We all visited each other," Burnham said.

"She (Ellen Feinberg) just called me the other day because she needed something for a science project" for Adam.

"This is really scary," Burnham said.

"We've been talking about the Yates case in English class. ... I'm really surprised. I can understand why a mom gets stressed."

Debbie Errede, 2706 Cherry Hills Drive, arrived home at about 5 p.m. and learned of the tragedy from reporters.

"My daughter, Rachel, used to play with Adam. He's a beautiful little boy with blond hair. They (the family) used to go for walks. They were pretty quiet. Very polite," Errede said.

Janet Leroy, who also lives in the same subdivision, has known the Feinbergs for years through their membership at the Sinai Temple.

Leroy said Samuel Feinberg is on the temple board and performs religious circumcisions. Ellen Feinberg, Leroy said, is also very active, serving on the religious education and Holocaust education committees and teaches third grade at the temple.

"She was working on, and it came to fruition Feb. 15, a project where the older kids would lead a service," Leroy said.

She said Ellen Feinberg wanted to see the older children, who had had extensive religious training in preparation for their bar and bat mitzvahs, be able to put that to use.

"She always put her heart into everything," Leroy said, adding that Ellen Feinberg was also a mentor to a child in Champaign.

There were no classes scheduled today for Barkstall Elementary School, where Adam was a fifth-grader. Parent-teacher conferences were canceled.

Parents of students at Barkstall Elementary School and staff were meeting to discuss how to handle the aftermath of the tragedy. Adam was a fifth-grade student there.

 
WITHIN A DAY, SHE'S FOUND UNFIT FOR TRIAL? WTF???


Mom found unfit for trial


By THE NEWS-GAZETTE
© 2002 THE NEWS-GAZETTE
Published Online March 2, 2002



CLICK TO SEE PHOTO
URBANA ? At an arraignment hearing Friday, Judge J.G. Townsend ruled Ellen Feinberg was unfit to stand trial on charges of murder and attempted murder in the stabbing of her sons.
Based on an evaluation by local psychiatrist Lawrence Jeckel, the judge ordered she be placed in a mental health facility for evaluation and treatment until she is fit for trial. Townsend also ordered she be held without bond.
He advised her of the charges ? two counts of first-degree murder for the stabbing death of Adam, 10, and one count of attempted murder for the stabbing of Matthew, 6, who was still listed in critical condition Friday night at Carle Foundation Hospital in Urbana.
Townsend said that if convicted of the murder charge, Ellen Feinberg faces a term of natural life in prison because her son was under the age of 12. The attempted murder charge carries a prison term ranging from six to 30 years.
Jeckel recommended she be placed in the McFarland Mental Health Center in Springfield in a secure setting until she can attain fitness to stand trial. Townsend agreed.
Townsend's ruling on the fitness issue came after a motion was filed by Ellen Feinberg's attorney, Carol Dison, to have her evaluated. With the motion, she filed a letter from Jeckel indicating he determined she was unfit to stand trial.
Friday evening, Champaign County Coroner Roger Swaney's office said preliminary autopsy results showed Adam died as a result of two stab wounds to the chest.
Swaney's office said toxicology studies remain to be done, and an inquest would be scheduled. Champaign County State's Attorney John Piland said late Friday that Champaign police are continuing to investigate the case and gather additional information, but details could probably not be released publicly.
Piland said the next step in the legal proceedings as the charges now stand depends on when it can be determined that Ellen Feinberg is fit to stand trial.
?The Department of Human Services will try to restore her to fitness as soon as possible,? Piland said.
Neighbors of the Feinbergs said Ellen Feinberg is a pediatrician.
According to The Associated Press, the state Department of Professional Regulation did not have a record of a medical license for an Ellen M. Feinberg but did have one for an Ellen M. Hochberg, living at the same address.
Department spokesman Tony Sanders said that license was obtained in July 1990 and changed to inactive, meaning the person could not practice medicine, in July 1999. There was no record of disciplinary action against the license holder.

Therapists: Depression in mothers undertreated
CHAMPAIGN ? Through sleep deprivation, hormonal changes, post-partum depression or underlying mental problems, many women may find mothering young children an overwhelming task at times, therapists say.
Dr. Ellen Feinberg, 43, accused of stabbing her two young sons Thursday, is not the first mother to face a charge of murder.
Two others are prominent in the news now. Andrea Yates, a Texas mother accused of drowning her five children, has pleaded innocent by reason of insanity. Marilyn Lemak, who lived in the Chicago suburbs, was convicted of feeding her three children peanut butter laced with drugs and suffocating them, and awaits sentencing April 8.
It is not even the first time such a case has happened in Champaign-Urbana. Many residents remember with horror the murders of the two toddler sons of Kathleen Johnson of Urbana, who stabbed and mutilated them in 1983.
The legal situation has changed since the 1980s, says Dr. Lawrence Jeckel of Savoy, who testified at Johnson's hearings, and also Friday for Feinberg.
Johnson was found innocent by reason of insanity, noted Jeckel, who said that in fact she was released from a mental facility ?in a matter of a month or two.?
Attorneys for Lemak argue their client had virtually no chance of being judged innocent by reason of insanity under current Illinois statues, calling the laws contradictory and confusing.
Brian Silverman, who was appointed by the court to defend Johnson, said it has never been easy to win an insanity defense.
?That's why it's big news when you hear about it,? he said. ?In most cases, the state has to prove you are guilty. In an insanity defense, you start by admitting guilt.?
Jeckel is ethically bound not to discuss Feinberg's case. He testified Friday that she was unfit to stand trial.
But he vividly remembers the aftermath of Johnson's tragic breakdown in Urbana's housing for married University of Illinois students.
Jeckel believes Johnson suffered from intermittent psychotic disorder, a condition in which a person may be delusional at times, then have periods of seeming normalcy.
He thinks the disorder may have been longstanding in Johnson, and had little or nothing to do with her pregnancies.
Jeckel's report on Ellen Feinberg, which was submitted in Court Friday to support a finding that she was unfit to stand trial, mentioned her ?history of mental illness.?
Jeckel agrees with a nationally recognized expert on mothers and depression, Dr. Diane Sanford, that serious depression in mothers of young children is under-diagnosed and under-treated.
Jeckel said insurance companies keep mental health benefits at 1980s levels out of ?narrow-mindedness and greed.?
?We can do a whole lot better,? he said.
Sanford, an adjunct professor at St. Louis University and author of ?The Post-Partum Survival Guide? said a severe mood disorder has often been misidentified and minimized as ?the baby blues.?
?The baby blues is what most women will experience ? mood changes, crying. Part of it is hormonal, part of it is sleep deprivation. It affects about 85 to 90 percent of young mothers,? she said.
Far more serious is post-partum depression, and a related condition, post-partum psychosis.
?A conservative estimate is 10 to 12 percent of mothers face this type of depression, and some say as high as 20 to 25 percent,? she said.
By a common definition, post-partum depression ends in the first year after labor.
?But it may been that the psychosis developed post-partum, never fully cleared up and continued unrecognized for several years,? Sanford said.
There sometimes are gender differences in family slayings, she said.
Often in news reports of such incidents, men who kill family members then kill themselves, while a woman may survive the attack itself and attempt suicide, or ?suicide by police,? in which a person threatens an officer or encourages the officer to shoot.
?Men and women may have a different kind of response when they become delusional, possibly based on hormones or a function of how they are brought up,? she said.
Champaign County Assistant State's Attorney Elizabeth Dobson said in court that Feinberg called authorities shortly before 4 p.m. Thursday and said ?she had killed her children and wanted to be killed by the police.?
Psychiatrists have testified that Andrea Yates and others have an underlying problem that might be triggered anew by changes, including pregnancy, that move them into a delusional state.
?In my opinion, and not trying to bash other health care practictioners, there are often very clear indicators that someone is becoming delusional, and that person could be treated aggressively with medication or therapy or both, and avert tragedies,? Sanford said.
She said society could begin by not stigmatizing people who seek therapy or medication to help them with mental health problems.

 
Back
Top