.. this has been a long time coming ..
Terminator 2 - Judgement Day -
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0103064/reference
rating on IMDb: 8.5/10
We know James Cameron knows how to make a film, but something must have change between Terminator (1984) and Judgement Day (1991). Maybe the issue is that with Terminator, he didn't have much money. Or maybe he wasn't thinking "cinematography".
The introduction scene has Schwarzy show up with his peepee in the air at a biker bar and politely ask for their clothes. A brief demostration of violence ensues, after which Bad To The Bone starts playing and we immediately know the tone of this film has nothing to do with the previous film. There is no humour in Terminator.
There's a brief scene with exo-only T800s which is kind of stupid, as these were explained in T1 to be infiltration models, while Skynet fights its above-ground battles using "normal", tank-like and helicopter-like machines, the H-K's. Still, it's a decent scene, so no complaints there. I also understand they want to call back to T1 so obviously they will try to cram in the exo. A nerd would still disagree, though.
The brief introduction of the snotty, annoying kid co-protagonist comes with its own soundtrack and we reeeally need to stop doing this.
Sarah Connor is introduced as being in a mental institution. Ok. Let's forget that a terminator ripped through an entire police station and that its carcass was left behind in a press, and that there is plenty of evidence to prove as much. Government coverup n' all that. I actually quite like this part, and the lead up to the first confrontation between the two terminators.
The new character of Sarah Connor is believable and Linda Hamilton does a good job. Also Cameron's own audio track really helps when he's not forced to blare out Guns & Roses.
There's some minor film tricks here, "how does one terminator know which way they went" but this is standard filmmaking stuff and the suspension of disbelief takes care of these.
(lol @ stuntman in obvious Arnold mask when he does the bike jump)
Then you have the long chase scene in the waterway. The big explosion that the T1000 walks away from is not great, because you are now looking at an antagonist that is indestructable, which - do i really need to explain this? - dampens the effect of any future scenes of combat they might be in.
Up until now i was on board with this film, but from here onwards, it starts to annoy me.
Edward Furlong as John Connor is terrible. His lack of acting aside, and his direction by Cameron, are irrelevant compared to the very fact that his lines are structures as those of a protagonist. WE, the audience, are now expected to identify with this 13yo kid. He does a cringy "we are buddies now" thing and Arnold escorts him away. There's the "your parents are dead" scene, which could be annoying from a canon point of view, because the "two" terminators sent back were sent, in T1, from an experiemental facility, which was later captured by the resistance. Even if we accept two were sent, this would have been in rapid succession. So while a second terminator already breaks canon, what's more annoying is that the T1000 has far more indepth knowledge of the 20th century, and far too good mimicry, for having access to the same exact information that the T800 has.
This is a big point, because Terminator 1 is a film that "ends". There is no material for a sequel, because the very plot of this film is "let's make that no other terminators exist". So obviously they had to walk back some things, and break canon. Up to a point, i am inclined to forgive this.
Anyway, Sarah breaks out of the mental institution, at the same time that both terminators arrive. John does his "swear to not kill anyone" speech. And i don't get it.
John Connor at this time is a fringe criminal. He hates his own mother and steals money from people's bank accounts. He despises his foster parents and clearly gets into a lot of trouble. It would totally be this character's fantasy to have a bigass terminator to kill everyone he doesn't like, and in his position he has nothing to gain by asking the T800 to not kill people. And you know the reason why? No, it's not character writing. It's not because the story demands it. It's because Terminator 2 was rated PG-13. This is why we have a scene with a 13yo child teaching his big friendly giant terminator how to say Hasta La Vista Baby.
T1 has nothing of this and that's why it is such a pure film. It draws from the crime films of the early 80s, it's dark, seedy, without salvation.
T2 is not a bad film, in itself it has a lot of really great things. The nuclear explosion scene with skeleton reveal is absolutely epic, but the scenes where the T800 fires a minigun and an assortment of grenades into the police and hits NOBODY are A-Team levels of cringe.
Cameron is a really talented director and skilled in all aspects of filmmaking, but he has decided to got for a casual film, here; a film here where THE HEROES are hiding behind a desk from a hail of bullets, and nobody's getting hit because they are THE HEROES. There is no drama, no crying here, or if there is, it's for show - the stupid protagonist will soon again be chirping like a fucking bird who found a cookie.
This, together with the absurd invincibility of the antagonist makes for a film that can't be taken too seriously.
Here is a comprehensive list of what really, really makes it impossible for me to like T2.
1. John Connor's character and Furlong's acting, his dialogue and screeching voice.
2. the absurd liquid-metal technobabble. The T800 is scary because it feels real, the T1000 is in superheroland.
3. twice the heroes manage to escape the terminator, and twice again they put themselves in its way.
4. the ending scene where the T800 "sacrifices itself", together with all attempts to humanize Arnold's character. THIS IS THE MAIN POINT OF THE TERMINATOR.
The fucking tag line, "a machine, cold, calculating, unstoppable".
The appeal of T1 was that the terminator is just a dumb machine, and it will keep trying to kill you, it cannot be distracted, it doesn't take time off, it's direct, dumb and brutal. Not only does T2's T800 fail by trying to be more sympathetic, but the same way the T1000 fails by being too clever. There is something of a beautiful agony in knowing that you are just barely escaping a T800
just because it's too stupid, but at the same time you are not really escaping, just delaying the inevitable.
T2 is a boom boom shooty film for kids.
T1 is a hellhole. Sarah Connor is just a waitress girl who one day gets abducted and knows she's about to be raped and/or murdered. Only after witnessing the impossible she barely starts to accept the reality of Kyle Rees and even then she fucks up and brings the Terminator back on her track by trying to call her mother. The Terminator casually murders anything in its way, where the important word is CASUALLY. It doesn't kill a dog out of spite, or a truck driver because they were annoying, it has one.single.purpose.
Arnold in T1 is mesmerizing. He still had some of the machnie like body movement in T2, but in T1 he truly looks like a machine, behaves like a machine. T1 is solid, grounded, realistic, and scary, and while T2 is not a terrible film, the two are miles apart.
My vote, Terminator 2 - Judgement Day:
7.5/10 - minus 1 if you have watched The Terminator
My vote, The Terminator: 8.5/10