Latest sensationalized health threat: enterovirus 68

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

SunnyD

Belgian Waffler
Jan 2, 2001
32,674
145
106
www.neftastic.com
There's a difference between reporting on, and sensationalizing. Note the article linked above - FIRST CHILD...

Since the day I started this thread, how many children have died in car accidents? How many children have die in bike accidents? How many children have died while playing football? And now, 1st kid dies of this particularly severe cold (according to those bold headlines.)

Getting sick isn't a laughing matter, and since I started this thread, Ebola (1 death in this entire country) has completely dominated the headlines. And, it has been sensationalized to hell and back for the sake of news ratings.

Dying in car accidents and bike accidents have been happening since whenever cars and bikes became mainstream. We've become numb to them.

Dying while playing football, let's see, I think that was just sensationalized in the capital region of NYS fairly recently was it not?

But zomg new virus that is taking out susceptible children and spreading across the country! Now THAT'S newsworthy, and the fact that it is capable of doing some lasting damage and/or killing children is particularly concerning too. Especially, since you know - it's just a virus, can't we just slap together a vaccine or drug and make it go away? Right? Right...? :sneaky:
 

MarkXIX

Platinum Member
Jan 3, 2010
2,642
1
71
Dying in car accidents and bike accidents have been happening since whenever cars and bikes became mainstream. We've become numb to them.

Dying while playing football, let's see, I think that was just sensationalized in the capital region of NYS fairly recently was it not?

But zomg new virus that is taking out susceptible children and spreading across the country! Now THAT'S newsworthy, and the fact that it is capable of doing some lasting damage and/or killing children is particularly concerning too. Especially, since you know - it's just a virus, can't we just slap together a vaccine or drug and make it go away? Right? Right...? :sneaky:

Reminds me of an argument I got into with one of my wife's university interns before I went to Afghanistan last year.

She was all worried about me dying in combat so I told her she was more likely to die in a car accident than I was in a modern war zone. She refused to believe it, so I sent her statistics. She still refused to believe it....
 

yuchai

Senior member
Aug 24, 2004
980
2
76
There's a difference between reporting on, and sensationalizing. Note the article linked above - FIRST CHILD...

Since the day I started this thread, how many children have died in car accidents? How many children have die in bike accidents? How many children have died while playing football? And now, 1st kid dies of this particularly severe cold (according to those bold headlines.)

Getting sick isn't a laughing matter, and since I started this thread, Ebola (1 death in this entire country) has completely dominated the headlines. And, it has been sensationalized to hell and back for the sake of news ratings.

Maybe there's some sensationalizing, but I don't think a disease should only get attention if it kills a lot of people. If this thing ends up sending a lot of kids to intensive care, it does deserve attention since it would create a real economic impact and may even affect capacity of hospitals or other care facilities.
 

rudeguy

Lifer
Dec 27, 2001
47,351
14
61
There's a difference between reporting on, and sensationalizing. Note the article linked above - FIRST CHILD...

Since the day I started this thread, how many children have died in car accidents? How many children have die in bike accidents? How many children have died while playing football? And now, 1st kid dies of this particularly severe cold (according to those bold headlines.)

Getting sick isn't a laughing matter, and since I started this thread, Ebola (1 death in this entire country) has completely dominated the headlines. And, it has been sensationalized to hell and back for the sake of news ratings.

How many kids should die before it's reported in the media?

I don't know what's up with you lately doc but that isn't right. Retorting on an issue that is a direct threat to my sons life is fine with me.

Step away from the TV or the radio or whatever has your thinking so messed up
 

Red Squirrel

No Lifer
May 24, 2003
68,332
12,559
126
www.anyf.ca
At this point this one is probably even worse than Ebola since nobody really knows the source yet and there's already been a few deaths. It's odd that it's only affecting children. Maybe adults have stronger immune systems? You'd think they'd still get sick though.

I don't know if it's as contagious as Ebola though. Ebola is highly contagious and has a high death rate which is what makes it so dangerous.
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,213
5,794
126
For the last week I have had the worst Cold in years. 1 of the days I swear I had to empty the contents of my nasal passages every 10-20 minutes during the entire day. It was as if my whole being was nothing but a mucous factory. :S

Thought has crossed my mind that it might be this Virus, but I have no way of knowing.
 

Gibsons

Lifer
Aug 14, 2001
12,530
35
91
At this point this one is probably even worse than Ebola since nobody really knows the source yet and there's already been a few deaths. It's odd that it's only affecting children. Maybe adults have stronger immune systems? You'd think they'd still get sick though.
For one possible explanation, look at RSV. The throat swells in both children and adults, but children have a more difficult time mostly because they have a narrower (and thus easier to obstruct) trachea.

Yes, there are quite a few other plausible explanations.
 

Mai72

Lifer
Sep 12, 2012
11,562
1,741
126
Meh.

I remember when children would work the coal mines at night. Wimps.
 

GlacierFreeze

Golden Member
May 23, 2005
1,125
1
0
I don't really understand the problem with the article or see the "sensationalization"

It's sensationalism if it's reported on and hasn't (yet) killed as many people as car wrecks, cancer, etc. in a week's time.

Similar to people wanting to be proactive against Ebola and be accused of wanting to spread mass panic. lol geeeez

When it kills hundreds of thousands of people then we can worry about doing something or even reporting on these things.
 
Last edited:

rudeguy

Lifer
Dec 27, 2001
47,351
14
61
It's sensationalism if it's reported on and hasn't (yet) killed as many people as car wrecks, cancer, etc. in a week's time.

Similar to people wanting to be proactive against Ebola and be accused of wanting to spread mass panic. lol geeeez

When it kills hundreds of thousands of people then we can worry about doing something or even reporting on these things.

Yea I'm normally the one bashing the media for all the hype. But this shit really is dangerous and it has killed children. I don't have a problem with it. But then again I don't read the news 4 times a day, listen to it on the radio, watch the news or any of that. I get 10 minutes worth of local news on my way into work and that is fine for me.

I really think people need to break away from the news a bit more.
 

manimal

Lifer
Mar 30, 2007
13,559
8
0
Yea I'm normally the one bashing the media for all the hype. But this shit really is dangerous and it has killed children. I don't have a problem with it. But then again I don't read the news 4 times a day, listen to it on the radio, watch the news or any of that. I get 10 minutes worth of local news on my way into work and that is fine for me.

I really think people need to break away from the news a bit more.



yup



Dr OP needs to change the title.
 

CZroe

Lifer
Jun 24, 2001
24,195
857
126
As a libertarian, I am disappointed to see both the left and right politicizing Ebola. If Obama does something big and public to address it which would satisfy the right's supposed expectations, then he is guilty of "distraction politics" over an issue that doesn't particularly concern us. If he does what he can discretely and behind the scenes without making a big deal out of it, then he is "lacking leadership" on the issue that concerns us all.

If it's true that Enterovirus D68 crossed the border with immigrant Guatemalan children and the administration is covering it up because that is bad for them politically, shame on them, but don't try to politicize that angle before you have anything backing it up. Similarly, don't try to spin Ebola into a border debate. Shame.

Calling on Obama to institute a travel ban is ridiculous. We've had almost as many cases as Nigeria. If everyone followed our lead and banned travel from countries with Ebola from the recent outbreak then we ourselves would need to be banned from traveling to the rest of the world. Get a grip and stop using that angle to attack the president and his administration. Let the agencies whose job it is take care of that.

Now, all this talk about him putting friends and political hacks with no credentials in charge of such matters IS worth talking about, but they have been taking this WAY too far (especially Sean Hannity).

The left talking about the right cutting funds for NIH and CDC isn't making matters better either. Al Sharpton trying to find a racism angle is despicable. Both sides need to be slapped because this is a bipartisan issue.
 

Exterous

Super Moderator
Jun 20, 2006
20,471
3,589
126
yup



Dr OP needs to change the title.

Well, to be fair the coverage has dropped off the face of the planet now that Ebola is here. I completely see his point. I was so critical that enterovirus 68 needed daily 'Breaking News!' updates but since Ebola hit I have not seen a single update on enterovirus 68 on CNN or GMA in the morning. Ebola is scarier and makes better news than something that is actually getting a few people sick
 
Nov 3, 2004
10,491
22
81
It's sensationalism if it's reported on and hasn't (yet) killed as many people as car wrecks, cancer, etc. in a week's time.

Similar to people wanting to be proactive against Ebola and be accused of wanting to spread mass panic. lol geeeez

When it kills hundreds of thousands of people then we can worry about doing something or even reporting on these things.

But everyone is already aware of cancer and car wrecks so it's not exactly news or needy of public awareness. Several hundred people (mostly kids) are infected and it's important for both parents and health care providers to be aware of it so that appropriate treatment can be administered quickly.
 

GlacierFreeze

Golden Member
May 23, 2005
1,125
1
0
But everyone is already aware of cancer and car wrecks so it's not exactly news or needy of public awareness.

Yeah everyone does know but some bring it every time something is mentioned about another thing as if no one should talk about it or do anything at all. Pretty naive and short sighted if you ask me.