I've been builder and caretaker of an mATX LGA-775 Gigabyte board running continuously since 2010. that was before UEFI BIOS. It was fine, just for a budget workstation.
I've had an upper-mid-range EVGA LGA-775 board, still in storage in case my server with similar chipset breaks down.
And I had an ASUS Striker Extreme LGA-775 board, which was promoted as top-end, but had manageable problems.
When it comes to building any system that has any kind of overclock objective, I stick with ASUS. But there are good Gigabyte boards, MSI, EVGA and so on. But since the Striker, I've chosen boards that didn't give me even one-time trouble in configuring them.