- Oct 27, 2006
- 20,736
- 1,377
- 126
In a recent thread, PH had a great post outlining a good plan on a cohesive and comprehensive set of rules and administrative organization related to the question of interrogation and torture.
I just watched a 60 minutes clip on Yahoo where John McCain says unequivocally "The United States has tortured", speaking directly about waterboarding. Further, he draws the direct connection with our conviction of Japanese war criminals post WW2 for waterboarding US soldiers.
Then of course, he votes against the bill that would have the Army's field manual apply towards the CIA's handling of things such as waterboarding and 'enhanced' interrogation techniques. The bill passed with a solid majority in support of it, though the Republicans pretty much lined up against it, I think it was 189 against, and 179 of those were (R)'s voting no.
On the bill, it wasn't the end-all solution to begin with, PH had a great suggested course of action. A course that will be impossible to apply with the Bush WH, but that brings us to some questions.
Will this back-and-forth of words and actions hurt McCain as a 'straight-talker'?
If McCain gains the Presidency, what will his actions be on the Torture/Interrogation subject?
I just watched a 60 minutes clip on Yahoo where John McCain says unequivocally "The United States has tortured", speaking directly about waterboarding. Further, he draws the direct connection with our conviction of Japanese war criminals post WW2 for waterboarding US soldiers.
Then of course, he votes against the bill that would have the Army's field manual apply towards the CIA's handling of things such as waterboarding and 'enhanced' interrogation techniques. The bill passed with a solid majority in support of it, though the Republicans pretty much lined up against it, I think it was 189 against, and 179 of those were (R)'s voting no.
On the bill, it wasn't the end-all solution to begin with, PH had a great suggested course of action. A course that will be impossible to apply with the Bush WH, but that brings us to some questions.
Will this back-and-forth of words and actions hurt McCain as a 'straight-talker'?
If McCain gains the Presidency, what will his actions be on the Torture/Interrogation subject?