MEDIAGATE MG-350HD Wireless High-Definition MPEG4 Netplayer
- Thread starter Pardus
- Start date
These things are a great concept but every time I look into it I am turned off. A friend had an older highly rated Buffalo media player that worked for over 2 years for him because he generated content for the unit he knew worked. Now he has an ipod and although his unit works with vc1 it naturally won't do H.264 even though it can do wma-HD and 10 other formats. I try it out to see if I might buy it off him and I find that even though it can do wma-HD it can't do plain old wma 7 or 8 or 9. Well I have 2 years of beyondTV wma files. I then find it only plays 75% of my AVI files. On some formats it FF/RW well others not at all.
What I'm getting at is I am doubting any little box will ever be able to play my content. It will take a PC. When laptops and desktop PCs are $300 where does a highly limited soon abandoned $200 media player fit in? It seems retrofit your old PC with a $120 Fry's motherboard/ C2D combo , stick it behind the PC and don't worry about it for 4-6 years. Am I off here?
Sorry not a thread crap just a general questioning of the concept, mostly to myself.
What I'm getting at is I am doubting any little box will ever be able to play my content. It will take a PC. When laptops and desktop PCs are $300 where does a highly limited soon abandoned $200 media player fit in? It seems retrofit your old PC with a $120 Fry's motherboard/ C2D combo , stick it behind the PC and don't worry about it for 4-6 years. Am I off here?
Sorry not a thread crap just a general questioning of the concept, mostly to myself.
It really depends on the execution of the concept. Some media players, like my D-link DSM-320 (and 520) uses the software in server-side to decode the media. I use TVersity to stream decoded media into my DSM-320 box upstairs. The codec pack with TVersity streaming software couldn't play some of the contents, so I uninstalled it, installed K-lite mega pack on my server, which in turn plays pretty much anything available. Check around on the net to find the player that fits you. Decoding done by the media box itself is definitely restrictive, as it require updates by the manufacture for any new codecs after product release (or wasn't included originally).
Also, be careful with the wireless part. My DSM320 has problems streaming higher-bit rate video files over wireless, the video seems to skip a good number of frames in regular interval. Streaming it via wired connection remedied the problem, but it defeats the "wireless" function. If my DSM320 chokes on high-rate SD video, it's probably impossible to get acceptable performance in anything remotely HD.
I have an IODATA linkplayer 2 which is probably the most mature of the devices when it comes to drivers and while its great its now old tech.
If your looking for the next generation for the same price look at this.
http://popcornhour.com/
Mine is supposed to ship in a few weeks and should replace my aging LinkPlayer. It does MKV, VC-1, and H.264 formats up to 1080P on top of what the previous generations did.
If your looking for the next generation for the same price look at this.
http://popcornhour.com/
Mine is supposed to ship in a few weeks and should replace my aging LinkPlayer. It does MKV, VC-1, and H.264 formats up to 1080P on top of what the previous generations did.
kki000
Will have it on http://www.FreshScoop.Com when I get it and test it over a few days and post a blurb in here as well. I was able to order it last week and they estimated a January ship date around the 14th.
It was a tough call between the popcorn hour or a pc and I might still compare the two.
Need to try it on my $400 HD Projector too.
Will have it on http://www.FreshScoop.Com when I get it and test it over a few days and post a blurb in here as well. I was able to order it last week and they estimated a January ship date around the 14th.
It was a tough call between the popcorn hour or a pc and I might still compare the two.
Need to try it on my $400 HD Projector too.
I have 2 of the older verison that doesn't do HD content. They work great. So much better then the buffulo and linsys stuff. The only problem is when trying to transfer data to a hard wirelessly or though the lan. It uses a NAS so you need software to do it its very slow. I found it fast to connect to my laptop through the USB cable and copy it that way. Also a groups a new firmware the lets you connect using an FTP client and its blazing that way too.
Really all in all it a piece of equipment and far better then most out thier. Now that the 360 can do Dixv, it mighty be the only one close to it in function and useablity. But you can't save stuff to the drive in the 360 so this is much better for take stuff with you as well.
Really all in all it a piece of equipment and far better then most out thier. Now that the 360 can do Dixv, it mighty be the only one close to it in function and useablity. But you can't save stuff to the drive in the 360 so this is much better for take stuff with you as well.
So when buying a device like this you have to ask yourself a couple questions:
1. Do you want something that just shows you a list of files and that can play them?
or
2. Do you want something that is skinnable, has nice menus and graphics, can sort on different types of things like genre and title, which other perks like youtube and other plugins?
If you answer yes to #1 then the mediagate will probably work for you but it may not play all the files and the support is very limited and forget about asking for new features.
If you answer yes to #2 then stay away from these devices like these. The ONLY device that I have found that can do all I want is a modified XBOX. I know this really isnt option for most people so you have to be careful on what you want and what you expect from a box. If the box says it can do what you want to do then go ahead and buy it but if you buy a box thinking you can get the vendor to add the stuff you want then that may lead to dissappointment down the road.
I have owned a MVIX 760HD, XBOX (running XBMC), Netgear EVA8000 and a HTPC (running MediaPortal) and here is how I rank them:
1. XBOX (running XBMC) - great but limited hardware and eventhough HD is possible it is very limited. PERFECT for playing your DVD and MUSIC collection from a network share.
2. HTPC (running MediaPortal) - great software - skinnable - plays MANY formats and can do HD with the right PC hardware - plan on replacing my XBMC boxes with this setup
3. Netgear EVA8000 - great piece of hardware. The beta forums for this box is second to none. If you have a problem they will try to fix, unlike MVIX. You can post your wishlist and they try to incorporate them.
4. MVIX 760HD - perfect if you want a list view of all your files. it plays a lot of formats but it has some serious bugs that have yet to be addressed. This is due that the chipset is old is getting very little attention from the group that can fix it
1. Do you want something that just shows you a list of files and that can play them?
or
2. Do you want something that is skinnable, has nice menus and graphics, can sort on different types of things like genre and title, which other perks like youtube and other plugins?
If you answer yes to #1 then the mediagate will probably work for you but it may not play all the files and the support is very limited and forget about asking for new features.
If you answer yes to #2 then stay away from these devices like these. The ONLY device that I have found that can do all I want is a modified XBOX. I know this really isnt option for most people so you have to be careful on what you want and what you expect from a box. If the box says it can do what you want to do then go ahead and buy it but if you buy a box thinking you can get the vendor to add the stuff you want then that may lead to dissappointment down the road.
I have owned a MVIX 760HD, XBOX (running XBMC), Netgear EVA8000 and a HTPC (running MediaPortal) and here is how I rank them:
1. XBOX (running XBMC) - great but limited hardware and eventhough HD is possible it is very limited. PERFECT for playing your DVD and MUSIC collection from a network share.
2. HTPC (running MediaPortal) - great software - skinnable - plays MANY formats and can do HD with the right PC hardware - plan on replacing my XBMC boxes with this setup
3. Netgear EVA8000 - great piece of hardware. The beta forums for this box is second to none. If you have a problem they will try to fix, unlike MVIX. You can post your wishlist and they try to incorporate them.
4. MVIX 760HD - perfect if you want a list view of all your files. it plays a lot of formats but it has some serious bugs that have yet to be addressed. This is due that the chipset is old is getting very little attention from the group that can fix it
1080p mkv (h264) file playback... thats the holy grail for me. I finally got those to play correctly on my pc, but I was hoping for an easy way to display them on my hdtvs.
I have an old xb fully modded that I havent booted up in a few years. If xbmc can now playback 1080p content, then I'm more than willing to dig up the xbox....
I have an old xb fully modded that I havent booted up in a few years. If xbmc can now playback 1080p content, then I'm more than willing to dig up the xbox....
I have the old xbox and a new xbox 360. Maybe I should use one of those. Anyone care to suggest the best route to do that.
Xbox isn't even remotely powerful enough to do 1080p content. It can't even do 720p. XBMC is great for non-HD stuff, but the line is drawn there.
For 1080p, you really need one of the "next generation" type players such as the Popcorn Hour device mentioned above (mine has shipped and I'll hopefully have it tomorrow).
Jaxidian
Platinum Member
XBMC CAN play 720p files - i do it every day with the component video adapter to my HD projector... It can output to a 1080i HDTV, but yes are right it can not play a native 1080i video... so if you acdtually have native 1080i files then yes you need to find something else.
Here is the link
720x480 pixel video output to 720p HDTV (1280x720 progressive) = OK! (eg upscaled).
720x480 pixel video output to 1080i HDTV (1920x1080 interlaced) = OK! (eg upscaled).
It does h264 and xvid .MKV files - but of course if the file is native 1080i then it wont play, but if it is 720 then it works like a charm
720x480 is not 720p its 480p
720p is 1280x720 which the xbox does choke on. the best you can get to play well on an xbox is 960x540 which looks pretty good
You realize 720x480 is 480p, not 720p right? The Xbox cannot handle 720p source material. You can play it, but it will be extremely choppy.
TRENDING THREADS
-
Discussion Zen 5 Speculation (EPYC Turin and Strix Point/Granite Ridge - Ryzen 9000)- Started by DisEnchantment
- Replies: 22K
-
Discussion Intel Meteor, Arrow, Lunar & Panther Lakes Discussion Threads
- Started by Tigerick
- Replies: 17K
-
Discussion Intel current and future Lakes & Rapids thread- Started by TheF34RChannel
- Replies: 23K
-
-
Discussion Speculation: Zen 4 (EPYC 4 "Genoa", Ryzen 7000, etc.)- Started by Vattila
- Replies: 13K
Facebook
Twitter