Mechanical keyboard help

Defy13

Member
Jan 10, 2011
32
0
0
I'm looking to grab a mechanical keyboard as my current one is starting to get old
I was looking at the XArmor U9Plus Cherry MX Blue
and Razer BlackWidow Ultimate
the SteelSeries 7G is a little pricier then I would like.
Could I get some opinions on them? (I was having a lot of trouble finding reviews for the xarmor keyboard)
 

Kyanzes

Golden Member
Aug 26, 2005
1,082
0
76
A good starting point for finding info on mechanical keyboards in general: http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1468692

Also, be very careful with the keyboard layouts. Some mechanical keyboards (well, some keyboards in general) tend to have exotic layouts. E.g., I tried the 6G and its right shift is a bit shorter than usual. Due to this I'm unable to reach the opening parenthesis which I need all the time while coding.

The ENTER on the 6G/7G is also oddly shaped. Since, I assume, you don't use any national characters it's probably less of an issue for you. For me it was a nightmare as I kept pressing it instead of a national char.

Anyways, make sure you buy the right layout. Sometimes the difference from standard can be miniscule (I didn't notice the short SHIFT on the 6G).

I like Das Keyboard.

I know nothing about the XArmor.
 
Last edited:

Ben90

Platinum Member
Jun 14, 2009
2,866
3
0
First decide what key type you want. I'm going to shamelessly rip off Geekhack here. That page is packed with too much information and would confuse new buyers.

It seems Cherry Blues are a very popular key for "gamer" quality boards. My guess for this is they stand out a lot more than Blacks or Reds. Since Razer or SteelSeries don't compete with Filco in regards to build quality, they need that extra pop the blue switches gives to impress buyers. Lets look at why:

attachment.php
attachment.php


If you can tolerate the noise that the switch makes, these are a great key to type on. The switch is very light so your fingers don't get fatigued. It actually takes a while to get used to at first when coming from a rubber dome because it is so light. Very very tactile as you can see from the force chart. But lets really examine it. The operating point is when the electrical contact is made. The reset point is when the electrical contact stops. These two points are very far apart. This is the main reason why I feel Blues are unfit for FPS gaming, at least for myself. If you do play FPS games, examine how you press the keys, if you SOMETIMES don't depress the key all the way, stay far far away from Blues. However, they do do great for RTS type games such as Starcraft.

Lets check out the next closest switch type: Cherry Browns
attachment.php
attachment.php


This switch has one internal change compared to the Blue. Its obvious in the GIF, the clicky thingy is now one piece with the top. This creates a few changes. First it makes the switch less loud and harsh. Second it fixes the operating/reset point problem the Blue has. As the last side effect, it lightens the switch further and it makes the force chart more uniform. I haven't personally typed on a Brown, but I can tell you that the return stroke of a Blue is weird as shit. This looks to fix that. Despite sounding like all positives, its all up to personal preference. Remember that Browns aren't clicky.

Now time for some linear action: Cherry Blacks

attachment.php
attachment.php


This switch is the generally heralded as the best gaming switch due to its linear action. I agree, but find it very boring and tiresome in day to day typing. Which brings us back to the Razer/SteelSeries marketing. From a theoretical standpoint, these or Reds (below) are the only switch to use for hardcore gaming. That should give you an idea of just how boring/tiresome this switch can be. Gaming companies basically live on marketing, and even they are hard pressed to sell you the "best" gaming switches. Don't let the force chart fool you, these are very stiff. They moderately redeem themselves in FPS games however.

Lets lighten our linear lumbering levers: Cherry Reds

attachment.php
attachment.php


Enter Cherry Reds. Still slightly boring when compared to a tactile switch, it fixes what was wrong with Blacks, the stiffness. Once again its all personal preference though. A lot of girls like stiff Blacks. This is a newer switch and might be slightly harder to find than the Blacks because of this.

I know that I didn't necessarily give you the information you were asking for, but the main selling point of a mechanical keyboard is the switch itself. Keep in mind that are other makers of mechanical switches, not just Cherry MX. I really recommend visiting GeekHack and doing some research before purchasing. The wealth of information on that site regarding boards is just astounding. All my sound clips and images are from there.

I'll post in a bit regarding some boards themselves when I get a break.
 
Last edited: