lawn mower recommendations for ~1/4 acre?

Tiamat

Lifer
Nov 25, 2003
14,068
5
71
I don't really need a ride-on mower but I want self-propelled.

The variable bagging/mulching feature, as well as good quality motor of Honda HRX series sounds nice to me, although gas mowers are very noisy and obviously require gasoline.

The Ryobi RY14110 is electric, has less features than the Honda, but also costs less than half and is quieter in operation.

Anyone have any thoughts on how to make a decision? While both seem to get good reviews, I am still uncertain which to buy since i don't know what kind of long term issues might arise.

I do like the fumeless, quiet operation that the Ryobi brings to the table, however, I understand the Honda is practically bulletproof.

Thanks!


Update 5/3/2011:

After using the Ryobi once, it was a lemon. Not all 4 wheels would touch the ground at the same time even though the ground was flat (I checked with my level). Also, one of the rear wheels didn't receive power 85% of the time, I'm pretty sure there was something wrong with the gear in the wheel not catching with the motor. Also, the battery (after being conditioned 4 times) still didn't last very long. It took 4 charge sessions to complete the lawn with mild use of the rear wheel motor.

I returned it to Home Depot no questions asked, and picked up the Honda HRX without electric start and without cruise control. The Honda works phenominally. It cuts better, is quite a bit louder, starts on one pull, and the accelerator handle works well for controlling speed. The manual appears to be straight forward about maintanence and easy to follow which is better than I can say for manuals for other devices.

Conclusion: electric mowers just aren't ready to compete with gas mowers in terms of quality. I do note that the Honda cost almost 2x the Ryobi, but, that was only because the market did not have a comparably priced electric mower. Could I have saved money on a similar model from Toro? Probably, but I really like how the Honda does its job, so I don't have any regrets pertaining costs.
 
Last edited:

waggy

No Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
68,143
10
81
i have owned a few Toro's. the newer ones just don't seem as well built.
 

SandEagle

Lifer
Aug 4, 2007
16,809
13
0
lol, even for lawnmowers your input is "buy honda"

i so sorry Bignate, but does GM or Ford build lawnmower motors? maybe they should? my honda lawnmower has been going strong for 6 years. never changed the oil, filter, or plug lol. starts up right every time, even right after winter. great mower engines. i expected nothing less. if Honda made shoes, i'd buy em
 

bruceb

Diamond Member
Aug 20, 2004
8,874
111
106
My first choice has always been Snapper, but I also own 1 Honda OHV motor lawn mower.
Neither one has given any trouble. Only maintenance is yearly oil changes, clean the air filters, check the spark plug. Both are in the 6 HP range.
 

Jumpem

Lifer
Sep 21, 2000
10,757
3
81
i so sorry Bignate, but does GM or Ford build lawnmower motors? maybe they should? my honda lawnmower has been going strong for 6 years. never changed the oil, filter, or plug lol. starts up right every time, even right after winter. great mower engines. i expected nothing less. if Honda made shoes, i'd buy em

My Toro does the same. No maintenance, I abuse it, and it always performs perfectly.
 

PottedMeat

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
12,363
475
126
1/4 acre? get 2 ryobis! :awe:


how about letting the grass die or would the HOA go apeshit?
 

SandEagle

Lifer
Aug 4, 2007
16,809
13
0
I agree, but if you take a look at his posting history he views Honda products as a status symbol. Like these nice little examples below.

are u stalking me? who uses products as status symbols? not me. i like hondas. is that wrong?
 

Tiamat

Lifer
Nov 25, 2003
14,068
5
71
HOA would go apeshit if I didn't mow :p

I have the nicest lawn in the entire neighborhood because it was winter sod so it is very plush and green whereas everyone else has crap grass and dead spots.

This is my first house, so I just want to do everything right the first time.

I can purchase several extra Ryobi 48V batteries before I even hit the price point of the Honda.

But Honda has the bulletproof reputation...


My fiancee is pushing me to get a ride-mower (John Deere) oddly enough, but 1/4 acre lot is just too small for a ride-on mower, plus they cost like 2k$ lol...

sigh...
 

IndyColtsFan

Lifer
Sep 22, 2007
33,655
688
126
Honda is the best from all indications, but they were too expensive for me. I have 2 mowers: one is an old, beat up MTD or something like that (from 1999) that still works and another is a Troy Bilt I bought a couple of years ago. I use the Troy Bilt and it works great and was about half the cost of a Honda. My lawn is about 1/2 acre.
 

lxskllr

No Lifer
Nov 30, 2004
60,550
10,916
126
Christ. 1/4ac?! Use scissors... For something a bit more serious, get a manual reel mower. No gas,oil, or spark plugs, and it starts every time. They do the best job cutting the grass, and you'll get a little bit of exercise. It should take about 1/2 hour to mow 1/4 acre with one of those.
 

Dirigible

Diamond Member
Apr 26, 2006
5,961
32
91
Christ. 1/4ac?! Use scissors... For something a bit more serious, get a manual reel mower. No gas,oil, or spark plugs, and it starts every time. They do the best job cutting the grass, and you'll get a little bit of exercise. It should take about 1/2 hour to mow 1/4 acre with one of those.

Those things are terrible for lazy people like me.

A) I'm lazy. With that thing I gotta push it AND power the blades? To hell with that.

B) I'm lazy. This means I don't mow very often. The grass is TALL when I finally decide to do something about it. With that much grass, gotta take a running start at it. The blades will only cut a couple feet before getting bogged down and stuck. Gotta back up and take another running start. Takes forever and is exhausting to mow.


In conclusion, if you're a lazy person (as all good Americans should be) don't follow lxskllr's advice.
 

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Mar 5, 2001
49,601
167
111
www.slatebrookfarm.com
A $2000 John Deere riding mower is a piece of shit made in China under license by John Deere and sold at a box store, unless you're talking about getting a used riding mower. I've seen some great ones go for about $2k. The problem with riding mowers in box stores is similar to what sort of happened here and there in the digital camera market. With digital cameras, everyone was "ohhhhhh, look at all the megapixels!" So, a few camera makers made cameras with high megapixels and crappy lenses, and all you got were finely detailed blur. Riding mowers went the same way with horsepower. "ohhhh, this riding mower has eleventy hundred HP!" As a result, the box stores are getting more and more horsepower in the motors and cutting corners everywhere else. The mowing decks are getting thinner and thinner, and they're being made from more and more plastic.

Also, in regards to lxskllr's "1/4 hour to mow 1/4 acre with one of those" - It's amusing how people have no clue how big a 1/4 acre is. An acre is roughly the size of a football field (not including the endzones.) A football field is 100 yards by 53 1/3 yards or 5333 square yards. An acre is 4840 square yards. I don't think that 4 guys with reel mowers are going to mow an entire football field in 15 minutes. 4840/4 = 1210 square yards. That means, if you had a 3 foot wide lawnmower, and never had to turn around - could just mow one long 3 foot wide strip equivalent to 1/4 acre, you'd have to walk 1210 yards - more than 2/3 of a mile. The narrower your mower gets, the farther you have to walk. Add in all the turns, and either get a better sense of estimates for areas, else a riding mower. Get an older, used one. The new ones are crap.