[Jerk just looking for another excuse to bash Christians and Christianity ends up showing his eagerness by jumping too soon.]
The ladies must love you.
It was a stupid joke and he called it out. Seriously. WTF is so funny about it, especially when even the basic premise that sets up the FAIL of a punchline is so flawed? The "slightly different" part obviously is because we all look different from each other, but it's pretty damn stupid to think "in his image" ever meant anything so specific. It's like kindergarten joke... and YOU thought it was JHC-worthy.
Edit: Dammit. He responded himself while I wrote that.