I have to admit, I like it. The previews made me think it was a comedy about band camp or something..and I was mildly dismayed to see it was a drama. But it has a good hook.
Some thoughts:
- You have to appreciate marching bands / music to like this movie. Having spent countless hours watching the USC marching band practice at all hours of the day I can relate to this movie.
- You have to appreciate black culture. It's a very racially themed movie. If the closest you've come to a black person is watching the Cosby show, you'll probably not "get" it.
- Plot is cliche'd. Nothing we haven't seen before. Very unclimactic ending IMO.
- Character development, sound design, and super editing more than make up for it. Great screenwriting too.
- There are some fantastic music sound-off sequences. I can see myself fast forwarding to some of them like I do with fight scenes in kung-fu movies.
Thank goodness I'm not alone:
77% Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes
Some thoughts:
- You have to appreciate marching bands / music to like this movie. Having spent countless hours watching the USC marching band practice at all hours of the day I can relate to this movie.
- You have to appreciate black culture. It's a very racially themed movie. If the closest you've come to a black person is watching the Cosby show, you'll probably not "get" it.
- Plot is cliche'd. Nothing we haven't seen before. Very unclimactic ending IMO.
- Character development, sound design, and super editing more than make up for it. Great screenwriting too.
- There are some fantastic music sound-off sequences. I can see myself fast forwarding to some of them like I do with fight scenes in kung-fu movies.
Thank goodness I'm not alone:
77% Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes