Bitek
Lifer
- Aug 2, 2001
- 10,676
- 5,239
- 136
i do something similar. i buy used cars and drive them until the repair cost more then it's worth.
Though i buy $4-5k cars. I started doing it from the advice of my dad. I have purchased 1 new car (when i was 20). i just felt like i wasted 12k more to have a shinier car.
I was working some back of the napkin calcs on this as I just had to replace my old mazda. I had ~$3500 in suspension damage from potholes this accursed winter. The car had over 200K, but had been expecting a few more years out of it, but it was done and needed replacing.
Basically came down to amt of miles I drove and the cost of the car. From there I figured out what it would cost me per year to own spread over the lifetime. (eg $16K for mazda, got 13 yrs, ~$1200/yr) Bit more to it, but simple.
Looking at the used cars wasn't giving much of a price break over a economical new car, at least for my area. The newest cars are quite a bit more efficient than the older cars, plus the added mileage did't balance out the equation too much, plus there is the risk premium in buying used. So you figure the warranty protection, plus the financing on new cars is typically better than on used cars.
Added all up, the cost wasn't too much more for the cars I was looking at, plus my wife's car is hi miles, and it was worth it for our situation to keep two old cars going when repairs can be unexpected and expensive. Made more sense to get one new one, get it paid off, and then wife's car would about be near the end of its expected lifetime.
OTOH, we bought my wife's car used as it made more sense at that time.
Most of the price differences seemed to be in the class of car (truck vs sedan vs econocar) or if you didn't hold the car for a long time
Last edited: