Originally posted by: Ronstang
The FW was a fantastic and formidable figher but it was deadly to the pilot if a novice....it was not easy to fly at all.
All pilot accounts I've read state that the 190 was a much friendlier aircraft than the 109. The 109 suffered from very narrow and weak landing gear, you could easily tip the plane over on the ground or suffer gear failure on landing. Also, the 190 was very automated - in the 109 the pilot had to micromanage all of his engine settings, in the 190 much of this was taken care of. The greats, such as Hartmann, generally preffered the 109, while the bulk of the luftwaffe considered the 190 the better aircraft. However, none of the german aircraft were as approachable as pilots remember the allied fighters. Accounts say the P-51 and 47 were very easy to fly and land in. The spitfire was reported to be a handful on takeoff but other than that a very forgiving aircraft.
The allies had their dogs, too, though. The P-39 comes to mind. Famous for being a deathtrap due to its bizarre stall characteristics resulting from the engine being placed behind the cockpit (made room for the big 37mm cannon firing out the propellor hub).
I think it was Hartmann who made the comparison that the 109 was akin to a foil while the 190 was a rapier. It came down to preference and pilot style as to which was better.
Yaks are good planes, also. in a turning fight they'd destroy both main german fighters. In an energy fight, things go the other way. It came down to the pilots in most cases. The germans had more training, and in general won aerial confrontations. The RAF and USAAF had as much more training, however, and the average german pilot wasn't much of a match for his western counterparts late in the war. A few phenomonal german pilots were flying, of course, but most of the experienced pilots were dead and the impressive K/D ratio for the brits and yanks comes down to better training. Arguments can be made either way as to which aircraft were better. Don't argue with a british guy, though, I've never talked to one that would concede that the spitfire wasn't the best at everything.