Islam is hidden and forbidden. Hidden means that we don’t actually discuss it. We have the hearsay-opinion version of discussion that never talks about the actual motivation of Islam, its doctrine and world view. One of the ways we hide Islam is to not discuss it by diverting the conversation to our flaws, history and faults. It is a “See, we are just as bad or worse, therefore we should talk about our failings, not Islam’s failings.
We should discuss Islam, not ourselves. Another version of this is: “Well the Christians/crusaders did bad things.” This is another way to turn the discussion back to us. Again, what is the motivation of Islam? Why is it always about us? One of the ways that Islam is hidden is the lack of open and free discussion. Talking about Islam is considered a very sensitive subject.
Political correctness demands that no minority be offended. Any critical thought is met by disapproval. It is not possible for any form of religion to be bad. No minority may be offended. Since the talk is “hurtful” we may not do it. Islam is being added to a long list of topics that may not be discussed in any way that offends the minority of 1.5 billion people.
Islamic jihad invaded the Christian Middle East and subjugated them. The Crusades were a response to a cry for help by the tortured and oppressed Christians in their native land. Did the Christians do some wrong things?
Yes, but notice that the Crusades have been over nearly a thousand years. Jihad is active today. And while we are at it, why do academic libraries have many books on the Crusades, which lasted only 200 years, and so few on jihad, which has been going on 1400 years? The West has analyzed the Crusades, ad nauseam, and has barely looked at jihad.
So a man is nice and he is a Muslim. What does that prove about Islam? He may follow the Golden Rule and not Islamic doctrine. That is, he may be a poor practitioner of Islam and a good person.
Have you ever read the Koran, Sira and Hadith or know the Sharia? If so have you read the Koran in chronological order?
I understand what you mean. And i fully agree with you that we should be able to discuss the Islam. But the whole issue is that when we tell Muslims to not take the Quran literally to full extent just as we ask Christians or Jews not to take their holy books literally, a problem is presented. The reason why the Islam seems so hostile to the west, is because in the west people do not treasure freedom and have no respect for it, just as is done in Islamic countries. Freedom boundaries are constantly crossed. Having respect for each other, respecting each others freedoms and being against extreme expressions of personal (usually lustful)desires. Forcing personal views upon others.
Not using the common sense.
The issue is here of course, that a society is a dynamic system that is constantly changing. But a society requires a feedback system to fall back to. And a feedback system requires a reference. There is something as a reference that people use as a guidance in life, usually religion or moral and traditional values that have been passed on or taught. Since more and more people view freedom in the absolute way, meaning that they should be able to do whatever they can think of, regardless how others might feel about it.
Also, while there is nothing wrong with capitalism, capitalism without a strong moral view, will allow for excesses. Just look at the visual ads how one of the most basic instincts of (unsuspecting) humans (just customers) are used to let them buy anything you want or how you can shape their opinion anyway you want. It works... And it works best when you have a young fresh (hormone driven) generation every 20 years... Society is a dynamic system that is constantly evolving.
This may seem paranoid when you read it. But it is not. It is natural consequences, other may call it chaos or "the butterfly effect". It may seem overwhelming, but it is not. Give into it and see how comforting it is to see how things work when able to realize and visualize (or to experience it all at once in the mind) it. Some might call it revelation.
Most people do not understand what freedom of choice really consists.
Thus we come to the real question :
What is freedom ?
Freedom is for man and woman :
To receive and to enjoy education.
That people respect each others boundaries and do not force their lustful desires upon others.
That people communicate properly.
To have within borders of common sense and mutual respect a possibility to express creativity.
To let the scientific method prevail over assumed personal views.
To not confuse lust with love.
To accept that lust only works with love.
To accept that gathered experiences shape the mind of a human being.
To accept that having bad experiences also shapes and thus influences the mind.
I can go on and on...
I have looked into the books you have mentioned. Many ones. Different versions of the same. But came to the conclusion that with out having the original messages, i must accept the highly probability that these texts are tainted.
Just as is the Bible and the Torah...
And you are surely right about one thing. The golden rule.
Being a good person has nothing to do with religion. Religion is a tool. A guide to help people to make that personal connection from within your mind with what is naturally the true source of what makes a human a human and not an animal... A lot of people claim that humans are no more than animals. I disagree. Humans have naturally no limitations because of the ability to use creativity
and hope to solve problems. That is what makes humans so incredibly powerful but also so very dangerous at the same time. That is why some societies use versions of popular religions to force people to not be creative. But this will be their downfall in the always occurring end (dynamic system ever changing system remember) for not being able to cope with inevitable problems of life.