Blade Runner 2049, Scene By Scene
1. titles
cool. i like the black and white, grainy effect, it recalls the neo-noir style of the previous film.
2. intro
ugh; bad copy of the original intro, with some nausea-inducing camera tilt. also, why would someone have their own id photo on their in-car control center? do you need to be reminded of what your face looks like?
3. on the farm/house
fire's too high for a dutch oven. why do you need a metal pressurized suit to grow insects?
3b. on the farm/fight
given the rubble is concrete, ryan gosling should be dead now, OR he is an android. yep, he's an android. cool fight scene. "you've never seen a miracle" i can tell this is the key to the plot.
3.c on the farm/report
pretty good scene, introduces some mystery and moves forward to the next scene.
interlude1. flight
trying to give a sense of how the world is overpopulated, but the detail is too minute, and there is no contrast.
interlude1. at the station
random extra blurting out exposition. modern voight-kampf test.
interlude1. apartment
multicultural melting pot copied from the original. more exposition.
4. loneliness/at home
i really should explain how the replicant works as an antagonist, because you don't need to explain anything: he's bad, we're good, kill him. but when you need to identify with a synthetic human, questions spring to mind. why do they need to eat? why do they need to feel emotions? why can they not have a system built in which covers all their psychological needs, like an internal brain drug system? surely if you can make an android WITH emotions, you can make one without?
i did find nice the laser + hologram cigarette lighting things, except that tobacco is a plant. remember the rules you just set for this world without vegetation? and the whole psychologica attachment to a wayfu is weird, more so for a purpose-built machine.
4b. loneliness/rain
man this scene is long and slow and boring
5. after the job/morgue
introducing the partner. copy of the "boring" scene in BR1. why does the mortician say "sorry" ? is he afraid to hurt the feelings of the replicant? again, why do replicants have emotions? emotions serve us, as animals, to make us reproduce and to keep us together, an evolutionary trait that you do not need to build into a machine, more so if you have perfect control over it. the reason the Nexus 6 were made illegal is *exactly* because they developed emotions, when they were meant not to. actors who are supposed to despise replicants keep giving them non-verbal communication, meaning they perceive them as people and not machines, which is bad action or bad writing, you decide.
5. after the job/office
this is what scene 3 was referring to. replicants can reproduce. not a surprise if they can eat. anyway, the point is that if replicants are people-but-made-differently, they they would feasibly have more or less the same human rights that non-replicants do, making the whole "retiring" redundant. on a similar note, gosling must have been told to do the dead stare which is giving mixed messages on how human-like these replicants are. Zhora could hold a better conversation than a replicant two generations down the line.
interlude2. flight
... the film's catchphrase, again.
6. database/reception
that's a cut-up apple keyboard. crappy set. introducing "the blackout"
6b. database/mysterious woman
introducing the antagonist. "you can make them as human as you want them to be".
6c. database/the archive
exposition for the blackout. some nice set transitions. mannequins in the jar suck balls. the skeleton belongs to Rachel from BR1.
6d. database/the antagonist
finally mentions the words slave. nonsensical replicant birth scene. is that Anne Hathaway ? nice butt. horrible villain evil-without-reason that only hollywood could birth.
7. on the street
horrible set with bad extras, makes you appreciate even more how awesome BR1 was.
7b. on the street/pleasure models
"i've never seen a tree before". "you dont like real girls" implies replicants have sex. what exactly would they ejaculate? if they need pleasure, can this not be built it?
8. on the farm/investigating
Rachel had a baby (not exactly a surprise by now). i'm ready to turn this off because i'm bored.
9. morgue
nice death scene.
10. at the station/apartment
why would they need memories if they clearly know they are fake. at this point, we have replicants who feel emotions (while not supposed to), who are essentially cloned humans, yet they have no free will, yet they have free will. i again do not see the point of creating a machine for the purpose of enslaving it, and giving it the very thing that conflicts with enslavement.
10b. at the station/flashback
10c. at the station/birth records
god this film is boring. gosling could be the son of Rachel. gosling's "Alexa" somehow doesn't spy on him.
interlude3. the city
nice jacket. again, these towering visuals do nothing without contrast.
11. San Diego ruins/approach flight
aside from the ludicrous shot, a flying piece of metal does not need help from a kyte to draw lightning. we already have lightning protection on normal airplanes and the thing shorting out the systems is reeeally hard to believe. also, somehow a metal brick without wings can do a controlled landing. why is gosling stunned? these nexus can kill a man with a punch (scene 9) and survive being rammed through a concrete wall (scene 3).
11b. San Diego ruins/scavengers
11c. San Diego ruins/the orphanage
how do they feed these kids? why are they all without hair? nice performance by the slaver though. gosling remembers he lived here. incredibly slow reveal scene.
12. at home
13. the botanist
"happy in a cage" reflects the protagonist. tons of exposition. actually not a bad scene due to the convincing delivery by both actors and a soundtrack that works for this type of emotion.
14. at work/the test
gosling is worth his money here.
14b. at work/going rogue
actually picks up the pace a bit.
15. at home/pleasure girl
again exceedingly long scene, and the hologram girl isn't really important for the film, even though she might be for gosling.
15b. at home/getting ready
again, overtly long and i'm not sure why i'm supposed to care for hologram girl.
interlude3. doctor badger
announcing the final showdown
16. at work
this is a police station, remember? a replicant barges in and attacks a captain. we're also shown that every replicant can be tracked, which means the antagonist just condemned herself to death.
17. the hotel
the pacing in this film is horrid.
17b. the hotel/elvis
not sure why they had Deckard react the way he does. my guess is that they wanted some confrontation to use the tripwires, and then needed to resolve it somehow.
17c. the hotel/answers
why does gosling jump to the conclusion that this guy is Deckhard, his dad, and the husband of Rachel?
18d. the hotel/attack
gosling casually shows how ridiculously strong they are, gets taken out.
interlude4. capture
i like the fire effect
19. la resistance
again, this is not bad. it twists things around a bit. frau blucher is kinda horrid but we'll pass for now.
20. abducted
wasn't this recording wiped in the blackout? also, Ford doesn't remember how to be Deckard. also, and this is really painful, is Wallace convinced that they need Deckard's sperm to generate the new replicants? if anything, it's Rachel that somehow managed to ovulate. Once you got that, *any* human male would do. Besides, these are replicants; you made one, you can surely replicate it?
Ford somehow manages to deliver ONE line convincingly, which is more than i've seen him do in 20 years.
interlude4. the bridge
it's time for our hero to Kick Ass(tm) !
21. on the beach
nice dead scene. it's a shitty climax, because the antagonist and the hero have basically zero interaction, the hero is just trying to kill the antagonist because she wants him dead and she has Deckard, but in no way she personifies the struggle in the character arc of the hero.
22. in the snow
having gosling NOT being Deckard's son is a great move that gives some depth to his character. he's just another replicant, fighting for all the other replicants. no reaosn to rehash "tears in the rain", though.
before closing, i'd like to point out that Wallace and his evil goon replicant have the same interest as the hero; they want to turn replicants from machines into humans. The whole conflict is born out of misunderstanding and could have been resolved in the very opposite direction that it instead was.
in conclusion, not an horrid film, but nowhere near the level of perfection that BR1 had.