Just went from AL MX5021's to Logitech Z-2300's: *shocked* by the difference!

Haphazard

Member
Jan 21, 2001
75
0
0
I have an 80/20 music/games listening profile and had been using Altec Lansing MX5021's for the past few years. Admittedly, the AL's were an absolute pleasure to listen to ... save for a mild hiss audible in quiet surroundings that was a minor bother at best. So, after reading raves about the Z-2300's (particularly CNet's review), I decided to bring them in as a replacement ... hoping, of course, for better than AL's quality minus the hiss.

The Z-2300's arrived yesterday and I must say, I'm absolutely stunned and horrified by the sound quality! Compared to the MX5021's, the Z-2300's sound like they are under water. The entire midrange is simply absent ... zero ... nada ... not even a hint ... even after hours of tweaking with an equalizer. The sub has too low a cross-over and puts out massive amounts of bass ... all of it sloppy! I am having a very hard time imagining what people have been raving about with these. I am far from being an audiophile, but these things are simply intolerable. They are going straight up on eBay!

Which leaves me in a bind. The AL's are gone, and I am left with limited options for a quality 2.1 set. The Klipsch 2.1 Promedia's would seem to be a natural choice at this stage, but I'd rather have some of the newer amenities ... like a wired remote, etc.

Folks, what are my options? What are some good 2.1 sets out there these days.

Also, what would be the next level up from Klipsch/Logitech/etc. for a quality 2.1 setup?
 

LOUISSSSS

Diamond Member
Dec 5, 2005
8,770
54
91
Originally posted by: Haphazard
I have an 80/20 music/games listening profile and had been using Altec Lansing MX5021's for the past few years. Admittedly, the AL's were an absolute pleasure to listen to ... save for a mild hiss audible in quiet surroundings that was a minor bother at best. So, after reading raves about the Z-2300's (particularly CNet's review), I decided to bring them in as a replacement ... hoping, of course, for better than AL's quality minus the hiss.

The Z-2300's arrived yesterday and I must say, I'm absolutely stunned and horrified by the sound quality! Compared to the MX5021's, the Z-2300's sound like they are under water. The entire midrange is simply absent ... zero ... nada ... not even a hint ... even after hours of tweaking with an equalizer. The sub has too low a cross-over and puts out massive amounts of bass ... all of it sloppy! I am having a very hard time imagining what people have been raving about with these. I am far from being an audiophile, but these things are simply intolerable. They are going straight up on eBay!

Which leaves me in a bind. The AL's are gone, and I am left with limited options for a quality 2.1 set. The Klipsch 2.1 Promedia's would seem to be a natural choice at this stage, but I'd rather have some of the newer amenities ... like a wired remote, etc.

Folks, what are my options? What are some good 2.1 sets out there these days.

Also, what would be the next level up from Klipsch/Logitech/etc. for a quality 2.1 setup?

QFTQFT!

i wasn't happy with the z-2300's either. they lacked ALL mid-range sounds. and the listener was left with squeaky annoying highs and boomy inaccurate bass.

i sold them for a set of M-Audio LX4's and they are much MUCH better.
 

yhelothar

Lifer
Dec 11, 2002
18,409
39
91
Yeah MX5021 are definitely better, and they cost more to boot. Altecs are known to be more musical anyways.

Logitechs are more known for loud, powerful sound for gamers.

If you're really serious about musical quality, get yourself a set of entry level powered monitors
http://www.audioengineusa.com/
The A2, I hear, are very highly acclaimed at the $199 pricepoint.