Fire kills 3 in Seton Hall dorm prone to false alarms
By Mary Jo Patterson Star-Ledger Staff
A small but intense fire sent acrid black smoke through a freshman dormitory at Seton Hall University in South Orange before dawn yesterday, killing three students and sending hundreds of others on a flight for their lives.
Fifty-eight students were injured, four critically, by the flames and thick smoke that billowed from a third-floor lounge. The smoke blinded and choked 18- and 19-year-olds as they felt their way, or crawled, to stairwells. Others, terrorized, remained in their rooms, crying and begging for help. At least one jumped from his window before firefighters could extend rescue ladders.
Nearly a score of false alarms in recent weeks had caused many students to disregard the fire alarm at first. Then, as the smoke filled the building, they realized this was no prank. ??I heard people screaming. . . . ?This one?s for real! This one?s for real!?? said Jason Esposito, a resident of the dormitory, Boland Hall.
Alison Liptak was one of those who discounted the alert. ?I just thought it was another false alarm. I just laid there, kind of ignoring it, until I heard someone running down the hall,? said Liptak, 18, of Clifton. The pajamas-clad freshman escaped from her fourth-floor room to find another horror scene outside. She looked up to see students leaning out windows, pleading for help.
As of early this morning, investigators had not pinpointed the cause of the fire, but they had ruled out careless smoking and faulty electrical wiring.
Authorities identified the three dead students as John Giunta of Vineland, Aaron Karol of Green Brook and Frank Caltabilota of West Long Branch. Two of the three were found in the lounge, burned beyond recognition, according to sources at the scene. The third, whom fellow students tried to revive, was found in a bedroom nearby.
The most seriously injured were three of 12 victims admitted to the burn unit of Saint Barnabas Medical Center in Livingston, and one victim at University Hospital in Newark.
By day?s end, 45 students had been treated and released from seven area hospitals, most suffering from smoke inhalation.
The six-story Boland Hall - built in 1952 as the university?s first dormitory - is home to 600 Seton Hall freshmen.
University officials said that 18 false alarms had been registered at the 350-room structure since Sept. 1, fewer than in previous years. Still, a number of students buried their heads in their pillows at the sound of the alarm. ?I didn?t think anything of it. We?ve had fire alarms going off all the time during finals week, and I figured, ?More of the same,?? said Tom Semko of Howell.
Hellish sights and sounds confronted fleeing students.
Anthony Neis, an 18-year-old from Staten Island, passed a young man who was clad only in shorts, covered with burns, and moaning. ?He must have been in such pain,? said Neis, who escaped unharmed.
Carrie Fleisher, a freshman from Hillsborough, saw a teenager on fire. ?He was totally blackened. Some kids were hitting him with a jacket. He was conscious and hitting himself, too,? she said. Jumping from the ledge Outside, one teenager hung by his hands from a window sill. Another, Nicholas Donato, a 6-foot-1 freshman, walked to his window ledge and jumped, breaking an ankle and wrist.
Yatin Patel, 19, of Jersey City, trapped in his room, heaved mattresses out his window, with his roommate?s help. Paralyzed with fear, he was standing at the window, contemplating jumping, when a firefighter burst into the room. Patel wet a sock, put it over his mouth and nose and - grabbing the kneeling fireman?s left leg - began to crawl out into the corridor. His roommate held Patel?s leg in turn and crawled behind them. The trio moved slowly through the darkness, under flames licking from ceiling tiles, to a stairwell.
Down the hall, Virginia Wannamaker dialed 911 on her cell phone as she waited in fear with her roommate. The 18-year-old from Irvington heeded the advice of the fire dispatcher, stuffing a comforter under the door and sealing it tight with packing tape. They opened windows and turned on a fan.
South Orange fire sources said they were alerted to the fire at 4:28 a.m. by the college?s public safety department and had the fire under control by approximately 4:45 a.m. Officials on the scene could not pinpoint exactly when the blaze started, however. Seven other municipalities also responded to the general alarm fire.
University officials said the building?s occupants included 18 paid resident assistants, one priest and four professional staffers. In the event of a fire, resident assistants are to knock on every door, said Lisa Grider, a spokeswoman for Seton Hall. South Orange firefighters conducted an extensive primary search of the dorm, followed by two more, she added.
Still, two freshmen slept through the entire ordeal undetected and emerged unscathed hours later, at 2 p.m.