Let's put it this way:
If Star Wars came out now, (assuming the trilogy didn't exist before now), all you Star Wars die-hards would be pissed off about Chewbacca. WTF? A big hairy teddy bear that is OBVIOUSLY retarded and annoys you through the whole movie with his castrated growls. You would be SERIOUSLY annoyed. --But kids would find it endearing. --As you did.
If Empire came out after it, all you Star Wars die-hards would be pissed off about Yoda. WTF? A little green muppet with Grover's voice who speaks words in backwards order?!?! HOW ANNOYING!!! --BUT KIDS WOLD LOVE HIM, AS YOU DID.
Then, Return of the Jedi.... Dear Lord. Lucas has REALLY done it this time! He has destroyed the whole series! A BIG SLUG with a laughing gremlin companion? THAT THING SHOULD NOT have been in the movie. --And don't even GET ME STARTED on the race of jibberish-speaking teddy bears! WHO ARE THESE MOVIES FOR ANYWAY?!?! KIDS? Hmmmmm.....
And let's just pause and think of the OTHER characters in the movies: Robots that do nothing but offer comic relief with their slapstick interaction, little desert-dwelling elves or munhkins who shout cute little sayings in kid voices, funny-looking aliens that remind us of muppets, and what about all the characters like storm-troopers and bounty-hunters that look LITERALLY JUST LIKE PLASTIC ACTION FIGURES? DO you think those figures look like that for any particular reason? Hmmmmmm......
Star Wars movies are children's movies. Jar-Jar is a children's character. No better, no worse than any other in the series.
Ricky
DesignDawg