These lists are never useful. It is because the items on the list are biased to begin with.
Think of the typical vehicle commercial:
* Car X has more acceleration than car Y.
That may be true by a miniscule amount, but it ignores the fact that car Y has more features, better handling, bigger capacity, better fuel economy, better towing, more reliable, better looking (albeit that is in the eye of the driver), cheaper, etc.
Whomever makes the list items can make any candidate sound great by only putting the list items that are popular and ignoring the list items that are not popular. So I could make a list that makes Clinton sound angelic and Trump evil. I can also make a list that makes Trump sound angelic and Clinton sound evil.
The lists also have problems with relevancy (a president has no power to do things that are in congress's control by the constitution, but most lists include those irrelevant items in a prominent position). The lists also have problems with scale/precision. Candidate X may have a 90.010 ranking by some entity and candidate Y may have a 90.009 ranking by that entity which is essentially a tie, but the list will put the checkmark next to only candidate X since that candidate was higher.
The list isn't the way to get anywhere unless it is complete, accurate, and unbiased. And asking highly biased people to make a complete, accurate, and unbiased list is foolish. Asking non-biased people and you end up with people who don't care about politics and won't get it complete or accurate and it probably will still end up being biased.
Instead, you need to make your personal list of things that matter only to you. Then you need to fill in the blanks yourself. Vote that way.
For example, to me, no personal characteristic of any candidate makes one bit of difference. A candidate can be the stinkiest scum on the biggest wart of the most foul troll and I will still vote for that candidate if that candidate truly would vote in the way that I think makes the best choice. To others, it is all about personal characteristics and how they will actually change the country means nothing.