Linksys E4200, Asus RT-N56U, SMC, or Buffalo Router?

Nov 29, 2003
61
0
61
My Buffalo router has been dropping wireless signal on and off for a couple weeks. Comcast did have a problem in the area, but when I connect directly to the modem via a hard-wire pc, the signal doesn't drop. I want to head things off before it gets worse. I can't live without a wireless network, so I need a new router.

I work from home to a remote server, but I never access my network remotely. I have as many as three or four notebook pc's connected at one time, but that's rare. Usually there are two at peak operating times with one or two hard-wired pcs as well. There are some other wireless items attached, too, such as a wii.

We do stream media and use VOIP. A print server would be fantastic, but I am considering getting an all-in-once wireless, too.

What would you recommend? It has to be something reliable. I had an SMC Barricade prior to the Buffalo and loved it. I just found it one of those items that was hard to find in my area and decided to give Buffalo a shot. This one hasn't lasted very long, so I'm disappointed.

Thanks in advance for the suggestions.

Edited to add: I do want the ability for MAC filtering.

AC
 

MtnMan

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2004
9,340
8,674
136
Due to the number of wireless devices I was looking for a dual-band router upgrade to an older Buffalo w/DD-WRT.

The advertized features for the Asus RT-N56U looked too good to be true for the price. That proved true, I found it to be very unstable, often doing an imitation of a brick. I couldn't even ping the router from a wired PC. I ended up having to power cycle it every 12 - 24 hours to revive it. It went back before the week was out.

The E4200 sounded good, but $179 was a bit steep. I then found one at Sam's Club that had been returned and marked down to $120. Had it about 3 - 4 weeks now and it has proved stable, wireless performance is great. I also have a 1TB drive connected to it acting as a NAS. Downside is that the USB port can't be used for a printer, if you are looking for that capability.

DD-WRT is also working on a firmware of the E4200, there is a pre-release (they call WIP) for it, but USB port not supported.
 
Last edited:

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
smallnetbuilder.com has tests and reviews on those models.

Almost any should be able to MAC filter.

I have a E4200 and like it a lot. I upgraded from an E3000 and the signal strength is much better. I purchased a refurb directly from their website for $109.

The E4200 has the ability to blacklist or whitelist 32 MAC addresses. The whitelist or blacklist option applies to all, it would have been nice to make it a toggle for each MAC entered and be able to allow some and block others. Still as long as you just white list all known devices that will allow the functionality.
 
Last edited:

zero koopa

Member
Apr 21, 2008
126
1
81
Just picked up a e4200 from BB for 159.99. It runs really hot so much that i put it up on some pieces of wood to keep air flowing underneath. Besides that it has worked flawlessly.
 

alkemyst

No Lifer
Feb 13, 2001
83,769
19
81
Just picked up a e4200 from BB for 159.99. It runs really hot so much that i put it up on some pieces of wood to keep air flowing underneath. Besides that it has worked flawlessly.

heats not necessarily a bad thing, a lot of pro 8 port switches get hot to the touch as well.

They could easily add a fan, but that would just add noise and not aid performance.
 

MtnMan

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2004
9,340
8,674
136
Just picked up a e4200 from BB for 159.99. It runs really hot so much that i put it up on some pieces of wood to keep air flowing underneath. Besides that it has worked flawlessly.
Mine is certainly warm, but I wouldn't call it hot.