M11X replacement

xapo99

Member
Jun 14, 2012
108
0
0
www.thelucidnutritionist.net
First post but long...can't find reviews of a laptop I am looking at with the lowly i3 cpu.

I have an M11X laptop I basically take on business trips around the UK and just use it in the evenings on overnight stays to play games mostly. The only think I never liked about it was it is a bit too small but it is better than having to play games on a phone or something.

However it just endured a rather hefty fall down some stone stairs and has been bodged up before after road trip knocks and bumps and to cap it all off, I think the HDD is dead. Rather than even spend money on a new hard drive I think I have had my monies worth, the spec is Core 2 Duo SU7300 which can run OC'd to 1.73 (I never did though to save battery), a 500GB drive, 4GB ram and an Nvidia 335m.

I've been looking at Ultrabooks or 13 and 14 inch laptops but they seem to be pretty pricey but I checked out the Acer M3 in a shop near where I was today. The review on here says the screen isn't great quality...but it looks better than my M11x and is bigger. Despite the same res.

Basically this Acer M3 is the i3 model with the 640m (Kepler).

I have some questions if anyone can answer them.

1. Will the CPU be too slow for the GPU (i3 2367, Sandybridge 1.4GHz with HT) ? Is it likely to be crap in games ?

2. How can the GPU (when coupled with say an i5 or i7) perform so well even with a quite poor ddr3 memory setup and under 30gb/s bandwidth ?

3.Would I be better off spending the same on an i5 with a lesser GPU ? (there is a Lenovo with an i5 but a 6470 GPU)

I can't spend any more then £500 and want new...most laptops at this price come with way less than a 640m, hence my interest in the Acer, IF the cpu isn't too slow, the next model up with an i5 is out of my budget.

thanks
 

Zap

Elite Member
Oct 13, 1999
22,377
2
81
1) If the SU7300 was kinda-sorta working for you, the new Ivy Bridge based CPU will blow it out of the water in the same games.

2) In your budget and limited to Ultrabooks, you have to take what you can get.

3) For gaming, no. Everything else, maybe or yes.
 

xapo99

Member
Jun 14, 2012
108
0
0
www.thelucidnutritionist.net
1) If the SU7300 was kinda-sorta working for you, the new Ivy Bridge based CPU will blow it out of the water in the same games.

2) In your budget and limited to Ultrabooks, you have to take what you can get.

3) For gaming, no. Everything else, maybe or yes.

Thanks. Just so happens the M3 is sort of an Ultrabook and is on offer. The others in the price range aren't. I can get also the HP DV6 with an AMD A6 plus crossfire with its own GPU or something like the Lenovo mentioned.

Neither of those are a graphically powerful, but both potentially have better CPU's...the SU7300 was ok...I mean I never compared it to another m11 with an i5 or something.
 

xapo99

Member
Jun 14, 2012
108
0
0
www.thelucidnutritionist.net
Thanks, that is surely the spiritual successor to the M11X. However similar units being bussed by UK resellers like PC Specialist are way over budget. Even a refurb M11x with an I5 and 540m is.

All that is putting me offbthe Acer M3 with the 640m is the ulv 1.4ghz sandy I3 which I estimate would be similar to a Core 2 at about 2ghz or an Arrandale at about 1.6 ???
 
Last edited:

sm625

Diamond Member
May 6, 2011
8,172
137
106
the ulv 1.4ghz sandy I3 which I estimate would be similar to a Core 2 at about 2ghz or an Arrandale at about 1.6 ???

According to passmark it scores about the same as a Core2 2.6GHz. It also scores the same as an athlon II X2 250... which is quite a feat.
 

xapo99

Member
Jun 14, 2012
108
0
0
www.thelucidnutritionist.net
Ok, I had a look at that, I thought it was much slower than that, as sites like notebookcheck seem to reckon.

So the CPU looks like an 'upgrade' over the Core 2 SU7300 I have (1.3-1.7GHz speed depending on OC on or off), i'm just wondering why the GPU performs so well for a lowish 29gb/s memory bandwidth...
 

xapo99

Member
Jun 14, 2012
108
0
0
www.thelucidnutritionist.net
So as long as the CPU can drive it, should be good, thanks for all the info people.

I already have a Crucial SSD M4 sitting unused to go in it and a spare 4gb sodimm (so probably remove 2 and fit 4, totalling 6).