Logitech z-5500 vs. Entry Level HTIB

Falc

Member
Nov 30, 2004
25
0
0
I currently own a hodge-podge home theater setup made from different speakers that I've collected over the last few years. Well not surprisingly, it sounds like crap. I want to upgrade my system with a more cohesive set and I'm down to two choices. In one corner are the Logitech z-5500 "computer speakers". They're 500 watts of THX certified goodness and I've read nothing but great things about them including several reviews that tested them in a home theater setup. Across the ring from them are the entry level HTIB systems from Panasonic (SC-HT05), Samsung (HT-DB600), and Sony (HT-DDW660). I already own a DVD player, so that isn't a factor.

Now normally, I'd just head to a store and listen to them all for myself, but that isn't possible because I live in the middle of no-where. So I need your help. How do these HTIB systems compare to the z-5500's? The z-5500's are more expensive (about $70), but are they better? Has anyone else made this comparison?

As a side note, if anyone could tell me why my current setup sounds like trash, that would be nice. I have Sony floorspeakers for the fronts ($100 ea), a Sony sub ($100), JBL N-Center ($100) and JBL N-24 for the surrounds ($50 ea) with a JVC 6000VBK receiver ($150). Now that adds up to be $650 in audio equipment, so it seems like it should sound a lot better than it does. But when I switch to a surround mode, it sounds like total crap. The center is fuzzy sort of like static and almost no sound at all comes out of the floor speakers or surrounds. I've tried adjusting everything I can adjust (levels, modes, etc) on the receiver, but nothing helps. For the past two years I've just been running the system in stereo mode w/sub because that's the only way it sounds half-way decent. Is it the receiver that's crap or do I just have a bad setup here that I should sell off and replace with a cohesive unit from above?

- Falc
 

calyco

Senior member
Oct 7, 2004
825
1
81
If you cant hit the $1000 mark at the very least for a complete system then I would suggest you to save your money till you can instead of getting a HTIB. IMO $1k-$2k is the sweet spot, you get the most bang for your buck. That dosent mean there arent any good budget components out there, Im just giving you an idea on how much you should spend on a decent HT setup. Also if you dont mind refurbished or used it is a great way to save some money.. audiogon.com or accessories4less.com are two sites Ive had good experiences with. If you want to piece together a complete system but cant demo check out hometheaterforum.com or avsforum.com, alot of good info there.

I think MM sets are a good replacement for a small HT setup, depending on the size of your room. The top of the line ones are better than most HTIBs. I would recommend the Creative Megaworks or Gigaworks cause I think they sound pretty damn good for the money but if its just for HT use (DVD/TV) Im sure the Logitechs or Klipsch would do just fine.
 

slpaulson

Diamond Member
Jun 5, 2000
4,412
13
81
It sounds like your problem is with your reciever, or you have something hooked up wrong.
You should look for a refurbished Onkyo reciever, I've seen those go for pretty cheap.


If you do decide to get a packaged home theater I would look at Onkyo instead of Sony, Samsung and Panasonic.

Does that Logitech system even have a remote?
 

Xab

Member
Dec 12, 2002
107
0
0
I'm in this situation too, I have a Bose 321GS that I use for my PC/TV (theyre both in the same room) and I've heard so many good things about the Z-5500's. I'm wondering how it would stack up to my system, since I would save about $1,100 doing it. The Logitechs have optical in for my PC, and digital in for my TV, so it would get me less clutter by getting rid of a box reciever unit. I'm interested to hear some opinions.
 

bigpow

Platinum Member
Dec 10, 2000
2,372
2
81
upgrade your receiver, keep your speakers - that should blow Z5500 out of the water
 

BuLLBuG

Member
Jan 18, 2005
27
0
0
how about Z680? i got Z680 i thought it works the same with z5500
only different between both was the Z5500 has better looking on the Soundtouch control cernter
 

Wuzup101

Platinum Member
Feb 20, 2002
2,334
37
91
The z5500 satalites are revised and sound a bit better than those on the 680s. The sub on the z5500s is a 10" rather than an 8" like on the 680s. The sound on the z5500s is clearer overall than that of the 680s... bass is also tighter and less boomy than on the 680s. Controls are nicer and they do have a wireless remote (not sure if the z680s did).