Man dies just hours after reaching Everest Summit - went blind -

dahunan

Lifer
Jan 10, 2002
18,191
3
0
26 May, 2010

It is with our deepest regrets that we report the passing of Peter Kinloch, who was a bright spark in our team, and he is missed very much. Peter summited Everest at 1:18 p.m. on 25 May and passed away at 3:00 a.m. on 26 May. At this very sad moment, we send our sincere condolences, thoughts and prayers, to his family, loved ones, friends, and colleagues. [back to top]


http://www.summitclimb.com/new/default.asp?linktype=r&nid=132#26may
^^ the climbing crews blog

Just hours after one of the greatest moments in the mans life (anyones life for that matter) he goes blind and was forced to stay there and die...

icon_eek.gif
.. so many ways to view this

http://www.everestnews.com/everest2010/summitclimbeverestnorth05292010.htm
This report is written in an attempt to explain the tragic loss of Peter Kinloch. We only spent 6 weeks with Peter, however, during that time we were a team climbing and resting together for many days, so were able to get to know one another well. Peter seemed to be a fit young Scotsman with an interesting life of experiences. He worked for the Police in Merseyside as a member of the civilian support staff dealing with incident pattern analysis and the extraction of management information from crime and incident databases, a specialist in which he held a PhD. Peter was shortly due to take up a new post in Belgium. From what we know of Peter, a great loss has occurred with his passing, and we are extremely sorry this has happened. We wish to send our deepest condolences to Peter's family, loved ones, and family.

Peter passed away shockingly and unexpectedly on the night of 26 May in the early morning hours, after 2:00 am, at 8600 meters, while climbing down from the summit of Mount Everest.

Peter's summit day started at 10:00 pm on 24 may at camp 3 at 8300 meters. After dressing and preparing his kit, food, and water for the summit, he and the rest of the team set off for the summit at 12:00 am in the early morning hours of 25 may.

Our team went upward and passed the obstacles one surmounts in the climb of Mount Everest from the Tibet side, including first step, mushroom rock, second step, third step, final snow slope, and dihedral. On the way up the final obstacles, Peter was in good spirits, moving steadily and sure-footedly together with our team, reaching the summit at around 1:00 pm on 25 May.

Summit team leader David Obrien radioed leader Dan Mazur, who was in camp 3 at 8300 metres, at 1:18 pm on 25 May to say the team was on the summit and everyone was in fine spirits and good health. David said it was very cold and windy and it had been a long and difficult climb.

On the summit Peter was elated, cheery and bubbly. Earlier during the expedition while dining with the team, he had said that climbing Everest would be the realization of a dream he had had for 25 years. While standing atop Everest, Peter took summit photos with the team. Conditions were sunny, but extremely cold, windy, with blowing snow and some cloud.

Descending from the summit, Peter surprisingly seemed to lose his
coordination and took a few slips and stumbles. These moments of clumsiness were interspersed with normal walking. Finally, reaching the top of the second step at approximately 2pm, he asked leader David Obrien, if David would show Peter how to descend the ladders. Peter told David that he (Peter) was having difficulties seeing, then finally that he couldn't see anything at all and was blind.

Peter seemed unsurprised about his blindness and explained to David that the blindness had happened before, although never in mountain conditions. Peter was perfectly coherent at this time and calmly explained that the condition was not snow blindness as he had no pain and he recognized the blindness from a previous episode.

In camp 3, several of the team's sherpas had descended earlier in the day with other members. 3 sherpas were sent up to assist over a period of several hours: Jangbu (Junior) was sent first, then later Phurba and Gyelje.

Over many hours of slow progress helping the now blind Peter, he, David and Jangbu reached the area of "Mushroom Rock" at 8600 metres at approximately six o'clock.

Here they stopped for a rest, David gave Peter food and opened Peter's backpack to take out some of Peter's water for him to drink. The temperature was very cold with high winds. Upon examination, Peter had initial signs of frost bite on two fingers. Peter was mentally coherent as he was able to recognize the symptoms via his sense of touch and show his frostbitten fingers to David. He requested that David remove his extra large mittens out of Peter's rucksack. Throughout this event, Peter's speech and thinking seemed to remain sharp and he did not evidence any signs of HACE. His blindness seemed to be unique, and unconnected to any other illness.

The other 2 sherpas arrived soon after to help with the rescue. The 3 sherpas and David did everything they could to get Peter beyond this point for the next 8 hours to no avail (tried administering dex, high amounts of oxygen, etcetera). Tragically, they were finally forced to come down. The rescue team did everything in their power to help Peter for about 12 hours coming dangerously close to needing their own rescue and not returning themselves.

David and the other 3 sherpas arrived back in camp 3 at 5:30 in the morning with hypothermia, exhaustion, and minor frostbite.


It is with our deepest regrets that we report the passing of Peter Kinloch, who was a bright spark in our team, and he is missed very much. At this very sad moment, we send our sincere condolences, thoughts and prayers, to his family, loved ones, friends, and colleagues.

Summitclimb
 

ixelion

Senior member
Feb 5, 2005
984
1
0
Don't they screen people for medical conditions before letting them climb?
 

Jzero

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
18,834
1
0
Just another day in the office at the top of the world....everyone that attempts Everest (really any high-altitude climb) is keenly aware that they may never make it back.

Just hours after one of the greatest moments in the mans life (anyones life for that matter) he goes blind and was forced to stay there and die...

The scary thing is that in the legendary 1996 storm where 8 people died in one day, Beck Weathers' vision failed and he too was left for dead...and then he miraculously came to and staggered into Camp IV where he was almost again left when other climbers again believed he was already dead...

There's no medical screening. Mountaineering is still largely self-regulated. A climber is expected to know what medical issues he might have, and while in a guided expedition the guides may have some sort of medical check prior to putting them on a summit team, if this guy never disclosed that he had this blindness there is really no way they could know.
 

darkxshade

Lifer
Mar 31, 2001
13,749
6
81
I have come to the conclusion that climbing Mount Everest is just as difficult as taking Carentan.
 

Jzero

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
18,834
1
0
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_altitude_cerebral_edema

I guess the other climbers weren't nearly as experienced as they thought. Seems obvious to me what the guys problem was, the other climbers should have noticed it and not allowed him to continue the ascent

According to their account he was completely lucid and had no symptoms other than the blindness, which is something that had happened to him previously (although not while climbing). He had also already summited, thus he was at the point of no return. As the old Everest cliche goes, you might as well be on the moon if something goes wrong up there.
 

speg

Diamond Member
Apr 30, 2000
3,681
3
76
www.speg.com
I'm confused as to what happened during the bold part. They give him meds, but why can't they guide him down?
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
10 years of getting a phd only to die while trying to get 2km lower than my flight over memorial day...
 

ShawnD1

Lifer
May 24, 2003
15,987
2
81
This is probably a stupid question but why can't someone parachute down from a mountain? Any time I've gone skiing, the top of the mountain was always very windy. You might not go the direction you want, but at least you'll get off the mountain.
 

Number1

Diamond Member
Feb 24, 2006
7,881
549
126
This is probably a stupid question but why can't someone parachute down from a mountain? Any time I've gone skiing, the top of the mountain was always very windy. You might not go the direction you want, but at least you'll get off the mountain.

You're right, it is a stupid question.
 

Connoisseur

Platinum Member
Sep 14, 2002
2,470
1
81
This is probably a stupid question but why can't someone parachute down from a mountain? Any time I've gone skiing, the top of the mountain was always very windy. You might not go the direction you want, but at least you'll get off the mountain.

I'm no parachuting expert but i assume jumping off a mountain isn't exactly like jumping off a flat cliff or a diving platform. You'll prolly just end up crashing into a "fun" part of the mountain depending on the wind. Mountains aren't ALL vertical.
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
Don't they screen people for medical conditions before letting them climb?

Why? If you make the choice to climb Everest, you should screen yourself for medical conditions; it's your responsibility, not anyone else's.
 

deadlyapp

Diamond Member
Apr 25, 2004
6,672
744
126
I'm no parachuting expert but i assume jumping off a mountain isn't exactly like jumping off a flat cliff or a diving platform. You'll prolly just end up crashing into a "fun" part of the mountain depending on the wind. Mountains aren't ALL vertical.

Not to mention the air is so thin you'd probably just plummet back to the ground anyways.
 

Jzero

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
18,834
1
0
I'm confused as to what happened during the bold part. They give him meds, but why can't they guide him down?

It takes too long, and is too difficult. 4 men including 3 sherpas spent 12 hours helping him and they only got from the 2nd Step (28300 ft) to Mushroom Rock (28000 ft).

Also worth noting, the fact that he died on descent from the summit is not significant - the descent is the most dangerous part of the route and is when most accidents happen. You're fatigued from nearly 24-hours of nonstop climbing, lack of oxygen, etc.
 

ShawnD1

Lifer
May 24, 2003
15,987
2
81
I'm no parachuting expert but i assume jumping off a mountain isn't exactly like jumping off a flat cliff or a diving platform. You'll prolly just end up crashing into a "fun" part of the mountain depending on the wind. Mountains aren't ALL vertical.
Most mountains I've been to are vertical enough for a parachute to easily work. The biggest problem would be coming down into some trees or coming down too fast on uneven ground (broken legs). The mountain being insanely steep is why Everest is so difficult to climb. If it were a gentle incline like Brewster Mountain in Canada, Everest would be as simple as walking up to the top.

In mountains where the trees have been cleared and the ground has been evened out for skiing, people already use parachutes to fuck around.

http://www.environmentalgraffiti.com/featured/skiing-cliffs-nothing-parachute/15172
http-inlinethumb44.webshots.com-45739-2627678040105101600S600x600Q85.preview.jpg
 

ShawnD1

Lifer
May 24, 2003
15,987
2
81
Not to mention the air is so thin you'd probably just plummet back to the ground anyways.

Unfortunately we have video of people actually doing this - paragliding from the higher parts of Everest (probably not from the very top)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9W6PbjQTV4

Here is a BBC story about a paraglider who was sucked into a wind storm and it pulled her higher than Everest.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/6369923.stm
"There's no oxygen," Mr Wenness said. "She could have suffered brain damage but she came to again at a height of 6,900m with ice all over her body and slowly descended herself."
Yep, it sure is cold up there.
 

ed21x

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 2001
5,411
8
81
what a heroic way to go. while this is sad, it's inspiring that he left after realizing a dream. mad props to him.
 

PricklyPete

Lifer
Sep 17, 2002
14,582
162
106
As sad as the story is...he took the risk when attempting the ascent. You really can't fault the others with him. Even if summiting Everest has become quite the business, there are some serious risks involved.