• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

lets make this easy.. a quick poll. Propane or Charcoal?

Originally posted by: KLin
biased poll much?

not really? charcoal is a huge PITA, although it tastes better, in my opinion.

propane tastes... different.. subjective about better i suppose, and is WAY easier to deal with
 
Give me King of The Hill over Family Guy or The Simpsons anyday.😛

I love that narrow urethra suffering redneck B4stard. Charcoal though FTW.
 
coal all the way.

if all i got to do is turn a knob and slap on dinner, ill cook on the stove. i grill out 4-5 days a week. good way to give the wife a break, and i dont have to clean up my mess in the kitchen.

besides, i need time to knock back a few beers and BS.
 
Originally posted by: armatron
Originally posted by: KLin
biased poll much?

not really? charcoal is a huge PITA, although it tastes better, in my opinion.

propane tastes... different.. subjective about better i suppose, and is WAY easier to deal with



what? pita? i spend 5 mins on coal. thats dumping, arranging, spreading. about the same time i spend on pulling out pots and pans and planning in the kitchen.

propane is easier though. but taste and enjoyment rules over convenience any day when it comes to cooking.
 
Originally posted by: shimsham
Originally posted by: armatron
Originally posted by: KLin
biased poll much?

not really? charcoal is a huge PITA, although it tastes better, in my opinion.

propane tastes... different.. subjective about better i suppose, and is WAY easier to deal with



what? pita? i spend 5 mins on coal. thats dumping, arranging, spreading. about the same time i spend on pulling out pots and pans and planning in the kitchen.

propane is easier though. but taste and enjoyment rules over convenience any day when it comes to cooking.

what charcoal do you use? some types (just from what I've eaten at friends places) leave food with a... ignitable fluid taste.. like lighter fluid... even though i think it was the type where you dont add lighter fluid? Im assuming maybe he put the food on too early?
 
Originally posted by: armatron
Originally posted by: shimsham
Originally posted by: armatron
Originally posted by: KLin
biased poll much?

not really? charcoal is a huge PITA, although it tastes better, in my opinion.

propane tastes... different.. subjective about better i suppose, and is WAY easier to deal with



what? pita? i spend 5 mins on coal. thats dumping, arranging, spreading. about the same time i spend on pulling out pots and pans and planning in the kitchen.

propane is easier though. but taste and enjoyment rules over convenience any day when it comes to cooking.

what charcoal do you use? some types (just from what I've eaten at friends places) leave food with a... ignitable fluid taste.. like lighter fluid... even though i think it was the type where you dont add lighter fluid? Im assuming maybe he put the food on too early?


any ready light ive ever used had the "gas" taste. speaking out my ass, i think the manufacturers use way too much fluid so they light instantly and easily, like that type of coals are designed to do.

what i use depends on how attentive i can be to the coals. if i dont have much free time (like when im grilling a big dinner for company) to watch the grill, i just some kingston coals. its easier to just look and tell when theyre ready, and it takes slightly longer to cook, giving me more time to socialize.

if i have the time to tend the grill (cooking for the family), i use wood coal. just charred wood really. it lights quicker, burns hotter, and is cheaper. tastes better than charcoal to me, too.
 
What I do to light charcoal is take a propane blowtorch to the charcoal until it glows red. A lot easier to light and tastes great!
 
There is no point in ever useing charcoal. To grill you are better off with propane, BBQ and smoking requires wood.

The reason I use propane to grill is because it is easy, clean, and efficient. I don't have to spend much time preparing and tamping a wood fire for what is going to be at best a half hour cook. With propane I can have a meal prepared in under an hour from start to finish. The only charcoal that I could do that with is the ?easy light bricks? stuff which is treated with chemicals that imparts an undesirable taste on the food and is more expensive then propane. So I get worse taste for more cost. The untreated charcoal is okay and does help the flavor of the food, but to use properly takes almost as much time as using wood and adds no where near the distinct flavor that the different woods can. And remember the quicker the cook, the less important what you cook with is. For quick grilling, propane wins in my book.

Smoking and BBQ is a different story altogether. When I am going to do either I am already dedicating either a full day to cooking (BBQ) or several days (smoking) so I might as well take the time to set up a proper wood burning pit. For either of these charcoal will not do because I am going to be cooking my meat for a long period of time, and that means they will get the benefit of having that real wood flavor. Wood is in most cases not more expensive then non-treated charcoal (there are some types of wood that can be really expensive to cook with, but you shouldn?t be using those woods unless you really know what you are doing) and wood definitely imparts a better flavor, and it only takes about a half hour extra prep time. What is thirty minutes when I am already dedicating at least 20 or so hours to cooking?
 
I have both and use both. They both have their uses, so it's nice to have both available. Having said that, I prefer to use charcoal for most things and probably use it 80% of the time.
 
Originally posted by: leftyman
charcoal for taste...propane for ease and speed

Agreed.
Although, some of the better propane grills have added enough stuff to help the drippings smoke back through the food and add to the flavor.
 
Back
Top