Is this ROCK solid Stable........??

neoro

Member
Oct 31, 2002
89
0
0
Hi, there
I plan to get myself the following system..........

Pentium 4 2.53Ghz 533
Asus P4S8X
Gainward GeFroce 4 Ti4600
2x512MB DDR 333
Western DIgital SE 80GB

~yeah, i know its a intel.....

1)I do not plan to overclock... just a machine primarily for the purpose of Gaming...
Are the specs above stable enough........ or is there any component which can be replaced to make it more stable....

2)Whats the best GeForce 4 card now... I dont think i am opting for Radeon 9700 coz' it seems to have a lot of problem with the Asus Motherboard. Are there any motherboard out there that works well with Radeon 9700 pro. Would updating the bios and drivers slove this problem.......... -> anyone........ Asus P4S8X + Radeon 9700 Pro............

 

CrazySaint

Platinum Member
May 3, 2002
2,441
0
0
Yes, it should be extremely stable. As for the 9700 Pro having issues with that board, I think the only issue it had to do with running it in 8X AGP mode (which provides NO performance increase, btw) and AFAIK those issues have been completely resolved by now. Btw, you might consider waiting 2-3 weeks and getting a DC DDR motherboard which should be ~ 10-15% faster than than SC DDR.
 

Adul

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
32,999
44
91
danny.tangtam.com
Originally posted by: CrazySaint
Yes, it should be extremely stable. As for the 9700 Pro having issues with that board, I think the only issue it had to do with running it in 8X AGP mode (which provides NO performance increase, btw) and AFAIK those issues have been completely resolved by now. Btw, you might consider waiting 2-3 weeks and getting a DC DDR motherboard which should be ~ 10-15% faster than than SC DDR.

we just have to wonder what the cost mayb
 

neoro

Member
Oct 31, 2002
89
0
0
hmmmm.......
got to agree with the dc ddr now......
went to forums at http://www.asusboards.com/ and most of them says the board is shit....!
oh well........
maybe i will wait a little more for
P4SDX............ :)

when do you think this boards will make it to the market.......

well as for that I have got another question...
If cash would to be a Limiting factor
If i would to stick to the 2x512 DDR 333 c2.5
will i NOTICE any difference...... or its time to gear up with Crucial XMS........

10-15%........?? How much is that.....
Can i Notice it in Games........
 

neoro

Member
Oct 31, 2002
89
0
0
p4pe
I might consider that......
only now....
i am planning to wait until mid november or early december and hopefully the New mobos with Dual Channel DDR comes out......
by that time i think the price of these boards should come down a little.
 

Insidious

Diamond Member
Oct 25, 2001
7,649
0
0
If the drool at the corner of my mouth is any indication, that is gonna be a sweetie!

Your biggest stability factor is going to be relative to the OS you run. I've been having
good luck with XP. (just don't try to tweak it to death until/unless you are very familiar with it.)

(edit: I've been eyeing the P4PE)
 

neoro

Member
Oct 31, 2002
89
0
0
All right then.... The P4PE it is then.........
But i am only free to get the stuff in DEcember.....
Do you guys think by then the Dual Channel DDR Mobos will be out in the market........
If so... should i go for that instead of the p4pe......??
 

RIGorous1

Platinum Member
Oct 26, 2002
2,053
0
71
also another thing to keep in mind for stability is cooling .... yeah you've got great parts that don't seem to have any known conflictions, but true stability in the long run is all about what you put those good parts in... Heat has always been a factor of stability.

For example I used to run my rig on a steel case with 2 80mm fans and 2 system blowers. However... periodically I'd get crashes when running games like medal of honor with every graphic feature turned on. I couldn't figure out what the hell the problem was because everything about my rig seemed fine, so I scapegoated XP as the culprit. Recently I've switched my case to an aluminum full server tower similiar to the antec 1040 which I got here on AT with large side window for 84 shipped and crashes are no longer seen.

Also I put in 2 vantec stealth's, 2 Y-S tech manual RPM fans, and an antec 3 led fan... I have a total of 10 fans in my computer all high quality and stable cpu temps are 35C with my case never exceeding 32C. Truly a frozen RIG. :)
 

KF

Golden Member
Dec 3, 1999
1,371
0
0
Originally posted by: Insane3D
OMG!! You're gonna use Intel and expect stability?!?!? No WAY!! :p

;)

;)

Seriously neoro- you want maximum stability? Don't get a mobo until it has been around (for sale) 3 months. Run one stick of memory (unless the chipset has two memory controllers) which has the minimum number of chips (probably 8). Run the motherboard at conservative memory settings below what the memory is rated at. Underclock. Don't run anything that uses AGP - or better, use a PCI video card. Get on-board sound, or none. Use drivers that are one step back (as long as they work OK.) Put a big heatsink on the CPU that runs the loudest 80mm fan you can find. Leave the case open and hang an 120mm fan directed at the CPU and the video card.

Since you are a gamer (evidently), you are going to have to compromise. As best as I can tell, the extreme gamers run their system on the bloody edge of insanity (to get the max frame rate.) They OC to an extent that they require a new processor every few months (no problem) due to overvoltage. If you back off from that some, you can probably get a system the crashes due to hardware a couple of times a month or less. Since the typical game crashes more often than that due to software bugs (once they get it to work at all), that should be acceptable.

Some gratuitous advice: Do not blow the budget to get your dream system. In six months it will look sick compared to the new stuff, you will be out of money, and feel like an idiot.
 

Insidious

Diamond Member
Oct 25, 2001
7,649
0
0
Originally posted by: KF
Originally posted by: Insane3D
OMG!! You're gonna use Intel and expect stability?!?!? No WAY!! :p

;)

;)

Seriously neoro- you want maximum stability? Don't get a mobo until it has been around (for sale) 3 months. Run one stick of memory (unless the chipset has two memory controllers) which has the minimum number of chips (probably 8). Run the motherboard at conservative memory settings below what the memory is rated at. Underclock. Don't run anything that uses AGP - or better, use a PCI video card. Get on-board sound, or none. Use drivers that are one step back (as long as they work OK.) Put a big heatsink on the CPU that runs the loudest 80mm fan you can find. Leave the case open and hang an 120mm fan directed at the CPU and the video card.

Since you are a gamer (evidently), you are going to have to compromise. As best as I can tell, the extreme gamers run their system on the bloody edge of insanity (to get the max frame rate.) They OC to an extent that they require a new processor every few months (no problem) due to overvoltage. If you back off from that some, you can probably get a system the crashes due to hardware a couple of times a month or less. Since the typical game crashes more often than that due to software bugs (once they get it to work at all), that should be acceptable.

Some gratuitous advice: Do not blow the budget to get your dream system. In six months it will look sick compared to the new stuff, you will be out of money, and feel like an idiot.



OMG...... Still laughing
rolleye.gif

 

Wolfsraider

Diamond Member
Jan 27, 2002
8,305
0
76
Originally posted by: KF
Originally posted by: Insane3D
OMG!! You're gonna use Intel and expect stability?!?!? No WAY!! :p

;)

;)

Seriously neoro- you want maximum stability? Don't get a mobo until it has been around (for sale) 3 months. Run one stick of memory (unless the chipset has two memory controllers) which has the minimum number of chips (probably 8). Run the motherboard at conservative memory settings below what the memory is rated at. Underclock. Don't run anything that uses AGP - or better, use a PCI video card. Get on-board sound, or none. Use drivers that are one step back (as long as they work OK.) Put a big heatsink on the CPU that runs the loudest 80mm fan you can find. Leave the case open and hang an 120mm fan directed at the CPU and the video card.

Since you are a gamer (evidently), you are going to have to compromise. As best as I can tell, the extreme gamers run their system on the bloody edge of insanity (to get the max frame rate.) They OC to an extent that they require a new processor every few months (no problem) due to overvoltage. If you back off from that some, you can probably get a system the crashes due to hardware a couple of times a month or less. Since the typical game crashes more often than that due to software bugs (once they get it to work at all), that should be acceptable.

Some gratuitous advice: Do not blow the budget to get your dream system. In six months it will look sick compared to the new stuff, you will be out of money, and feel like an idiot.

where are you getting this bs?
what would you have us do buy cheap and when it won't play the games we want, buy again?no thanks
the reason i buy the best available is, i don't have to wait to get the best.
i will use it until forced to upgrade in 3 years and spend less time time trying to figure out what bottle neck i have that prevents game"x" from running.

my rig is not a pci video ladden, underclocked, undervolted, piece of unprocessing power.
if i was to do all of the mods you suggest,wouldn't that be like throwing my computing money away?maybe i just need a p3 550 and a matrox millenium video card etc...try running ut2003 on that lol

at stock speeds:the proper drivers, proper cooling,your rig should be stable,compromising quality parts will affect this of course(akin to buying a ferrari and trying to put a jet engine in it:Q while it may seem like a smart thing to do odds are it would wreak havok with the slower parts)
but for the majority of gamers who do overclock, stability is the determining factor of enough is enough.

what good would an overclock be if you had to put up with crashes and instability?
i also use my computer for things other than gaming without stability issues,such as ripping dvd's,recording music,editing video...would i be happy with my "rig" if it caused me to redo the same proceedure over again if it wasn't stable?no

maybe this works for you but i highly doubt there are many that would be happy with a machine with your specs as stated above.
is this the type of machine you play games on?

neoro:you should be fine.there are some boards that won't run two sticks of ram overclocked but will run them at stock speed.

hth
mike
 

dszd0g

Golden Member
Jun 14, 2000
1,226
0
0
The Asus P4S8X is the main Asus board to avoid from what I hear, it is utter crap.

The P4PE is looking good, but it's too new to say with absolute certainty. As has been said, if you want guarenteed stability it is best not to buy a motherboard until it has been out a few months. Most users seem quite happy with it. A lot of users onboard sound stops working above 150FSB if you care about that.

What brand/model memory are you getting?
 

sandorski

No Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
70,674
6,246
126
Should be stable, but you can't really know until you slap it together and try it out. :)
 

neoro

Member
Oct 31, 2002
89
0
0
Kingston C2.5..........

if i am not into overclocking is it necessary to get the Top Performance Rams......
XMS C2??

I have not seen a review on the Normal Gainward 750...
Most of the reviews i see are the ones that are the Gold Sample....
Anyone with a Normal Gainward GF4TI4600 and not the gold sample......
How does the card perform........

 

dszd0g

Golden Member
Jun 14, 2000
1,226
0
0
Originally posted by: neoro
Kingston C2.5..........

if i am not into overclocking is it necessary to get the Top Performance Rams......
XMS C2??

FAQ: What does CAS2 and CAS3 RAM mean?

CAS makes a difference whether one is overclocking or not.

If you want to see the Sandra Memory performance difference between 2.5 and 2 on my A7V8X system:
A7V8X SiSoft Sandra

2015 vs. 2046, or about 1.5% difference in memory performance. That was on an AMD system, the difference may be more on a Pentium system where memory performance is more important.
 

neoro

Member
Oct 31, 2002
89
0
0
dszd0g.....

Whats the brand of you RAM.....
is c2.5 Kingston or Apacer ok..?.. the price seems to be more reasonable compared to Crucial
 

dszd0g

Golden Member
Jun 14, 2000
1,226
0
0
I use Corsair XMS, which is not one of the cheapest. Samsung Original is also popular on these and other forums I read. Crucial (Micron) is one of the better brands, but I don't see it overclocking as high as Samsung Original or Corsair XMS.

I have never heard of Apacer. Kingston is in the middle, IMO. But if you aren't planning on overclocking, I doubt you will have any problem. Some people even have good experiences overclocking with it. I really can't say don't get it or anything. I just personally think Corsair or Samsung Original is better, but get what your budget dictates. Just don't get generic memory or a brand most people haven't heard of. For example, I haven't heard of Apacer, thus I wouldn't get it. I just checked a few stores I frequent (online and in person's Web sites) and none of them carry it. Maybe someone else will speak up on that brand.

Mushkin was considered one of the best for a while, but they seem to have fallen a little behind in overclocking. They are still a good brand, though.

This is just based on personal experience and the threads I have followed. Other peoples opinions will vary.

I personally go with CL2 as for the difference in price I think it is worth the performance improvement. I really don't have a strong opinion as far as which (good) brand goes if you aren't planning on overclocking -- I doubt it will make any real difference. You would probably be much better off going with Kingston CL2, than Crucial CL2.5. Although that isn't an option as far as I can tell, Kingston seems to be behind and I haven't seen any Kingston CL2 memory above PC2100.
 

Duvie

Elite Member
Feb 5, 2001
16,215
0
71
Th dual channel DDR mobos (nicknamed Granite Bay for the iNtel chipset) should be available by mid Nov so it should be available though relatively immature by December...Wait to see the reviews....